- Joined
- Jan 2, 2009
- Messages
- 1,117
- Reaction score
- 69
- Points
- 4,891
- Attending Physician
I doubt that media coverage of the case was racially charged, however, I would presume that (at least partly) they were fueled by the general public's approach to this as race based. His fame probably had a larger role in it than race, but it would be naive to say that race wasn't involved in one way or another. Case in point (famous picture of reaction to OJ verdict):I agree the fact that he was a major celebrity, the grisly nature of the DOUBLE homicide, and the fact that all this was kickstarted with the nationally televised Bronco chase added to the circus that was the OJ Simpson story. But I still feel there was a racial element that contributed to the media frenzy. I remember reading a couple of months ago (probably around the time when the ***** was being sentenced to jail) that opinions on OJ Simpson continued to be divided primarily along racial lines.
Nothing short of a psychological test would reveal a potential psychopath of sociopath
Apparently now he's on suicide watch from an attempted hanging with his shoelaces. Don't they specifically not allow shoelaces into the jails for this specific reason?
Apparently now he's on suicide watch from an attempted hanging with his shoelaces. Don't they specifically not allow shoelaces into the jails for this specific reason?
Another BU med student from way back:
http://www.dailyfreepress.com/news/medical-student-charged-in-murder-1.945703
Again, do we not all remember the crazy astronaut diaper wearing lady? I guarentee there was no one better screened than the astrounaut corps, and she still got through. The truth is that we just don't have a psyche test that reliably weeds out this kind of crazy.
Though most prisons don't allow shoelaces for new inmates as a matter of policy, jails (where you go before trial) generally take them away on a case by case basis. Did your foundations jail visit teach you nothing?
Again, do we not all remember the crazy astronaut diaper wearing lady? I guarentee there was no one better screened than the astrounaut corps, and she still got through. The truth is that we just don't have a psyche test that reliably weeds out this kind of crazy.
Did your foundations jail visit teach you nothing?
I believe he's referring to your hearsay statement
I just thought statements that bold and unsubstantiated were probably just sarcasm. Guess I was wrong.
I think if attempts are made to "screen" medical school applicants for psychological disturbance in order to avoid admitting another Markoff, those students with treated mental illnesses would be barred admission, and creepy people like Markoff would still get in.
But, let's say I were an untreated bipolar II- then I might slide right by the admissions committees- answering "no" to all questions related to mental health history. Who is the better candidate? Eforest with no "official" mental health history, on no medications, w no treatment, or Eforest who carries the diagnosis bipolar II- but is well managed on medications.
I think it's impossible to prevent creeps from entering med school- they present themselves too well.
Interesting thing is that we rejected him from my medical school. One of my classmates interviewed him, and specifically wrote that he didn't trust him. It's creepy to think that it may have been craigslist in our area that was used to lure someone. Then again, who knows if living and studying where he ultimately did live and study contributed to uncovering his mental pathology. I feel so bad for his gf who no doubt should be taking Step 1 in a few weeks. That won't happen....wow I was staying out of this one but hiding the gun in a copy of gray's, that is too ridiculous.
Then again, who knows if living and studying where he ultimately did live and study contributed to uncovering his mental pathology.
Interesting thing is that we rejected him from my medical school. One of my classmates interviewed him, and specifically wrote that he didn't trust him.

It was not hearsay.
I have heard of an overwhelming number of male med students as well as residents that have very similar attitudes towards women as this guy has been reported to have.
really though, I want to know what this guy's SDN handle is. You know he's got one.
THAT was the one weird thing I noticed in every picture I've seen of him with other people, thank you for describing it better. Everyone says "oh he looks just like a normal kid out having fun..." no, you can tell that in many of the pictures where he's grinning he's not really happy...I think it's a little much to jump from that to accusing someone of being a serial killer though. Everyone has bad days just like many people can fake a good interviewMsKrispyKreme said:when he smiled, it was forced (no emotion in his eyes)

I interview applicants. I hated interviewing super conservative, emotionless students- I always had to carry on the conversation. I'd rather someone be a chatterbox than someone who is reserved and quiet.What school was this at? I wouldn't have a problem with no emotion. Its a med school interview you're suppose to be conservative, not show emotion. Also well dressed, articulate, intelligent....all positives when it comes to getting into medical school. It is a medical school interview you're suppost to brag about yourself (don't come off arrogant though). This doesn't seem like all that abnormal behavior. But, I wasn't there. Less interaction is sometimes best at interviews, you almost want to stay off the radar. Everyone is always watching. Maybe he/she was all bussiness. Sometimes the process can take a lot out of an applicant.
I interview applicants. I hated interviewing super conservative, emotionless students- I always had to carry on the conversation. I'd rather someone be a chatterbox than someone who is reserved and quiet.
The emphasis from up top is interviewing students who you could see yourself working with in the next four years, and more importantly, someone who has some working social skill that he or she would be using for a doctor-patient relationship. Most of my best interviews were people who were intelligent, yes, but more importantly someone who could talk about something else aside from medicine or academics. I'm not looking for "special" applicants who traveled the world and saved some babies along the way, (and I don't think I need to defend myself for this), I'm looking for someone who can just hold a regular conversation about anything. How hard is that? I'll leave all the academic/extracurricular/"special" stuff for the admin interviewers.I never want to be a student interviewer. I don't like student interviewers because they usually are the tougher ones to convice them to accept the applicant. The student interviewer always wants someone who is "special" whatever that means. I think student interviewers should do some self reflection, chances are they themsleves were just bland, blah, applicants once themselves. end rant.
What's there to talk about?I'm looking for someone who can just hold a regular conversation about anything.
The emphasis from up top is interviewing students who you could see yourself working with in the next four years, and more importantly, someone who has some working social skill that he or she would be using for a doctor-patient relationship. Most of my best interviews were people who were intelligent, yes, but more importantly someone who could talk about something else aside from medicine or academics. I'm not looking for "special" applicants who traveled the world and saved some babies along the way, (and I don't think I need to defend myself for this), I'm looking for someone who can just hold a regular conversation about anything. How hard is that? I'll leave all the academic/extracurricular/"special" stuff for the admin interviewers.
I don't think L2D is saying that a few extra questions or secondaries would filter out every disturbed med school applicant. What is probable is that these increased hurdles would increase the PROBABILITY of detecting something strange. JMHO
Sounds to me like you were indeed citing what other people told you as fact of an event happening without actually knowing of these events for yourself. Is it the courtroom definition of hearsay, dunno but I think you get the drift. Perhaps saying right off that you know of many such incidents would have been a better strategy and the question of whether or not strenuous graduate education attracts a certain number of people with a variety of personality defects from benign to debilitating is indeed worth thinking about
I'm still having trouble seeing how this guy is a 2nd year medical student at the age of 22. Even if they had a BS/MD pathway, he still wouldn't be old enough.
Exactly. I'm wondering if it's coincidence that the one school that makes its secondary essay "optional" ends up with a guy like this. I'm not saying that some folks can't fake it. But you don't know if you don't ask. As mentioned in this thread, this isn't even the first time BU ended up with such a model citizen. So common sense dictates that maybe there is something about their application process that (1) doesn't elicit thngs that the schools without this kind of admission issue manage to elicit, or (2) attracts people with things to hide. The goal should be to improve the screening process as you go along so as to eliminate whatever mistaken admissions they can. If the allegations are true here, this school probably might think hard about whether there are more questions worth asking. The schools that have tons of hurdles and lengthy essay requirements don't seem to have this kind of admissions history. All I'm saying.
Interesting thing is that we rejected him from my medical school. One of my classmates interviewed him, and specifically wrote that he didn't trust him. It's creepy to think that it may have been craigslist in our area that was used to lure someone. Then again, who knows if living and studying where he ultimately did live and study contributed to uncovering his mental pathology. I feel so bad for his gf who no doubt should be taking Step 1 in a few weeks. That won't happen....
Medical Field Can Draw In Sickos Who Like to Hurt, Says Shrink
A frightening few medical professionals are drawn more to the prospect of hurting patients than healing them - a rare phenomenon that may throw light on the accused Craigslist killer's career choice.
"The profession attracts people too comfortable with the hurting aspect," said Boston therapist Charles Foster. "It's a tiny minority - I hope."
In extreme cases, this depraved doctor complex can result in the Hippocratic Oath turned upside-down: First, do harm.
The contradiction could help explain how second-year Boston University medical student Philip Markoff, 23, could be the cold-blooded killer police say he is.
Such a person, psychiatrist Dr. Keith Ablow said, "could be a healer and a killer for a long time."
Markoff was arrested within a week of Craigslist masseuse Julissa Brisman's murder, thanks to an e-mail he sent to Brisman, prosecutors said.
"It's lucky it did fall apart as quickly as it did," Ablow said.
Ablow said the healer-killer complex is not such a mystery once you cut below the surface.
"It's a tragedy, but it could have been far worse," he said.
If convicted, Markoff would follow other Bay State killer-healers to prison, including Dr. Dirk Greineder of Wellesley and Dr. Richard Sharpe of Gloucester.
Greineder got life for the 1999 murder of his wife, who learned of his secret sex life. Sharpe, a cross-dressing dermatologist, murdered his wife in 2000. He hanged himself in prison in January.
http://www.bostonherald.com/news/regional/view.bg?articleid=1167909
Gotta love this article:
I love individuals who sell out their own crowd.
I don't believe his girlfriend is a medical student...not that life's gonna be a breeze or anything.
Gotta love this article:
I love individuals who sell out their own crowd.
I mean, who doesnt know a moody, nerdy type A med student who doesnt share details about their personal life with their tank mate in anatomy lab?
So maybe something happened and this kid just dug a really, really, deep hole. They keep talking about possible gambling debts, so who knows what's going on (although I don't think Foxwoods would give a broke medical student a very large line of credit).
I think people should just be sensitive of issues like this in general.
It's always so easy to say "Oh I would never do something like this" and "What a sicko" etc. I'm certainly not sympathesizing with serial killers, people with obvious mental distress, etc. but really, how do you know something traumatic or drastic changes won't happen in your life? And how well aware of yourself in that situation you won't change and do something out of the ordinary from your routine behaviour? Yes, you probably won't go around stalking women and killing them, but how sure are you that you can handle everything and not lash out?
I think people should really think before judging someone else and riding a moral high horse that they would never make a mistake and could never possibly go down and change for the worse. Life is really unpredictable and sometimes it's really hard to know what will happen in the future.
I also don't agree that his medical school should be held accountable for this. And it's not fair that secondaries and interviews are supposed to screen this out. Some people are VERY good fakers.
She is a med student.
moody + smart makes lots of people uncomfortable. I don't mind quiet nerdy types but when they start getting moody and wierd.. think I start to wonder about psychiatric problems.. I understand being moody to your friends or people who you are comfortable with. However, if you share nothing about your personal life except your moodiness, isn't that a lack of control over your emotions and a lack of professionalism (ie. if we aren't friends- we should be professional to each other)?
Bottom line: Expressing moodiness in anatomy lab will be a quick way to get yourself labeled as the next craigslist killer. Be Happy 🙂 Life is good
So Markoff's SDN username is footcloud? Interesting...
Is she an M2 at Boston? 😱
BTW I find it surprising that nobody here has said that they knew him. I know there's definitely bunch of med students who knew him from Albany, plus obviously the BU students.
I don't want anyone to get the impression I'm trying to defend a killer. As friends of someone who was arrested for a crime he didn't commit and later acquitted of all charges, I just am saying don't be so quick to jump to assumptions.
Some of the student papers which had headlines about the Craigslist killer were removed by the admissions office, and people in admission office anonymously told reports that they did it because it might reflect poorly on the school, while apparently some school officials said that officially perhaps the papers were picked up by students or didn't know what happened to them. The school should be more honest with applicants about the issue and shouldn't blame current students for removing some student run newspaper.
See ^this little factoid plus the fact that his father is a dentist makes it hard for me to believe the guy was really hurting for cash.
Plus it doesn't explain why he targeted women and kept trophies (e.g. their underwear) from his crimes. There are lot more easier ways to commit robbery than to go to the trouble of perusing internet ads, chatting with the victims, arranging to meet the victims in public places (the guy was caught on surveillance), doing Lord knows what with them, and then robbing them.
He has a ritual, and it appears that he just escalated. If he freaked out & got scared, then he would've shot the girl 1x and then fled...but he shot her 3x after pistol whipping & fighting her.
It seems that the school is trying to scrub away any memory of him at the school. Similar denying has also happened in the case of some clinical faculty.
Elaborate, please.
You like to gossip don't you? Not, one of the best charatistics to have.