i learned today that kcom students are being advised to sit for the usmle. i am waiting for their dean to call me back, however, i did speak with linda at the AOA and she explained the following which may help to clear up the panic:
1. an examination cannot be validated before it is administered b/c validation requires a statistical analysis. the usmle makers accomplish validation prior to administration by testing the test on volunteers. i guess comlex did not/does not do this?
2. the validity of the comlex was questioned by the FMSB--some board which oversees the usmle, etc. the bottom line is that it was a political move -- as the great einstein said, change always meets with resistance from mediocre minds.
3. so, basically, as stated by the executive director of the aoa (you can read this on the aoa website), the aoa has hired a private company to do the psychometrics..there are some 7 studies going on, 3 or so are complete and have validated the exam..the aoa officially therefore DOES NOT EXPECT THAT COMLEX WILL BE INVALIDATED...after all, step 2 and 3 have been validated now for years. EVERYTHING IS GOING TO BE O.K. there really is not much reason to panic..this all just seems like another example of d.o. disorganization--nothin' new..
4. should i take the usmle? linda herself--an aoa rep-- said she encourages d.o. students wishing to go into a competative speciality field such as neurosurgery, ent, etc. to take the usmle. louisianna does not recognize d.o.s so if you want to live there, you gotta do usmle...also, 5 states, west virginia, michigan, pennsylvania, florida, and i think nj?, require the comlex for d.o. licensure..otherwise, basically, all you need to do is take the comlex and you will still have acess to the allopathic match..call the residency programs in which you are most interested in order to find out what they individually require..
5. the bottom line: decide what you wanna be..a doctor pure and simple, a D.O. or an M.D...it does not appear that there is really anything to worry about on this issue..i will post if the dean of kcom tells me anything alarming...
--