The fashion industry definitely does its part but rest assured...the reaction of males to prettier girls in person is not lost on any woman. In fact, I never spotted the disturbing differences until a few months ago going out with a...very average looking female friend. Gorgeous body, not so fantastic face...and in every interaction, she's almost immediately friend-zoned. There are certainly guys out there who care more about personality than looks, but they are the minority. And to be fair, she is attracted to nicer looking guys so I'm sure if she would "date down" those guys would jump at it.
Nasrudin would like to believe that women aren't susceptible to looks. Even in the Qur'an the story in which the women, while slicing fruit, cut their hands inadvertently when seeing Joseph walk in the room due to his sheer beauty should clue you in that it's nothing new - ladies are very weak to male beauty. Zulaikha even grabs his shirt out of dear sweet lust, poor thing. Sure, in this day and age and due to historical requirements women had to overlook beauty for other more sensible traits...and many of my friends just think they can't "get" the super hot guy. On 30 Rock, she gets a crazy hot guy but keeps questioning what he actually wants because women are taught to "date down" in looks. But that's who they'd have if they could. Some have just had the luxury of living with self-contentment, as Nasrudin does. And if that's working for him, by all means carry on.
Oh, and this is gonna shock you but...most women aren't interested in "getting a penis whenever she desires'. It doesn't flatter us that men are undiscerning and willing to hop in the sack. What we're really discussing is someone you want to keep around.