Fall WW - Game Thread

[PippyPony]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Not sure he can put it back since he's dead. But I'm not allowed to question you about sketchy on thread actions I guess.

What about that was skEtChY?

Please, enlighten us.

 

[WildZoo]

What about that was skEtChY?

Please, enlighten us.

Telling someone to remove a strategic post that they won't be able to put back? Yes, totally pure behavior.

 

[PippyPony]

Telling someone to remove a strategic post that they won't be able to put back? Yes, totally pure behavior.

So secretive, too. Overwhelmingly subtle strategy!

This is the most angleshooty crap you have used in a long time

 

[WildZoo]

So secretive, too. Overwhelmingly subtle strategy!

This is the most angleshooty crap you have used in a long time

Well then why don't you just tell us what Flushy said, since you saw the post?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Dead is @PippyPony Halloween, a vanillager

Dead is @WildZoo Animal Costume, a vanillager

It is now Day 2.​

Roster
1. @Lawper
2. @mizchiefmanaged
3. @Coopah
4. @genny
7. @nyanko
8. @Ms Procrastinator
9. @kraskadva

Dead
0. FTF - vanillager
6. Pippy - vanillager
5. dubz - vanillager

 

[WildZoo]

******
Wolves have a sense of humor lol
But also sucks, my vacation just started 🙁
******

 

[PippyPony]

*******
Y'all stink like rotted pumpkins -- I asked for this game because it's the only time I'll have to play for months 🙁
*******

 

[PippyPony]

********
Wait, I was going to use this:

*********

 

[kraskadva]

Well that was an aggressive first day... Game won't last long at that rate.

 

[genny]

And it’s going to get a lot quieter with both puppy and ftf gone. 🙁

 

[genny]

I’m kind of lost for where to look next. I was starting to get comfy in that Pippy tunnel.

 

[kraskadva]

IDK Coops kinda feisty and defensive too, but that's clearly not definitive

 

[Lawpy]

so that double kill is frustrating especially it took out two active villagers

 

[Lawpy]

I think Coops is village from her posts and interactions. It feels similar to village Coops in past games

 

[Lawpy]

Hmm thinking but for now:

lynch genny

 

[genny]

Hmm thinking but for now:

lynch genny

Sure, if your goal is to lynch villagers. IDK why you think I’d kill Dubz and Pippy in one night. That’s just not me as a wolf.

 

[genny]

You know who would kill Dubz and Pippy though? Someone who was scared they might find him out.

 

[Coopah]

IDK Coops kinda feisty and defensive too, but that's clearly not definitive

Hi! That's me in a nutshell lol

 

[kraskadva]

Yeah, IDK, that was some serious sniping of talkative folks. I think I'd expect it to come from the more quiet contingent.

 

[Coopah]

You know who would kill Dubz and Pippy though? Someone who was scared they might find him out.

What are you thinking? I went back and read all of dubz's posts and she never really called anyone out

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Wait what the **** just happened? Two kills in one night in a game this size? Chaos? Vig? One wolf with two NKs each night?

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

I thought Pip was village because I’ve seen her try to pocket when she’s 3P or wolf. Early on she seems to lay off the sass a little bit and I wasnt getting that vibe from her.

 

[genny]

What are you thinking? I went back and read all of dubz's posts and she never really called anyone out

Lawpy. He’s a nervous wolf, and would be worried about Pip or Dubz.

Cray, if she was playing, would also do something like this.

And honestly, Pippy called you out. So I can’t put you in my village pile just yet.

 

[Lawpy]

Sure, if your goal is to lynch villagers. IDK why you think I’d kill Dubz and Pippy in one night. That’s just not me as a wolf.

NKA is tricky and WIFOMy. The conclusion I'm able to draw is wolves targeted active players in hopes of coasting through the game easily. Which is annoying because it has happened regularly recently.

I think you're being retaliatory and your interactions with Pippy are a bit unsettling.

 

[Coopah]

Lawpy. He’s a nervous wolf, and would be worried about Pip or Dubz.

Cray, if she was playing, would also do something like this.

And honestly, Pippy called you out. So I can’t put you in my village pile just yet.

Valid, I had her a wolfy with all the extra sass but I suppose I was wrong. I would definately kill pip as a wolf but I would never kill dubz, she's good to keep around because I can pocket her so I wouldn't approve that kill. But also I understand night kill analysis is never 100% and certainly not clearable, just a counterargument.

 

[genny]

NKA is tricky and WIFOMy. The conclusion I'm able to draw is wolves targeted active players in hopes of coasting through the game easily. Which is annoying because it has happened regularly recently.

I think you're being retaliatory and your interactions with Pippy are a bit unsettling.

I don’t think Dubz was particularly active D1.

 

[genny]

I think you're being retaliatory and your interactions with Pippy are a bit unsettling.

And you honestly think I’d kill her for that? I thought she was a wolf, so try reading my interactions with her through that lens.

 

[Coopah]

@Ms Procrastinator what are your reads?

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Would like to hear from Kras again.

 

[kraskadva]

I'm on long call today, so I've been in and out...
But I think miz calling me out, and not saying much else, is suspicious.
Ny not really contributing at all raises flags for me too.

 

[genny]

Wait what the **** just happened? Two kills in one night in a game this size? Chaos? Vig? One wolf with two NKs each night?

I don’t know why I didn’t think about a vig. It would be nice if they would speak up if that’s what happened.

 

[Coopah]

I don’t know why I didn’t think about a vig. It would be nice if they would speak up if that’s what happened.

I'd like to clarify that a one shot vig should speak up. Otherwise keep your mouth shut and pick better targets dum dum

 

[Coopah]

I'm on long call today, so I've been in and out...
But I think miz calling me out, and not saying much else, is suspicious.
Ny not really contributing at all raises flags for me too.

So you think people saying your suspicious is suspicious? Also Ny is notoriously a low poster and that is completely normal. Not saying she's not a wolf, no way to know, but that activity level is normal.

 

[kraskadva]

So you think people saying your suspicious is suspicious? Also Ny is notoriously a low poster and that is completely normal. Not saying she's not a wolf, no way to know, but that activity level is normal.

Not necessarily, since that's the name of the game, but doing nothing but picking on the noob, isn't very reassuring.
And idk what's normal for any of y'all, outside of some of the 2ndhand lounge chatter about games that I've heard over the years, so I'm just doing a cold read on what I see.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Not necessarily, since that's the name of the game, but doing nothing but picking on the noob, isn't very reassuring.
And idk what's normal for any of y'all, outside of some of the 2ndhand lounge chatter about games that I've heard over the years, so I'm just doing a cold read on what I see.

You’re awfully touchy for me just saying I’d like to hear from you again. I haven’t even put a vote your way today. Not picking on you, want to hear more.

I do agree with you wanting to hear more from nyan. She was fairly active last game and I liked it lol

 

[kraskadva]

You’re awfully touchy for me just saying I’d like to hear from you again. I haven’t even put a vote your way today. Not picking on you, want to hear more.

I do agree with you wanting to hear more from nyan. She was fairly active last game and I liked it lol

You also voted to lynch me yesterday for no particular reason, so...

 

[Coopah]

Not necessarily, since that's the name of the game, but doing nothing but picking on the noob, isn't very reassuring.
And idk what's normal for any of y'all, outside of some of the 2ndhand lounge chatter about games that I've heard over the years, so I'm just doing a cold read on what I see.

Which is why I'm pointing out normal for you 🙂

 

[Coopah]

You also voted to lynch me yesterday for no particular reason, so...

I thought she justified her vote? That's not no particular reason in my book, even if she is wrong, which I'm not convinced of but again staying away... far away

 

[Coopah]

Lynch lawper

he seems mildly panicked

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

You also voted to lynch me yesterday for no particular reason, so...

I put lynch votes on people to pressure them. I can’t get a feel for a new person if I’m unable to put any pressure on them to see how they respond.

 

[Lawpy]

I don’t think Dubz was particularly active D1.

she provided some content even though she was busy and her insights that I thought were useful. also she tagged people (I think nyans who came back online). so I think she was among the more active members.

And you honestly think I’d kill her for that? I thought she was a wolf, so try reading my interactions with her through that lens.

i feel she might have made you feel more concerned

 

[Lawpy]

Lynch lawper

he seems mildly panicked

i'm sad (and also distracted by a random thread in allo and memes). I don't like when active players get killed. I thought FTFlushy was village and he got lynched despite his being active and sharing his thoughts. Then Pippy and WZ were discussing and had some disagreements and both ended up killed. I made it clear before and I'm restating now that I dislike active players getting killed because it gives the impression of wolves trying to coast things easily by suppressing conversation. i'm sad and frustrated not panicked.

 

[Coopah]

i'm sad (and also distracted by a random thread in allo and memes). I don't like when active players get killed. I thought FTFlushy was village and he got lynched despite his being active and sharing his thoughts. Then Pippy and WZ were discussing and had some disagreements and both ended up killed. I made it clear before and I'm restating now that I dislike active players getting killed because it gives the impression of wolves trying to coast things easily by suppressing conversation. i'm sad and frustrated not panicked.

Who do you think is wolfy?

 

[Lawpy]

Who do you think is wolfy?

genny and nyans.

 

[kraskadva]

genny and nyans.

Reasons?

 

[kraskadva]

I put lynch votes on people to pressure them. I can’t get a feel for a new person if I’m unable to put any pressure on them to see how they respond.

That's a reasonable strategy...I still feel mildly miffed though.

 

[Coopah]

genny and nyans.

Why?

 

[Coopah]

That's a reasonable strategy...I still feel mildly miffed though.

Why? I get that anyone "going after you" seems to be inherently wolfy but you've got to drop it. Now if you can point out flaws in logic or know their meta or something else feel free to kick up a **** storm. Just my two cents said with love 🙂

 

[Coopah]

Heard from everyone except @nyanko and @Ms Procrastinator. Please come by when you have a chance and help us string helpless victims... I mean potential wolves up for lynch eh?

Is that enough tags Ny? No? Lol

 

[Coopah]

@mizchiefmanaged who are your reads besides fresh meat?