D
deleted703719
This is an organization that touts itself as promoting scholarly and professional behavior in medicine etc etc per their mission statement, but do they actually do anything worthwhile? I.e., do they do they use any of the money they collect from dues for things other than throwing banquets for themselves or giving out like 3 scholarships a year? If so, I have been hard pressed to find examples of this. I know for a fact that since junior AOA elections were held 6 months ago at my school they have not done a single thing.
I ask because I am deciding whether I want to be in AOA or not. Historically, I have been absolutely opposed to joining organizations like this (I refused to join Phi Beta Kappa on the same principle). I genuinely do not understand why AOA exists. If you are in the top of your class, have good board scores, research and volunteer experiences, these things should speak for themselves. Why should you pay money to be in AOA, an organization that's sole purpose seems to be to propagate and celebrate itself and its awesomeness. And yes, i know the obvious answer being because it looks good on your resume.
I am asking this sincerely. I am not trying to be a jerk. I don't know why I feel so strongly about this, but I feel that the sheer existence of something like AOA is wrong because there are so many brilliant, worthy and dedicated medical students who are snubbed each year. Why do you need an organization to say "hey, we're better than you". And FYI, I'm not just a hater, I submitted my CV and was nominated. I just wish I had not done it now. Somebody please change my mind.
TLDR; does AOA serve any real purpose as a service or charitable organization?
I ask because I am deciding whether I want to be in AOA or not. Historically, I have been absolutely opposed to joining organizations like this (I refused to join Phi Beta Kappa on the same principle). I genuinely do not understand why AOA exists. If you are in the top of your class, have good board scores, research and volunteer experiences, these things should speak for themselves. Why should you pay money to be in AOA, an organization that's sole purpose seems to be to propagate and celebrate itself and its awesomeness. And yes, i know the obvious answer being because it looks good on your resume.
I am asking this sincerely. I am not trying to be a jerk. I don't know why I feel so strongly about this, but I feel that the sheer existence of something like AOA is wrong because there are so many brilliant, worthy and dedicated medical students who are snubbed each year. Why do you need an organization to say "hey, we're better than you". And FYI, I'm not just a hater, I submitted my CV and was nominated. I just wish I had not done it now. Somebody please change my mind.
TLDR; does AOA serve any real purpose as a service or charitable organization?
Last edited by a moderator: