U UnimaasMED Full Member 10+ Year Member 15+ Year Member Joined Mar 11, 2008 Messages 180 Reaction score 1 Points 4,531 Dental Student Jun 30, 2010 #1 Advertisement - Members don't see this ad Can't a cyclic ring with 2 pi electrons be aromatic? (substituting 0 for 4n+2 rule). Don't understand why answer c on question 66 Destroyer is wrong. Anybody?
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad Can't a cyclic ring with 2 pi electrons be aromatic? (substituting 0 for 4n+2 rule). Don't understand why answer c on question 66 Destroyer is wrong. Anybody?
Troyvdg Dentistry not Debtistry 15+ Year Member Joined Jul 13, 2009 Messages 788 Reaction score 191 Points 5,241 Location Bay Area Pre-Dental Jun 30, 2010 #2 UnimaasMED said: Can't a cyclic ring with 2 pi electrons be aromatic? (substituting 0 for 4n+2 rule). Don't understand why answer c on question 66 Destroyer is wrong. Anybody? Click to expand... didnt look at the question, but in addition to huckle's rule, an aromatic ring must be planar, cyclic, and have a conjugated system of pi electrons. Upvote 0 Downvote
UnimaasMED said: Can't a cyclic ring with 2 pi electrons be aromatic? (substituting 0 for 4n+2 rule). Don't understand why answer c on question 66 Destroyer is wrong. Anybody? Click to expand... didnt look at the question, but in addition to huckle's rule, an aromatic ring must be planar, cyclic, and have a conjugated system of pi electrons.
L lex1489 Full Member 10+ Year Member Joined Sep 8, 2009 Messages 110 Reaction score 0 Points 4,611 Pre-Dental Jun 30, 2010 #3 There's actually 4 pi electrons on there. The lone pair counts towards the pi system Upvote 0 Downvote
D DATkiller Full Member 10+ Year Member Joined Apr 5, 2010 Messages 100 Reaction score 0 Points 0 Dental Student Jun 30, 2010 #4 If there was a posite charche instead of the negative charge, that molecule would have been aromatic. Upvote 0 Downvote
If there was a posite charche instead of the negative charge, that molecule would have been aromatic.