As of now I'm not sure 100% I'm going to accept, but I do want the option. I want to serve but I don't want it to interfere with any of my educational goals (whatever they may end up being, I don't want to be limited/restricted from something, hence no-way HPSP).
I ruled out HPSP for the same reasons. Little control over residency, zero control over you life and where you live for several to many years. If you still want to serve in the military in some way, you're left with the Reserves or NG and ASR is the best program in town.
Also, when does the Army get its time out of me? I know they will somehow, which is my main hesitation.
The logic behind ASR is that the NG hopes you'll stay in. Unlike full-time Army, a fair number of NG physicians stay in to retirement. So the Guard is using ASR to get enough of a pipeline to maintain manpower. Once enough are in the pipe, I'm sure ASR will go away.
Assuming I only accept the ASR for MS1-3, followed by a surgical residency, I am never deployable??😕 (4yrs medschool and >4yrs residency)
No. You are not deployable during med school nor internship. During residency, you are very unlikely to ever be deployed, but technically, they can do it. HIGHLY unlikely.
Also, you could be stop lossed and not able to resign your comission. HIGHLY unlikely.
They are willing to pay me ~150K$ and make me an officer, in exchange for a little recruiting for 3yrs, drill on some weekends with the unit for 8yrs and never be deployable to actually help troops or really "serve"? (Excluding a huge catastrophic event making me leave residency)
Correct. I think the Guard is doing ASR for three reasons:
1. Get a pipeline of incoming NG docs to replace those retiring. Primary goal.
2. Get word out about the Guard via "recruiting". Distant second.
3. "In case of emergency, break the glass". Have a pool of physicians they can call up if there is sufficient need. Even if you take ASR in your first year of med school, they technically have 3 years that they can pull you up for as long as they want if circumstances are bad enough.
Again, 3 is HIGHLY unlikely. But I'm sure the military likes to have that in their back pocket.
OTW it seems like an awesome deal!
Agreed. It really is.