Dr. Cox points are well noted and IMO she is spot on with saying it depends on the situation. I didn't say it was my first choice, I said that when there was a severely hypovolemic patient the clavicle helped hold the vein open allowing for access when it may be impossible in other areas. It became my first choice when I couldn't get a femoral.
When I said I "thought" it was supported by the literature it was because I only read it somewhere in a book like ATLS, Mont Reid etc, I never have seen studies done on it. I'm not sure which book it was, but with my poor reading habits it almost has to be ATLS, Mont Reid, Sabbistons, Washington Manual or On Call.
As for the chest compression thing, it only takes two words "hold compressions". Like Dr. Cox said, in that situation "sterile tech." is usually a half bottle of betadine poured over the site because you are removing the line in a few hours if the patient lives anyway. The safety issue is no different than the normal subclavian line if you have them hold compressions (aside from the urgency). It's like placing a chest tube when someone is doing compressions, before you cut/stick you just clear your field.
I don't remember the exact book I read it in, and I will try to find it because I really do believe SLUser11 would just like to see it. I do know that has saved me on more than one occasion.
Once two Cardiology fellows were trying in both femoral sites, neither with any success (they do fem sticks all day long). I tried once, couldn't get anything (no heart beat, questionable femoral pulse on compressions) and went to the subclavian and presto, first stick.
It even has helped me on non urgent lines. One day I was able to see the IJ collapse even with the patient in maximum trendellenburg using US. The needle just would not penetrate the IJ, and the carotid was directly under it so I couldn't go through and back up. Moved to the subclavian and got the line first stick. CVP of the patient was 0-1 when the monitor was hooked up and that was after the first litre of fluid.
Had an attending try both sides one night on a bad trauma with the same results, never able to get anything (this was after I had tried both sides as well). He moved up to the subclavian and got it first stick.
Those are just a few of the times I have seen it really appear like the clavicle helped hold open the subclavian when the femoral vein was collapsing to the point of not being able to place the line.
Our trauma FAST machine has a different transducer and you would have to change them out to do a line. The FAST transducer would suck for that.
I'll try and find that book in the next few days, I know I read it somewhere cause I am not smart enough to figgure out something that actually works on my own