I agree with the last statement... but I think your first statement takes it to an extreme I don't agree with. Basic science would tell us that 1 large meal for the day is not going to yield the same (or even comparable) results as a properly spread diet. I agree that if you are trying to do a perfectly portioned "80" meal a day diet, your compliance rate may become so low that you are gaining no benefits... but in my mind these nutritional and exercise ideals are things to be asymptotically approached. First you get yourself in the gym, and maybe you cut out pizza and soda from your life. A couple months down the road, maybe you start balancing your carb protein ratio a little more and start actually getting on a running schedule. Next thing you know, you are
@The Buff OP (which I imagine took many years of hard work).
Point being, at any point in that process you can stop if you notice it affecting your happiness or compliance. But completely going against the body of health and fitness knowledge seems like a very poor tactic for getting in shape, even if it maintains your compliance. We all know how complying to a poor MCAT study plan ends... and a poor health and fitness program yields similarly dissatisfying results.