I have enjoyed the program a lot so far. I'm impressed with Case and the institutional culture here. It's academically intense but also very laid-back. I absolutely feel that it's preparing me for my career goal (which is medical school). I have learned so much this year; not just scientifically speaking, but how to study more effectively, how to think more clinically, how to take exams. The advising is good. Some problems with premed advising as a whole is that every student is different and everyone you talk to tells you something different. I think that at Case they do a good job of trying to individualize the advising and help you to make a plan that is unique to your given situation. You get an academic and career advisor. Also, I haven't come across a faculty member that wasn't willing to meet and offer advice. It's a collaborative environment for sure, and you get the sense that the faculty truly want us to succeed. Our success is their success, and that's how it should be.
Probably the only downside to the program I can think of is that compared with other SMPs out there it is not a simulation of the first year of medical school. However, this is also positive because you really get to focus on physiology and make sure that you know it cold. Also, it opens up the door for you to take elective courses and tailor your degree towards what you specifically need/want to accomplish. Starting next year they are introducing "areas of concentration" that will allow you to specialize in given area of physiology. One example that people may find interesting is the neuroscience one, in which you do a clinical rotation through neurology with the 3rd year med students at Case. Also, having a somewhat lighter course load than some SMPs allows you to get involved in clinical and research opportunities (which are bountiful here in Cleveland).