AndyMilonakis said:
The AP only people tell me this argument (which I am biased about and favor). If you will be doing research 90-100% of the time, YOU DON'T NEED BOTH. YOU WILL NOT BE USING BOTH! Specialize in a narrow aspect of pathology just to keep a clinical appointment. Time efficiency in getting to where you want to be with respect to you career is key, as they tell me.
I'm not flaming you man - you know I repesct the research. But, I think it really depends on the kind of research. True, if you're doing basic science then CP is probably useless. If you're doing "translational research", it might be more useful to have CP. For example, CP is where all the training is for quality control and quality assurance testing. If your research involves bringing a new diagnostic test online, that could be very useful info to have in your back pocket. But, if you're comfortable with the idea of doing autopsies to cover your clinical responsibilities and mainly doing research, then that pretty much answers it, although that may change during your first two years of residency.
Also, here's another argument - you never know what direction research will take. A good researcher will follow the trail wherever it leads and adjust and retool as needed. I'm not saying get CP just in case - your argument
ad absurdum above regading the physics major addresses this issue. But, AP/CP has the additional benefit of providing job security - I don't think it's as easy to go back and "do CP" later. I consider it a trade-off of time for job security.
I totally agree that your (our) top choice is ideal for what you want to do. You can spend the first two years in AP and then decide what you want to do. But your research experience does fit really nicely with a specialty like renal. If research is your passion, man, I say go for it. I personally may not be able to do it, b/c of family considerations, but deep in my gut it always pulls at me. Right now I'm AP/CP but that could change into AP/research depending on how things go and what grabs me. Hopefully you'll get your top place, where they'll support you and have a track record of sending people that way. Also, hopefully you have people there with you to watch your back while you do it