I just got into this program and the Cincinnati one too..still waiting to hear on the other apps I submitted. Does anyone know how they compare?
IMHO you can't go wrong with either one.
EVMS and Cinci are as close as you can get to linkage, as far as true SMP programs go. Both are very small class sizes when compared to Gtown or BU, and both have great percentages when it comes to getting their SMP students into medical school.
Agree.
From what I understand, however, is EVMS is mainly geared toward producing primary care physicians. That is not to say, however, that you cannot enter into any specialty of your choice coming from EVMS medical school, but you may gain more exposure to different fields at Cinci.
IMHO when a school says it's primary care focused, it's not talking to premeds. The school is talking to the state and its taxpayers, partially to get funding, and partially to answer for how the school is addressing the lack of primary care providers in the state. Private schools get state funding too, and are under the gun to have an answer to the primary care problem. But this is all just talk: there is no obligation for a student to pick primary care. There are usually optional rural/primary activities, rotations, etc. but a "primary care school" still has to put you through your surgery rotations and give you electives, and their match lists have ROADs. I have yet to see a med school, other than LECOM, actually combine "primary care focus" with "generates primary care physicians" by
changing the curriculum. UWash is the #1 primary care school in the country, and that has
everything to do with
low student debt and
nothing to do with
how students are guided or taught.
When I'm looking at whether a med school prepares its students for a variety of specialties, I'm looking at what hospital(s) host its rotations, and how tightly the school is linked with those hospitals. I can't speak to Cincinnati because it's been a long time since I did this research. For EVMS, in adjacent buildings to the med school, there is a big level 1 trauma tertiary care hospital, a big children's hospital, a bunch of research centers, and multiple clinic buildings. Neither hospital belongs to EVMS, which is less cool than having an "EVMS Medical Center", but I'm not able to come up with a tangible reason why that would matter to a med student on rotations - it's not like the EVMS/Sentara/CHKD relationship is going to disintegrate on a shared campus. EVMS has a community focus, which for a med student means access to public health pathologies and activities without having to invent the wheel. EVMS has an active but limited body of research in progress - tons of reproductive endocrinology, no tropical medicine.
Personally, my current likes are ob/gyn, uro, vascular surgery, colorectal surgery and EM. I'm not looking to publish, I'm not looking to get an MD/PhD, I might want an MPH, and I will be more interested in location than prestige come residency. So: before I went to EVMS I looked at the faculty listings for those departments, and was satisfied when I saw that they
had such departments. After I arrived at EVMS to do the SMP I started getting to know faculty in those departments. I am well-oriented to how I would use EVMS resources to further my selfish needs.
I'm not explaining this to sell EVMS, but to suggest how you might go about assessing which school meets your needs. Think about what you need: if you think you'll want to do peds or a peds specialty, you'll need to notice whether there's a children's hospital at your med school. Hard to argue that you need one during an SMP, regardless. BTW, EVMS has its 2010 match list published on its web page.
But here's the thing, if you don't get into the host school Ucincy will give you a better shot of getting into other schools more so then EVMS.
I think this is true in the sense that more people have heard of UCincinnati than have heard of EVMS (on the west coast, nobody has heard of either, really). But I don't think there's a difference in how each SMP supports same-year apps. Both are good.
EVMS supports its SMP students' apps to other schools with as much aggression as Georgetown (to pick a "good at supporting same-year apps" SMP). The director gets a letter out, as soon as school starts, to explain the program and set expectations to the other med schools to which EVMS SMP students applied. I expect Cincinnati does the same.
Out of 23 students in last years EVMS SMP class, 20 got into med school, and I think 8 went to a med school other than EVMS. Of those 8, rumor has it that 7 also got into EVMS. Compare this to the class page on Cincinnati's site - probably about the same, plus or minus a couple.
I think with either EVMS or Cincinnati, you could make a strong bet that you
can stay at the host med school, which you can't with Gtown.
Also, midlife recently mentioned that EVMS has become a state school and not a private school. So if it is a public school I don't know how that will affect acceptances into their med school from doing that program. I don't know though. Perhaps she can give better insight based on things she's heard.
EVMS is not well known outside VA. Making it public isn't making it less well known.
As with any SMP, if you're the first EVMS SMP student that Upstairs Med School has seen, you carry the burden of explaining what the EVMS SMP is and why Upstairs should take it seriously. If Downstairs Med School already accepted somebody from the EVMS SMP before you showed up, most likely you'll benefit. But any given adcom may have never heard of an SMP. Even GTown SMP students have to explain what an SMP is.
Best of luck to you.