wow, it's cool this got a good discussion going
and it's also good to hear I am not the only one finding discrepancies between the review materials. I do find that the PR material has a lot more detail and pick the answer right out of the passage questions, and the EK book tends to have more obscurely worded questions. I too was frustrated in checking answers and disagreeing with what they said was correct. On some of them I felt like the question was so ambiguous that none of the answers fit. Then again I know the book claims to catpure the ambiguity of the real MCAT. The PR stuff seems more straight forward to me.
bottomfeeder, the PR Verbal workbook is a book you get when you sign up to take the class. I think it is good as it has a lot of passages. You can probably find it from someone on here who is selling their PR stuff or maybe on Ebay or half.com. As far as I know you cannot buy this one in a store, you must take the class. and I would totally be willing to discuss verbal questions from the EK book that we have on here. I will probably be doing 1-2 passages a day from it to keep the verbal fresh each day.
And Woolie, I have the same questions you do. I am a big reader, liberal arts major, did well on the SAT Verbal w/o prepping, etc., type of person and I also wonder if doing all these passages will really lead to improvement or if I should focus on the sciences where I know I need to bring up the numbers. I guess my strategy so far has been to do the homework for my PR class, without using their method which I find doesn't do much for me, and just to try to become familiar with the structures of the questions and getting the timing down. Other than that I am not really sure how else to prepare for this part of the MCAT. Hopefully, if I do all the EK 101 passages, and all the PR passages that will be enough.
Well, I'm off to do physics now, my least favorite section. Let's keep posting and keep each other updated on how it is going
Peace.