okay, just for fun here, why chicago hands down? Although a world class city, there doesn't seem to be a lot of appealing points there (and trust me I have spent a fair amount of time there) i.e. BAD violence-remember this last summer? totally flat, no ocean access (sure the lake is pretty damn close), cold winters, plus it seemed kind of dirty to me, and the people were sort of rude. Although there is no clear cut winners here, I feel if you like metro go NYC, if you like weather west coast is where it's at...san diego, SF, LA, wow...gorgeous!