UVic's clinical program has a better reputation (I think) than Windsor, and has more research opportunities. I have good research fits with my POIs at both schools, but my POI at UVic is fairly new and only has one grad student. However, the POI seems to have funding in the lab (whereas the other POI doesn't) and a lot of projects going on, which really appeals to me.
Windsor has a more diverse range of clinical opportunities, and from talking to the students, it seems that the clinical training is top-notch. I think I really need to think which aspect (i.e. clinical or research) is more important to me and what my long term goals are. However, I do want to keep my options open to an academic/research career in the future, so I think UVic will satisfy that goal better.
The major factor that is giving me so much grief though is the fact that Victoria is on the west coast, and far far away from my partner in Ontario
. He's stuck there and cannot come with me as he is in the middle of his own grad studies. Plus I haven't had a chance to actually visit the UVic campus (as I was only invited for a Skype interview this week) and did not get a "feel" for the program. So much internal conflict!