lightnk102 said:
This is a point that people have claimed many many times on a different thread, and other people have opposed just as many times on the same different thread. It's really impossible to say which is easier without taking both classes.
As a current second year who took the seeming crap-tastic class (as well as many of my friends), I've had no problems getting into med school as a result of it (3 acceptances, including BU), and there's been no obvious difference between the friends who took the one-semester physiology and the ones who took the two-semester physiology (all of us got into med schools of similar caliber).
No one asserted that you wouldn't get into med school off the two-semester track.
lightnk102 said:
I suppose Stinky Cheese has a point, in that if you want the fuzzy feeling of sitting next to med year students and pretending like you're one of them
That is not my point at all. It should be fairly obvious that this has nothing to do with "feeling like a medical student". Read the above posts more carefully.
lightnk102 said:
- by all means take the one-semester class. However, I think the purpose of the SMP is to take learn med school material taught by med school professors, not "sit beside the med school students in the classes."
The point is to show that you can take a rigorous, med-level course schedule and succeed. I feel that taking a similar courseload as the meds is what accomplishes this.
lightnk102 said:
I think the emphasis being claimed in physically sitting beside the medical students is a little misguided. Besides, being in the one-semester class means being crammed into a too-small lecture hall, tolerating dirty looks from the med school students, and having to wait in line at the front after classes end just to ask questions.
I'm sorry you've misunderstood my point. I don't care about sitting next to med students.
lightnk102 said:
I'm not arguing that the two classes are exactly the same, but I do think the differences are mis-represented on this forum and overblown. I believe cammy1313 and singing devil both took the one-semester physiology and i took the two-semester, but all three of us received a good number of interviews and are going to medical school next year.
No one is saying that you won't get into medical school if you take the two-semester class, but if people are coming to BU expecting to take a real med-school schedule, they need to know that is not the case.
lightnk102 said:
I agree with the previous poster that the two-semester physiology ends up being equally difficult due to its greater depth and detail. One option is just different from the other, and each person should make their choices based on their own priorities.
First, I doubt that the med school's physio is all that much easier than the two-semester class. If it was, then the med students would not be getting a rigorous enough physio education.
Secondly, students don't have a choice which track they're in, so people can't make their own choices based on priorities.
lightnk102 said:
In fact - being part of the smaller two-semester physiology class meant more personal recommendations since the professors (who are also on the adcom) get to know you better. Taking the one-semester vs. the two semester is based solely on what you're looking to get out of the experience. There are advantages and disadvantages to both. Representing one as clearly superior to the other is misleading.
No one has represented one as clearly superior to the other, but I maintain my belief that taking half as much material in the same amount of time has to be much easier than the one-semester physio class, no matter how many nitpicking details they ask for. I know many people in the two-semester phys class who love the class, but agree it is pretty easy and manageable. I wonder how many one-semester people feel the same?
Additionally, being in the two-semester track has limited the other courses one can take. People who were planning on taking Neuro can't because of the physio schedule conflict, but one-semester physio people can. People wanting to take certain research or mental health classes can't. The one-semester people can do all of this. Now do you understand why the two-semester track is pretty much the shaft?