ESTER - Electron DONATING or WITHDRAWING?

[djsahand]

---

Members do not see this ad.

in the kaplan book it says anything with a Carbonyl is withdrawing (meta director), but in one of the practice tests is that the ester is electron donating (ortho/para).

which is right?
thanks guys

 

[dat_student]

in the kaplan book it says anything with a Carbonyl is withdrawing (meta director), but in one of the practice tests is that the ester is electron donating (ortho/para).

which is right?
thanks guys

depends on the context, they both can be right...Having said that, Kaplan has mistakes and they may be wrong in one of the two cases. Again, it depends on the context.

 

[QofQuimica]

in the kaplan book it says anything with a Carbonyl is withdrawing (meta director), but in one of the practice tests is that the ester is electron donating (ortho/para).

which is right?
thanks guys

It depends on how the ester is connected to the ring. If the carbonyl is directly attached to the ring, it will be a meta-director. But if you have the oxygen attached to the ring (i.e., an acetylated phenol), it will be ortho/para directing.

 

[dat_student]

It depends on how the ester is connected to the ring. If the carbonyl is directly attached to the ring, it will be a meta-director. But if you have the oxygen attached to the ring (i.e., an acetylated phenol), it will be ortho/para directing.

also depends on the reaction type, In one reaction, a compound may be electron withdrawing and in another reaction that same compound may be electron donating and vice versa...

 

[QofQuimica]

also depends on the rxn type, In one rxn, a compound may be electron withdrawing and in another reaction that same compound may be electron donating and vice versa...

lol, I'm sorry, but although your posts are in perfectly grammatical English, I can't make any sense of them. Would you explain what you mean or maybe give an example?

 

[dat_student]

lol, I'm sorry, but although your posts are in perfectly grammatical English, I can't make any sense of them. Would you explain what you mean or maybe give an example?

which part of my explanation is not clear to you? 😉 I can try another language too

 

[QofQuimica]

which part of my explanation is not clear to you? 😉 I can try another language too

Ok, I am sure now that you are teasing me. And I'd say that you have a great future in writing political speeches if you change your mind about dental school. 😉 😛 Did you check out the subforum? What do you think?

 

[dat_student]

Did you check out the subforum? What do you think?

I'll do that later tonight. Right now, I am too nervous to focus on anything.

I'd say that you have a great future in writing political speeches if you change your mind about dental school. 😉

Seriously, I've already tried biology, astrophysics, chemistry, computer science etc. I've done a little bit of everything in science. I won't mind adding "political science" to the list. I am interested in anything that is directly or indirectly related to science.

 

[QofQuimica]

Seriously, I've already tried biology, astrophysics, chemistry, computer science etc. I've done a little bit of everything in science. I won't mind adding "political science" to the list. I am interested in anything that is directly or indirectly related to science.

Hmm, you've barely scratched the surface of possibilities. What about philosophy of science? Christian science? Science fiction? Mad science? (Bwah hah hah hah.)

 

[dat_student]

Hmm, you've barely scratched the surface of possibilities. What about philosophy of science? Christian science? Science fiction? Mad science? (Bwah hah hah hah.)

true, many possibilities. I'll be a science student forever.

 

[QofQuimica]

true, many possibilities. I'll be a science student forever.

lol, don't worry, you'd have lots of company. Anyway, it's more fun to be a student than it is to have a job. 😛

 

[dat_student]

lol, don't worry, you'd have lots of company. Anyway, it's more fun to be a student than it is to have a job. 😛

...and it's more fun to have a job than it is to have a wife I have had jobs too, all research and teaching jobs, no exceptions (i.e. excluding volunteer works). A student with my GPA shouldn't even be qualified as a teacher. Shame on them !