Animosity Between Surgeons And Anesthesiologists??

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

HEME-ONC

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
May 24, 2003
Messages
119
Reaction score
0
I have been hearing alot in regards to the fact that anesthesiologist have to take a lot of ridicule, in and out of the OR, by surgeons. Will anyone comment on this?
THanks
 
I'm curious about this myself. During my third year surgery clerkship, anes. seemed to get pushed around. I don't mind raising the table now and then, but I have no intention of taking orders from them. I remember seeing one major fight over when a patient should be extubated. I guess I'll find out more on my fourth year rotation.
 
Post this on the Surgery forum if you want both sides of the story.
 
i think there will always be animosity between surgery as long as there are incompetent surgeons/anesthesiologists.... when you are in the OR with a surgeon who respects the anesthesiologist and the anesthesiologist respects the surgeon, then you will see there are no issues whatsoever.

However some of the misunderstandings of our field relate to perceptions... It is very easy for everybody to see what the surgeons are doing - but it isn't always clear to everybody what the anesthesiologist is managing by preventing certain complications that haven't happened yet....

About surgeons ridiculing anesthesia outside of the OR - surgeons will ridicule everybody because they can... Just like any specialty will ridicule other specialties, it is just part of the nature of the beast. It is always easier to rehash old stories of unfortunate events in the hands of another specialty, to make yourself feel better.
 
Where I work, we generally have a good working relationship with the anesthesiologists. I suppose that's because we more than other surgeons (generalizing, of course) have a greater appreciation for the airway and management of a potentially tenuous airway. Additionally, even though we are quite busy in general, I think we're typically one of the more relaxed specialties.

On the other hand, when we're operating on the ear -- from things to tympanostomy tubes to stapedectomies -- we get really upset with anesthesia when the patient's anesthesia isn't adequate, they bump the table, etc.

Other situations are intbation and extubation. With our head and neck patients, it's often painful to watch an anesthesiologist intubate them. And often, they don't want to extubate when we think it's safe; this infrequently leads to arguments.

But as I said, we typically get along pretty well. When they run the SICU, well, that's another story...
 
neutropeniaboy said:
But as I said, we typically get along pretty well. When they run the SICU, well, that's another story...

Actually, if you don't mind, neutropeniaboy, I'm curious to hear the SICU side of the story, becuase I'm looking at programs where anesthesia runs the ICUs. Please share. . .
 
HEME-ONC said:
I have been hearing alot in regards to the fact that anesthesiologist have to take a lot of ridicule, in and out of the OR, by surgeons. Will anyone comment on this?
THanks

I am a practicing anesthesiologist and can tell you that you accept as much ridicule as you'll tolerate. I for one would never allow a surgeon to ridicule me. We are both physicians and on equal footing. I've had a few try to ridicule me............bad mistake on their part! 🙂
 
While I was doing my Anesthesiology elective, and watching the general surgeons try and pass blame on everything and anything to the Anesthesiologist, and then the Anesthesiologist slamming something down, and looking like "oops, did I do that" and then the Surgeon backs off, this is very entertaining indeed.... but its hard when the Surgeon picks on the first or second year Anesthesiology resident (easy prey as the vultures swoop down to the innocent unsuspecting victim).. "hey you, can you please keep MY patients blood pressure down and do YOURE job properly?" and then the Anesthesiology attending intervenes, "hey, we will take care of THIS side, lets just make sure that YOURE side is ok" and then there is a mutual respect for one another... man its terrible, and it is NEVER THE ANESTHESIOLOGIST instigating the bickering.. its always the Surgeon... so yeah I think that its definitely jealousy.. and the crazy thing is that the top tier Categorical Surg programs are insanely competitive, so what is there to prove??? ugh...so primitive..
 
HEME-ONC said:
I have been hearing alot in regards to the fact that anesthesiologist have to take a lot of ridicule, in and out of the OR, by surgeons. Will anyone comment on this?
THanks

As I've posted in other forums before:

1) Anesthesia makes surgery possible, not easy.

2) Anesthesia keeps the patient alive in spite of the surgeon's best efforts to do otherwise.
 
neutropeniaboy said:
On the other hand, when we're operating on the ear -- from things to tympanostomy tubes to stapedectomies -- we get really upset with anesthesia when the patient's anesthesia isn't adequate, they bump the table, etc.

Other situations are intbation and extubation. With our head and neck patients, it's often painful to watch an anesthesiologist intubate them. And often, they don't want to extubate when we think it's safe; this infrequently leads to arguments.

I love ENT docs. They don't want nitrous, they don't want muscle relaxants, they don't want the patient to move, yet they want them breathing and extubated deep, no coughing, no bucking, and no positive pressure.
 
when they run the SICU - then it is another story???? what is that supposed to mean? Are you implying that ENTs are all of a sudden "board certified" in surgical critical care?

and by the way, just cause an ENT feels that it is safe to extubate - if the airway is lost and there is a bad outcome, who goes to court?

other than that, i agree with neutrapenia boy --- and in general, i have always appreciated ENTs for their understanding of airways (since that is an interest we have in commoon). Hell, their main journal is "Laryngoscope" 😀
 
I think that part of the animosity stems from the fact that when the anesthesiologist is done with his work and is driving away from the hospital at a reasonable hour, the surgeon is just barely getting around to making his/her rounds. :laugh:
 
chicamedica said:
Actually, if you don't mind, neutropeniaboy, I'm curious to hear the SICU side of the story, becuase I'm looking at programs where anesthesia runs the ICUs. Please share. . .

They don't run the SICU per se, but the attending anesthesiologists alternate with the surgery critical care attendings as "the attending of the week" thing in the SICU.
 
jwk said:
I love ENT docs. They don't want nitrous, they don't want muscle relaxants, they don't want the patient to move, yet they want them breathing and extubated deep, no coughing, no bucking, and no positive pressure.

Yeah, and that's during the same surgery...

Sorry, but we work close to nerves, lay down tenuous flaps, and do microsurgery. So, if the anesthesia is challenging for you... 🙂
 
Tenesma said:
when they run the SICU - then it is another story???? what is that supposed to mean? Are you implying that ENTs are all of a sudden "board certified" in surgical critical care?

Oh, you can manage all the acids, bases, electrolytes, rhythm things, and vent parameters all you want.

We defer on all that stuff, but when you're working in a "closed" unit and they're managing surgical issues, it can be a little frustrating.

Above all, critical care is your ball game. There are just certain things that intensivists do that we don't agree with. But, that's how it goes, I guess.

Tenesma said:
and by the way, just cause an ENT feels that it is safe to extubate - if the airway is lost and there is a bad outcome, who goes to court?

Oh, come on. You can't suggest that it's that simple. You don't think an attorney with half of a brain won't pull us in as well?

Anesthesiologists do more intubating than we do, and they have a lot of tools and tricks of the trade for accomplishing it. We have our devices as well, and they're not surgical. And not to toot my own horn, but we're pretty good at it as well.

I think that when we have a good relationship with anesthesiologists, they're more willing to let us back them up and vice versa. It goes both ways. I've had anesthesia attendings intubate for me when I've been unable to intubate on the floor or in the OR, and I've endoscopically intubated or used the Dedo to intubate when they've been unable.
 
neutropeniaboy said:
Yeah, and that's during the same surgery...

Sorry, but we work close to nerves, lay down tenuous flaps, and do microsurgery. So, if the anesthesia is challenging for you... 🙂


Realllllly? Wow, I never knew that!!!!!!!!!!!
duh.....
 
Between the places where I did medical school and residency, I'm pleased to say that the relationship between gas and surgery is almost always professional and good. The exceptions to the rule (on both sides of the curtain) have been few and far between.

Unfortunately, there are a few jackasses that give surgery a bad name (you know the sort, those that are mean just to be mean); the best I could offer for that is don't let them stomp all over you! If you are a lower-level resident (and lack the power to do much about it), get someone meaner and higher up the totem pole than you to step in.

On the other hand, I remember an experience here with an anesthesiologist that I encountered early in my intern year that ridiculed the surgeons! I walked into a case to do a hernia one day and once he found out the case was going to consist of a fellow taking an intern through, he loudly said, "I DON'T WANT TO STAND HERE ALL DAMN DAY- SHE IS GOING TO TAKE TOO LONG- THE CAFETERIA IS GOING TO CLOSE IN AN HOUR." I thought he was being facetious at first but quickly realized he was serious. My feathers were ruffled at first but I saw he treated his own staff equally as bad so I realized it wasn't personal!

Bad 'tude isn't cool on either side of the curtain!
 
Foxxy,
you are right, bad attitude isn't right on either side of the curtain. But if you had to give citations on either side for "bad, macho attitude", I wonder which side would abuse situations. From what I have seen, the surgeons were very cordial, happy, and got along with everyone including the medicine folks. Anesthesiologists and the surgeons had the easiest time with each other at this hospital. Most of the surgeons were easy going, laid back (yes you heard me right), and respected the anesthesiologists. But there were also 1-2 bad apples in the bunch. I just hope that the surgery staff at my residency are just as nice. One can only hope.
 
attending surgeons at our institution love to give CA-1 and some CA-2 residents a hard time. but they quickly shut up when an anesthesiology attending is in the room. kinda sad to see that their ego is so fragile that they must bust on gas residents.

IMHO, anesthesiology owns the OR. all the surgeon is responsible for is cutting.
 
Hey if the surgeon gives you anymore problems just yell....Hey, who's the highest paid Physician in this room....Then say (in an extremely sarcastic voice)...that would be me Mr. Cutting Man...So do your job and I'll freakin' do mine....
 
LTbulldogs said:
Hey if the surgeon gives you anymore problems just yell....Hey, who's the highest paid Physician in this room....Then say (in an extremely sarcastic voice)...that would be me Mr. Cutting Man...So do your job and I'll freakin' do mine....

Wouldn't that depend on the surgeon? Gen Surg. maybe, but I would think Neuro, CT, etc would make as much or more as the gasser, right?
 
i love it when surgeons call out, "oh we really havent loss much blood at all!"

theres only 1700ccs of bloody stuff in the suction containers with 1000ccs of irrigation.

um....lets see....1700-1000 = 700! thats nearly a liter einstein!
 
chillindrdude said:
i love it when surgeons call out, "oh we really havent loss much blood at all!"

theres only 1700ccs of bloody stuff in the suction containers with 1000ccs of irrigation.

um....lets see....1700-1000 = 700! thats nearly a liter einstein!


Wait, my OB's only loose about 50cc on a C-Section - really - they say the rest is amniotic fluid, and of course I believe them since they're the surgeon. :laugh:
 
Top