I dont understand how it could rub you the wrong way. I have perforated and.felt terrible about it. I want to save teeth more than anything.. But when you're given bombed out tooth to work on, you go into it knowing that it may not have a viable prognosis. You do what you can... I don't have super powers.. Do you?? Give me a cup of flower and some baking soda.. What kind of cake can make with that? A pretty nasty one. Give me a bombed out tooth with poor oral hygiene, diet, bad margins.. and I cant guarantee you a great outcome there either.
"Patients control their own destiny" is true any way you spin it. Seeing the dentist once or twice a year doesnt equate to a quality dental care if their at home care is lackluster.
Pulp capping can be beneficial... Sometimes.... but to say that your pulp cap was successful 3 Weeks later is not quality. Or to say that its successful merely because a patient doesnt complain about it doesNT mean its a healthy or vital pulp anymore. Essentially, you may be delaying the inevitable, and that doesnt make it low quality, just unfortunate.