- Joined
- Jul 15, 2012
- Messages
- 44
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
- Other Health Professions Student
Hey Stories! I have a few questions:My alma mater! Let me know if you guys have any Q's 🙂
are you seriously choosing BU over yale and columbia? i dont know about the prestige for the locals, but yale and columbia surely heard more oftenly here in Indonesia..
BU is a fantastic school. Going purely by "rankings" BU (#11) is ranked above Yale (#13) and not too far below Columbia (#5). Also, I currently live in Boston - which would mean no relocating for me, and I have the opportunity to transfer to a full-time position at BU in the spring meaning the ENTIRE MPH would cost me ~$4,000. That is an absolute no-brainer for me.
If for some reason I got a great scholarship to Yale/Columbia or didn't end up with a full-time position at BU, then it might be more of a difficult choice, but the program at BU is fantastic. My friends who graduated with MPHs in Epi from BU are currently doing much better than those who graduated from Columbia (granted there are many extenuating factors).
Well, if you want to work/live in Boston post-graduation, BU definitely makes sense as it has a huge alumni network in Boston, and beyond that, it is definitely a well-respected school of public health, even if BU as a general name lacks the cache of Columbia or Yale. Yale's also a very small SPH, and though I imagine some are very attracted to the program for that reason, it probably does turn some other people off of it - it also makes the alumni network smaller than you'd expect it to be. As for Columbia, it is a wonderful school, but living in NYC as a grad student is something that I think some people would find stressful/not feasible financially. Columbia is also the only school of public health, that, when talking to alumni, I found alumni who did not enjoy their time there. Of course, this is anecdotal, but I personally just found it interesting that Columbia was the only place I was looking into that got negative reviews from some former students.
So, just saying people have their personal reasons for preferring certain schools, and basing your entire decision on US News Rankings and "prestige" is a bit short-sighted.
Just got my letter today. 12000$ Merit award!
Hey Stories! I have a few questions:
1. How was your experience with professors (are they friendly, approachable, available when needed, etc)?
2. What's your advice on how we can to get research assistant positions that can help toward expenses?
3. I see that you did two concentrations, how does that work, because I would love to combine Epidemiology and International Health.
4. Did you have many international students during the time you were there?
I am sorry to bombard you with all these questions at once. I just received my acceptance packet with a $15000 merit award, which is better than nothing, but it's still going to be expensive especially because I'm an international student. I really like BU, and I would be willing to apply to whatever scholarships/loans I find to cover the expenses.
Thanks!
are you seriously choosing BU over yale and columbia? i dont know about the prestige for the locals, but yale and columbia surely heard more oftenly here in Indonesia..
Well, yes, if you are planning in working internationally, name recognition suddenly does become much more important, and overall name recognition of the institution internationally becomes a more important concern, as some universities well known for public health in the U.S. are not well known internationally. In this case, the very top schools (Hopkins and UNC), the Ivies (Harvard, Columbia, Yale) and those particularly known for global health (Tulane and Emory I believe) would likely be the best choices.
Tulane is particularly well known for global health, and if you are interested in that discipline, it is definitely a good choice. I do not know a lot about the school beyond that, but my impression is that global health is its specialty and its reputation in other areas is not quite as strong? Though maybe I am wrong about that. In terms of Tulane vs BU in global health specifically, Tulane probably does have the edge, though I know an amazing professor at BU SPH (I did not go there, but he taught classes in the community health program at my undergrad) who has tons of global health experience and I would imagine BU's global health program is still quite strong.
I'm a bit surprised to hear you say you're applying for health policy... as far as I know, health policy concentrations in U.S. schools of public health are generally focused heavily on the functioning, organization, and analysis of the U.S. healthcare system, not on international health systems. If you wish to work abroad post-graduation, I feel it might be more useful to concentrate in global health where you would learn about international healthcare systems and take the policy analysis and program evaluation classes from the policy concentration as well so you still have those skills at your disposal.
Having gone to both BU and Yale, I would argue that BU is a better school for the vast majority of students interested in working in a non-research setting. Yale does a great job of preparing researchers, but lacks in non-research areas.
2.) It's just sort of luck. There's no real way to get a position except you have to be a good candidate, plain and simple. This means experience and related skill sets.
I remember you from last year--I've never met anyone whom has such a vendetta against a school, did you just have a horrific experience there or something?BU is pretty notorious for having a cattle call admissions process. Huge numbers of students apply, some using BU as a backup, and maybe half decide to go elsewhere even after being accepted at BU.
A couple years ago, they asked for "additional information" from applicants, as in another essay around Feb. 14th, BU's idea of a valentine I guess 🙄 So, no, it's not necessarily being a "good candidate" plain and simple, some pretty excellent candidates get passed over as BU figures they'll go elsewhere.
The thread is practically a SDN classic.
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=797974
Can't wait to see if they do this this year. It wasn't all fun and jokes as a Peace Corps applicant who was really into BU was treated pretty poorly by some BU administrator and couldn't get help getting this additional info to the school because she was in a foreign country.
I dug up the semi-infamous quote,
"I feel as though I have shown my desire to attend BU, through my actions and through the words in my statement of purpose already provided to the committee for review. I would be curious to know if there were any other applicants who sacrificed a weeks pay and rode for 12 hours round-trip in sweltering heat on a wooden bench seat carrying a neighbor's chicken one way in order to submit one form for Boston University."
Goes to show, that a so-called dream school can turn into a nightmare when you see what is under the surface.😱
Thank you for the info Stories. Most of the electives I was planning to take (if any) were going to be in International Health so, I guess it would be perfect for me to combine the two. We'll see.1.) Very friendly. Made several connections that were great and wrote me several great letters of rec for grad school #2 (PhD).
2.) It's just sort of luck. There's no real way to get a position except you have to be a good candidate, plain and simple. This means experience and related skill sets.
3.) You just take the courses for both 🙂 Nothing more than that! Just means you won't have many (if any) electives.
4.) Yes, there were some, but in my experience, mostly in biostatistics (mostly Chinese). This was also my experience at Yale.
Yeah, it took more than 10 weeks for me too since I submitted to SOPHAS on 10/13/12;I just got accepted to Yale for CDE... c'mon BU I want to hear from you!!! 🙂
I'm pretty frustrated I haven't heard from them yet... I submitted Yale's app after BU and I have a ton of ties to the school, grrr!
Yeah, it took more than 10 weeks for me too since I submitted to SOPHAS on 10/13/12;
11/1: BU received app from SOPHAS
11/7: app forwarded for review
1/11/13: Acceptance email
So hang on in the there. Good luck!
thank you for the input, i really learn much from the conversation here. my purpose taking policy focus was to learn policy analysis, program eval, decision sciences. i agree that the global health focus would teach me more about international healthcare systems, and i am also planning to take those electives as well
truth be told, BU is actually my least researched school. i know very little about the school. but i heard that a double focus is allowed? i would love to learn the best of the two worlds
i see.. i've always thought that the name 'yale' would open much job opportunities back here in Indonesia. but i am seriously putting this information into consideration.. wish someone from yale could give insights regarding this matter
regards
chris
I just got accepted to Yale for CDE... c'mon BU I want to hear from you!!! 🙂
I'm pretty frustrated I haven't heard from them yet... I submitted Yale's app after BU and I have a ton of ties to the school, grrr!
i DO agree that decision on USNews are somewhat shallow.. but as an international student, i have little understanding of the popularity and the quality of the schools.
you do realize that as an international student, which schools you heard more often usually are respected more.. such as harvard, hopkins, berkeley, etc.. the popularity of a school i think will have some aspect, as i have my career projection back here in Indonesia.
most of my seniors and employers currently in MoH have their MPH from hopkins and tulane. hearing the word 'tulane' too often, i wonder if the school is in any way better than BU?
by the way, i'm applying for health policy concentration
regards
I am applying to Health Policy concentrations, as well. Here is my take on things given your situation:
Name recognition is key for a position in an international organization or for an international student who wishes to secure a job in-country. (Whether or not we like this is a different thread entirely.) At the same time, it is important to reflect on whether or not the name recognition itself is the value or if there is something about students who have gone to a particular "popular" school? Is it that these particular individuals have "something" about them that they are then able to secure positions in otherwise lucrative organizations?
I am Asian-American hoping to "break into" the international field in Asia. For sure name recognition is part of my decision-making process - though a small part, as I believe "fit" is the best indicator of graduate school and subsequent successes.
As for the schools you apply, I would not worry too much about the curriculum themselves. At Harvard you can take global health related courses within the Health Policy Focus. Check out the curriculum guide. It is very useful. At Berkeley you can take the global health specialty area in addition to your Health Policy Concentration - and similarly at UCLA (though it is important to note that UCLA's policy concentration is domestically focused). At BU you may be in the same situation as Berkeley and UCLA - in that the policy focus will be on US related health policies but that you can supplement with electives by taking other courses in another concentration, such as the International Health concentration at BU. BU and Yale are on the same plane, as far as I am concerned. At Columbia you can take the Health Policy Focus with the Global Health Certificate. I believe Columbia's GH Certificate has coursework on healthcare systems abroad. Strictly speaking of curriculum, Harvard is your best best.
I suggest taking a closer look at curriculum guides/course descriptions. It is part of my own decision-making process, and I find it helpful. Best to know the details of what you are getting yourself. Good luck!
thanks porkbunsrule for sharing those very helpful information, i will definitely keep it in mind, hehe
btw i got accepted with 12.000usd merit award.. why do i get the feeling that all the applicants receive such scholarship?
thanks porkbunsrule for sharing those very helpful information, i will definitely keep it in mind, hehe
btw i got accepted with 12.000usd merit award.. why do i get the feeling that all the applicants receive such scholarship?
.Hello, everyone! It's great to see your good news. I have applied to Boston University, and SOPHAS sent my application today and ETS sent my GRE scores today. Does anyone know how long it takes BU to respond with receipt of application? Also, how long did it take to receive an admission decision?
I really like Boston U's International Health MPH. I also applied to Tulane's Global Health MPH and UMich's HBHE department (which I was recently accepted to). Which school is a very recommendable school?🙂🙂🙂🙂
Not sure if anyone will be able to answer this, but it is worth a shot:
Do you know if BU allows you to double-up scholarships -
For example, most stronger applicants receive a 12,000 - 15,000 merit award from BU, but I would also want to apply for the Community Scholars scholarship which covers half tuition. This would cover most of the degree. Anyone know if this is allowed/how it works.
If I am accepted I will contact FinAid and ask, just wondering.
Any takers?
I submitted my application pretty late, and I realise they are probably swamped with applications for the priority deadline, but should I be freaking out that it's been more than a week since my application was mailed and I haven't got any notification about my application being received/complete?
I doubt this happens because it would be akin to receiving 2 merit scholarships. I can see how it is possible if one is a merit award and the other is a need-based award. I assume that a school would spread the wealth as much as they can by rescinding the merit of 12-15k and offering the other scholarship, instead - or at the very least, giving you an opportunity to decide which offer you would prefer. I imagine one way to "double up" on awards is if one merit is from the school and another merit is from an external source (e.g., foundation, work, government).
...just my opinion, though.
What day was your application mailed? Mine was mailed on January 30th and I got a confirmation email today that my app was received.
Can someone point me to a link or other information that shows a double concentration (e.g., health policy + international health) is possible? If this is true of BU, then their offer just got interesting. Thanks in advance! 😀
Did they notify u by email/regular mail?Accepted to BU with merit on 2/11 yay!
Accepted to BU with merit on 2/11 yay!
Did they notify u by email/regular mail?