- Joined
- Jan 12, 2017
- Messages
- 125
- Reaction score
- 76
- Points
- 2,771
- Medical Student
Most other bad residents I’ve seen, it is a character issue. Those are difficult to fix
100% agree with these statements. Lazy / arrogant will remain that way.But, academically, they don’t change much either. The smart ones stay the smart ones and the ones who struggle academically continue to struggle.
With skills like tubes, lines and blocks, yes.Hi there, quick question.
Has anyone ever seen/witnessed a terrible, like really bad and untalented first year resident who at the end of their residency, became very very good?
Thanks
Good example of a trainee’s internal factors that are nearly set in stone. I’m not a PD, so it isn’t worth my frustration to try to change them.reality the issue was him not valuing residency time commitments over his family. He just did not care to do more than bare minimum.
Once they are that age, that has not been my experience for the vast majority of people I’ve worked with.People change.
I think it is the individual’s responsibility to “fix it.” But they rarely do. In my experience, people who have issues in these character issue areas have no desire to fix themselves because they have little to no self awareness of how they are perceived. So they have no drive to change because their behavior is not a problem for them.The other stuff like character building and grit, either they have it or they don’t. If they don’t, then the training program needs to recognize and fix it over time.
Agree a lazy resident is likely to be a lazy attending in the future.With skills like tubes, lines and blocks, yes.
With work ethic/communication/anger issues - not usually.
1. I would argue with the responsibility for building character lies with trainees parents. The only time I address character is when serious patient care issues arise repeatedly due to character deficits. Anything other than that is above my pay grade and risks loss of job. Desire to change must come from within.People change.
Your perception of calling someone a bad resident assumes that you’re superior and/or in a position of power to make that assessment.
If you’re teaching these trainees, then it becomes your responsibility to correct these character issues as it pertains to them practicing anesthesiology.
Simple example - one of the residents I used to work with always used to be labeled as lazy or having work ethic issues, when in reality the issue was him not valuing residency time commitments over his family. He just did not care to do more than bare minimum. Often times residency programs have mob mentality and compare everyone as the same - like no, a 27 year old single male may not have the same priorities and ability to participate as someone who has three young children while in residency.
Definitely - shifty behavior, lying, being slick, lazy, attitude - all these need to be ironed out over time. Some folks are so far away from the median that it takes a lot of work.
Ultimately, the standard is ABA boards. That tests competence.
The other stuff like character building and grit, either they have it or they don’t. If they don’t, then the training program needs to recognize and fix it over time.
Have seen this too. Image is everything. Attendings talk and gossip. Sometimes stupid stuff gets blown up unnecessarily. Fly under the radar.I'll only add that sometimes people unfairly get a bad rap as a "bad resident". Had a classmate who got labeled as bad in his 2nd or 3rd month due to no fault of his own (truly! Senior resident told him to go to Grand rounds instead of starting blocks/epidural with the pain team, then attending was pissed that he was 'late' and ripped him a new one in front of everyone. Of course, that senior resident didn't own up to it being his own fault.). The attending (pretty volatile guy, no longer faculty there) that got mad at him then basically told the whole world how bad he was. Once someone labels you as such, it's all anyone can see or focus on. He had to work twice as hard as me to dig himself out of that hole.
OP - Why are you asking this?Hi there, quick question.
Has anyone ever seen/witnessed a terrible, like really bad and untalented first year resident who at the end of their residency, became very very good?
Thanks
1. Yes and no. Parents are responsible for raising children. Not training them to have qualities of a good anesthesiologist. That mentorship responsibility falls somewhat on the attendings.1. I would argue with the responsibility for building character lies with trainees parents. The only time I address character is when serious patient care issues arise repeatedly due to character deficits. Anything other than that is above my pay grade and risks loss of job. Desire to change must come from within.
2. Not quite sure your point about a single 27 year old male. You aren’t suggesting that his accomplishments should be devalued? I am all for helping each other out because we all run into tough spots in our lives. Ultimately you can’t let personal issues consistently overwhelm your responsibilities in the workplace, especially when a mistake can result in a patients untimely demise.
Sorry, did not read your post carefully enough. Attendings certainly need to mentor residents to help them develop clinical skills and judgement as well as professional behaviors that will help them in their career. However, there is only so much that one can do. I have yet to find the cure for laziness and I have had plenty of exposure to lazy colleagues through the years. They coast on the backs of those among us who would rather die than shirk work.1. Yes and no. Parents are responsible for raising children. Not training them to have qualities of a good anesthesiologist. That mentorship responsibility falls somewhat on the attendings.
2. Don’t worry. I was that 27 year old resident. I purposely lived within walking distance from the hospital so I would always be available. For 4 years all I did was eat, breathe, sleep, and dedicate myself to my program in residency. I understand not everyone can or wants to do that. I’m just trying to be kind to those who sincerely cannot.
Hi, you called my name?Hi there, quick question.
Has anyone ever seen/witnessed a terrible, like really bad and untalented first year resident who at the end of their residency, became very very good?
Thanks
I am not superior....this is a question a friend of mine is asking, but doesn't speak English. And neither is he.Your perception of calling someone a bad resident assumes that you’re superior and/or in a position of power to make that assessment.
I am not superior....this is a question a friend of mine is asking, but doesn't speak English. And neither is he.
LolI am not superior....this is a question a friend of mine is asking, but doesn't speak English. And neither is he.
No I am not.A you in an English speaking country?
I was labeled a "bad resident". It wasn't because my character showed that I was lazy but that I was a quiet, passive person. I had crap attendings who were lazy and didn't want to teach me anything. It didn't help that my program recruited foreign anesthesia attendings from like England, India who were just there to do their time in a US residency program. So I was compared to these foreign board certified anesthesia attendings masquerading as CA-1 residents. Worse yet, I had some Indian attendings who looked down on US grads like me. They wanted the program to be all Indian. I worked hard and graduated from the program, but f*ck them!Hi there, quick question.
Has anyone ever seen/witnessed a terrible, like really bad and untalented first year resident who at the end of their residency, became very very good?
Thanks
This is not surprising. Lots of growth happens across all specialities during intern year.Worst 1st year resident ever I was told
I caught up by year 2 or 3 in residency and honestly by year 4 and finals I.was far ahead, and getting farther than pretty much all my class...
Has anyone ever seen/witnessed a terrible, like really bad and untalented first year resident who at the end of their residency, became very very good?
Who is to say that “bad resident” means character issues? It can be a number of things.You can teach anesthesia. Why in the world do you think you can fix character issues? At best you can get them to cover it up until they are no longer under your thumb. ….
What makes them terrible and bad??Hi there, quick question.
Has anyone ever seen/witnessed a terrible, like really bad and untalented first year resident who at the end of their residency, became very very good?
Thanks
It’s been discussed earlier. It can mean a variety of things, in my opinion. Character issues seem tougher to fix. As they were saying, you may be able to hide them a little, but they are typically still there. Probably pretty rare for someone to have an epiphany and, at age 30, suddenly say, “I’ve been a horrible person my whole life. I should change the way I am and the way I treat others!”Who is to say that “bad resident” means character issues? It can be a number of things.
I know your response but I was trying to get the OPs answer. We are making assumptions that it’s a character issue.It’s been discussed earlier. It can mean a variety of things, in my opinion. Character issues seem tougher to fix. As they were saying, you may be able to hide them a little, but they are typically still there. Probably pretty rare for someone to have an epiphany and, at age 30, suddenly say, “I’ve been a horrible person my whole life. I should change the way I am and the way I treat others!”
Gotcha. Thanks for clarifying.I know your response but I was trying to get the OPs answer. We are making assumptions that it’s a character issue.
I would say diverting fentanyl or other drugs is a showstopping professionalism issue, and sadly, almost every program deals with that at least every decade. If they don’t, they likely aren’t paying close enough attention. I’ve also seen other showstopping criminal behavior. Oftentimes it is just a sense of entitlement that gets them labeled as lazy or problematic. I’ve seen some fairly serious examples over my career. But overall, I count myself lucky to have worked with mostly outstanding individuals.It's a rare resident who has genuine showstopping character or "professionalism" issues.
I think that residents who are identified as having "professionalism" issues often just have some round-peg square-hole personality differences that create friction with certain staff members. Cultural or generational differences. At the risk of spouting some woke words, sometimes there's bias or even racism involved when people don't behave the way a 1950s TV doctor should. Once they're on the ****list and the faculty gossip mill gets going, they're scrutinized and every mistake or misstep.
The subjectivity of professionalism is also fertile ground for a paper trail to get someone fired on flimsy grounds.
If someone told me a resident was unprofessional, I expected to hear something egregious, but it rarely was.
I went to an international conference recently and met some docs from EU. In Sweden they get graded only by paper/computer exams. None of this subjective professionalism issues.It's a rare resident who has genuine showstopping character or "professionalism" issues.
I think that residents who are identified as having "professionalism" issues often just have some round-peg square-hole personality differences that create friction with certain staff members. Cultural or generational differences. At the risk of spouting some woke words, sometimes there's bias or even racism involved when people don't behave the way a 1950s TV doctor should. Once they're on the ****list and the faculty gossip mill gets going, they're scrutinized and every mistake or misstep.
The subjectivity of professionalism is also fertile ground for a paper trail to get someone fired on flimsy grounds.
If someone told me a resident was unprofessional, I expected to hear something egregious, but it rarely was.
They also train for many more years with a lot less stressful schedule. Don’t have medical school debt. They do get paid well, nowhere close to here, but they have a better lifestyle. I remember during my psych rotation someone who was visiting from Greece who commented on how hard we worked. We started at 8am…had 2-3 hours where we sat around and talked about patients and their differential, drank coffee, done by 5 almost everyday. I think the working 5 days a week was what bothered her.I went to an international conference recently and met some docs from EU. In Sweden they get graded only by paper/computer exams. None of this subjective professionalism issues.
Sure enough when I told them what happens here his exact question was “How can you then prevent bias in the process?”
And they masks their tests in school by mot putting their names on the exams. Just some random number assigned to them.
And they don’t publish papers describing the race of the patients/subjects.
And they don’t have NPs and their CRNAs are never independent.
Anywho I am digressing.
I was confused by your statement and had to read it twice for it to click. Because I am like who’s sitting around for 2-3 hours talking about patients? The Americans or Greek? Then I realized you meant an American psych rotation. lol.They also train for many more years with a lot less stressful schedule. Don’t have medical school debt. They do get paid well, nowhere close to here, but they have a better lifestyle. I remember during my psych rotation someone who was visiting from Greece who commented on how hard we worked. We started at 8am…had 2-3 hours where we sat around and talked about patients and their differential, drank coffee, done by 5 almost everyday. I think the working 5 days a week was what bothered her.
They also train for many more years with a lot less stressful schedule. Don’t have medical school debt. They do get paid well, nowhere close to here, but they have a better lifestyle. I remember during my psych rotation someone who was visiting from Greece who commented on how hard we worked. We started at 8am…had 2-3 hours where we sat around and talked about patients and their differential, drank coffee, done by 5 almost everyday. I think the working 5 days a week was what bothered her.
You really shouldn't compare Greeks to swedes or UK or any other EU country. Europe is just a geographical term and the eu is a financial agreement between vastly different countries with vastly different work ethics, beliefs, cultures...They also train for many more years with a lot less stressful schedule. Don’t have medical school debt. They do get paid well, nowhere close to here, but they have a better lifestyle. I remember during my psych rotation someone who was visiting from Greece who commented on how hard we worked. We started at 8am…had 2-3 hours where we sat around and talked about patients and their differential, drank coffee, done by 5 almost everyday. I think the working 5 days a week was what bothered her.
I don't know about the greeks and their corruption however they are all quite different from each other.You really shouldn't compare Greeks to swedes or UK or any other EU country. Europe is just a geographical term and the eu is a financial agreement between vastly different countries with vastly different work ethics, beliefs, cultures...
In fact a lot of Europe hates their nearest neighbors and have gone to war repeatedly for centuries.
Europe is not one country.
The Greeks in particular are known the world over for their lethargy and corruption.
Medical school is as different in each country as the next. Even inside some countries there are different streams. Some streams for medical school are almost the exact same as the US and lead to about 100k eur debt. Not as bad as your but still bad. They're very stressful. They take very similar exams to you...
So there's that
What about their lethargy? 🙂I don't know about the greeks and their corruption however they are all quite different from each other.
The one Greek person (actually born and raised in Greece) that I work closely with is an extremely hard worker. N=1What about their lethargy? 🙂
Have zero clue TBH!! 🤣🤣What about their lethargy? 🙂
Yes they are all very different. Which ones lead to 100k in euro debt? I've known a few people from Ireland, France, Sweden and the UK and they all didn't have medical school debt (although every citizen is taxed much more).You really shouldn't compare Greeks to swedes or UK or any other EU country. Europe is just a geographical term and the eu is a financial agreement between vastly different countries with vastly different work ethics, beliefs, cultures...
In fact a lot of Europe hates their nearest neighbors and have gone to war repeatedly for centuries.
Europe is not one country.
The Greeks in particular are known the world over for their lethargy and corruption.
Medical school is as different in each country as the next. Even inside some countries there are different streams. Some streams for medical school are almost the exact same as the US and lead to about 100k eur debt. Not as bad as your but still bad. They're very stressful. They take very similar exams to you...
So there's that
I’ve seen three British comedians in the past few weeks. Each one made several jokes about how awful the National Health Service is. Mostly revolving around the inability to get seen for anything.Yes they are all very different. Which ones lead to 100k in euro debt? I've known a few people from Ireland, France, Sweden and the UK and they all didn't have medical school debt (although every citizen is taxed much more).