CHOOSE YOUR OWWN - Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Mods
@Animal Midwife @Dr. ForgotToFlush @kaydubs

Mechanics
Lynch close is 10PM EDT.
Night close is 10AM EDT.
Majority starts Day 2.
Assume lynch is closed when majority is hit even if no mod is available.
No Lynch is allowed.

Greater Idea Mafia/RolePMs

wiki.mafiascum.net

Rules
1. Make at least 5 posts per game day. Naked lynch votes don't count.
2. Everything may be edited but lynch votes. Just be sure to not delete stuff.
3. No quoting, copypasting, or otherwise duplicating mod messages from role PM. Use paraphrasing.
4. No screenshots.
5. No asking for subs on thread. Use your role PM instead.
6. Dead cannot post anything in game thread but encouragement for their preferred team.
7. Spectators cannot post in game thread.

Roster
1. @SARdoghandler
2. @katashark
3. @genny
4. @mmmdreamerz
7. @WildZoo
8. @BigCats
10. @alissa14
12. @Sunbodi
13. @Barkley13
14. @SportPonies
15. @cubsrule4e
16. @WonderingStudent
17. @Stagg737
18. @CoffeeQuestionMark

 

[Animal Midwife]

Discards
SAR - Mafia 1x Governor
kata - Vanillager
genny - Village Nymphomaniac
3m - Village Blocker
dubz - Village Compulsive Child Killer
BC - Village Enabler
alissa - Village Vanilla Cop
Suni - Village 1x Paranoid Gun Owner
Barks - Innocent Child
Sporty - Wild Card
cubs - Vanilla Wolf
Wonder - Village Cop
Stagg - Alien Psychotrooper
Coffee? - Wolf Miller

 

[Animal Midwife]

Table of Contents
Day 1 - Final Tally; Stagg was village doctor
Night 1 - 3m was mafia goon and cubs was village tracker
Day 2 - Final Tally; Lawpy was village doctor
Night 2 - genny was village supersaint
Day 3 - Final Tally; Coffee? was mafia cupid
Night 3 - alissa was village doctor and SAR was village mason
Day 4 - Final Tally; kata was mafia compulsive hider
Night 4 - Barks was village bloodhound
Day 5 - Final Tally; Suni was wolf cop

 

[Animal Midwife]

It is now Day 1.​

 

[cubsrule4e]

Last

ETA: Sorry... I thought this was AM's Reverse WW game since I got the last role I picked instead of the first.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Well this is about the easiest, most certain thing thats ever happened.

Lynch 3M

 

[BigCats]

Discards
dubz - Village Compulsive Child Killer
Barks - Innocent Child

I’d just like to start off by saying y’all have no sense of a good time

 

[BigCats]

Mmm time to build my reads entirely upon how good your discarded role was

 

[BigCats]

Well this is about the easiest, most certain thing thats ever happened.

Lynch 3M

See especially given her discarded role I’d be super down for this but if she did finally get a non-village role I’ll let her have a day or two to revel in it first

 

[SARdoghandler]

Mmm time to build my reads entirely upon how good your discarded role was

Glad to know I'm not the only one planning to wifom the **** out of this

 

[cubsrule4e]

See especially given her discarded role I’d be super down for this but if she did finally get a non-village role I’ll let her have a day or two to revel in it first

Well then have fun getting yelled at about how your D1 vote is crap and baseless and your reads suck and you should be lynched for it

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I’d just like to start off by saying y’all have no sense of a good time

Innocent child is my favorite role
I cannot fathom why stagg would not select alien psychotrooper

 

[cubsrule4e]

Innocent child is my favorite role
I cannot fathom why stagg would not select alien psychotrooper

He may have been sippin' on the bubbly and misread it as Alien Proctotrooper

 

[SARdoghandler]

lynch Stagg

I want to know your thought process behind turning down a semi unseerable 3pish role

 

[SARdoghandler]

Innocent child is my favorite role
I cannot fathom why stagg would not select alien psychotrooper

Glad to see we're on the same page haha

 

[BigCats]

SAR - Mafia 1x Governor
kata - Vanillager
genny - Village Nymphomaniac
3m - Village Blocker
dubz - Village Compulsive Child Killer
BC - Village Enabler
alissa - Village Vanilla Cop
Suni - Village 1x Paranoid Gun Owner
Barks - Innocent Child
Sporty - Wild Card
cubs - Vanilla Wolf
Wonder - Village Cop
Stagg - Alien Psychotrooper
Coffee? - Wolf Miller

Reads based entirely on discards:
Village
kata/genny/dubz/Barks/Sporty/Coffee/cubs
SAR/alissa
3m/Sunbodi/Stagg/Wondering
Scum

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

SAR - Mafia 1x Governor
kata - Vanillager
genny - Village Nymphomaniac
3m - Village Blocker
dubz - Village Compulsive Child Killer
BC - Village Enabler
alissa - Village Vanilla Cop
Suni - Village 1x Paranoid Gun Owner
Barks - Innocent Child
Sporty - Wild Card
cubs - Vanilla Wolf
Wonder - Village Cop
Stagg - Alien Psychotrooper
Coffee? - Wolf Miller

Reads based entirely on discards:
Village
kata/genny/dubz/Barks/Sporty/Coffee/cubs
SAR/alissa
3m/Sunbodi/Stagg/Wondering
Scum

You would grant village read for discarding innocent child?

Edit:
Yet not for paranoid gun owner?

I think the rest here is solid but those two seem backwards

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Well this is about the easiest, most certain thing thats ever happened.

Lynch 3M

What if 3M, wondering, stagg, and barks are all the bad guys and the game is solved strictly by discarded roles

 

[BigCats]

You would grant village read for discarding innocent child?

Knowing that there could’ve been a childkiller at play? Sure! I personally would’ve discarded it in a heartbeat unless the counteroption sucked à la wolf miller- either you get instakilled when you reveal or you get NKed soon after.

 

[cubsrule4e]

What if 3M, wondering, stagg, and barks are all the bad guys and the game is solved strictly by discarded roles

Yall are the ones handing out cred strictly based on roles. I only focused on 3M.

 

[BigCats]

You would grant village read for discarding innocent child?

Edit:
Yet not for paranoid gun owner?

I think the rest here is solid but those two seem backwards

Specifically the fact that it’s Sunbodi who discarded PGO (which seems right up her alley) is what lands her scum according to my Totally Accurate Readslist

 

[cubsrule4e]

Specifically the fact that it’s Sunbodi who discarded PGO (which seems right up her alley) is what lands her scum according to my Totally Accurate Readslist

I agree with this assessment, but theres really just no telling with her unpredictability. I could actually see her throwing away Alpha 3x vig wolf for vanilla village.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

Well this is about the easiest, most certain thing thats ever happened.

Lynch 3M

Or ya know, maybe it’s not lol?

But nice try attempting to get everyone to jump on me.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Knowing that there could’ve been a childkiller at play? Sure! I personally would’ve discarded it in a heartbeat unless the counteroption sucked à la wolf miller- either you get instakilled when you reveal or you get NKed soon after.

Who knew there could be a childkiller at play? I personally did not know that. I would've picked it. Also not sure who would've picked child killer to begin with

 

[cubsrule4e]

Or ya know, maybe it’s not lol?

But nice try attempting to get everyone to jump on me.

If you are not non-village (ie if you are village) I will eat that gigantic cat in the hat hat that your cow is wearing.

 

[WildZoo]

I’d just like to start off by saying y’all have no sense of a good time

What do you think I am, some kind of murderer??

 

[mmmdreamerz]

If you are not non-village (ie if you are village) I will eat that gigantic cat in the hat hat that your cow is wearing.

Which is what you do every single time you try to lynch me and I’m village. Every. Time. Lynching me for a discarded role is silly, but I think you know that. Completely NAI.

 

[WildZoo]

Mmm time to build my reads entirely upon how good your discarded role was

I think this means I should lynch wonder

 

[cubsrule4e]

Which is what you do every single time you try to lynch me and I’m village. Every. Time. Lynching me for a discarded role is silly, but I think you know that. Completely NAI.

I cant be wrong forever

 

[mmmdreamerz]

How about we just automatically assume everyone who discarded a wolf role is village and see how that turns out

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Yall are the ones handing out cred strictly based on roles. I only focused on 3M.

Why not the others?

 

[mmmdreamerz]

I cant be wrong forever

I intend to go to my death bed #alwaysavillager

 

[WildZoo]

SAR - Mafia 1x Governor
kata - Vanillager
genny - Village Nymphomaniac
3m - Village Blocker
dubz - Village Compulsive Child Killer
BC - Village Enabler
alissa - Village Vanilla Cop
Suni - Village 1x Paranoid Gun Owner
Barks - Innocent Child
Sporty - Wild Card
cubs - Vanilla Wolf
Wonder - Village Cop
Stagg - Alien Psychotrooper
Coffee? - Wolf Miller

Reads based entirely on discards:
Village
kata/genny/dubz/Barks/Sporty/Coffee/cubs
SAR/alissa
3m/Sunbodi/Stagg/Wondering
Scum

Ok but how do you know I wouldn't discard a kind of ****ty village role for an OP 3p or wolf role.

Because I totally would.

 

[WildZoo]

(and did in the first round. C'est la vie.)

 

[cubsrule4e]

Which is what you do every single time you try to lynch me and I’m village. Every. Time. Lynching me for a discarded role is silly, but I think you know that. Completely NAI.

If you think targeting due to discarded roles is silly then SAR and Coffee and whoever else that has been posting deserve a reprimanding from you as well. Darn ignorant whipper snappers!

 

[WildZoo]

It is silly, by the way, totally bogus strategy, but also amusing for early in the day

 

[cubsrule4e]

Why not the others?

Because they dont every game make it clear how much theyd like to be a wolf (in this case multiple other factions), but the point still stands.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

If you think targeting due to discarded roles is silly then SAR and Coffee and whoever else that has been posting deserve a reprimanding from you as well. Darn ignorant whipper snappers!

You were the one who came on the thread guns blazing to lynch me D1 based on a discarded role. The thread had barely opened. I mean I get it to some extent, but I also don’t think it’s good game play.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

(and did in the first round. C'est la vie.)

I definitely picked scum over vanillager in round 2

 

[BigCats]

Ok but how do you know I wouldn't discard a kind of ****ty village role for an OP 3p or wolf role.

Because I totally would.

Oh totes! But I’d be way more concerned if you had discarded a high-quality village role. Wayyyy more suspicion of better scum roles there (even though statistically the odds are probably about the same but shhh)

 

[cubsrule4e]

You were the one who came on the thread guns blazing to lynch me D1 based on a discarded role. The thread had barely opened. I mean I get it to some extent, but I also don’t think it’s good game play.

Actually Im lynching you because you didnt even give me a "haha" on my brilliant opening joke. I mean I had to constantly refresh the page for a whole 30 seconds to make sure I was able to set that up.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

Actually Im lynching you because you didnt even give me a "haha" on my brilliant opening joke. I mean I had to constantly refresh the page for a whole 30 seconds to make sure I was able to set that up.

Lol. I’m also trying to do radiology rounds and just spilled coffee all over my keyboard so you’ll have to forgive my lack sense of humor

 

[cubsrule4e]

I definitely picked scum over vanillager in round 2

I picked scum in both prior rounds, finally got pissed off and gave up and picked sacrificial lamb.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Because they dont every game make it clear how much theyd like to be a wolf (in this case multiple other factions), but the point still stands.

I feel like it wouldn't make sense to give up those 4 roles

But the sign ups also stated your discarded role would be revealed.

This is what's going to keep me from voting there today because the alternative would be they have super awesome village roles and the discarded pale in comparison

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I picked scum in both prior rounds, finally got pissed off and gave up and picked sacrificial lamb.

Lol you're a sacrificial lamb?
No Mel-jo for us?

 

[cubsrule4e]

Lol you're a sacrificial lamb?
No Mel-jo for us?

Well my first set of options was pretty good. Then I think AM felt bad and the second round gave me an option she knew I wanted... then not but an hour later before I could even officially submit that pick, was rolled into a black hole of options.

 

[WildZoo]

I picked scum in both prior rounds, finally got pissed off and gave up and picked sacrificial lamb.

For some reason I absolutely believe this

 

[mmmdreamerz]

For some reason I absolutely believe this

I feel like it’s kinda hard to lie about too

 

[cubsrule4e]

For some reason I absolutely believe this

Well I mean it was better than just quitting on them like I had considered for a few minutes.

 

[WildZoo]

Wait a second, I don't see sacrificial lamb on the list