I just want to share this to put things in perspective...
My brother went to Intarmed in UP Manila. I went to Princeton University in New Jersey, magna cum laude. Itinuloy na ng brother ko yung Med nya sa UP Manila, although he could have went sa UCLA or Mt. Sinai. -- first choices nya. Why in UP? Low cost. The money he could've spent in medical school here in the States, he used them to travel around the world after he finished his MD. He finished all his Steps before his year-long world tour and started his residency training here after that. He is now doing his masters while specializing. Sabi nya, iba daw talaga ang mga students sa UP. I never thought and imagined the height of arrogance based sa mga stories nya. In his best friends' own words, nag-Intarmed din, ignorance-based yung arrogance ng mga taga-UP, para daw lumalabas na napaka-great accomplishment nung Intarmed, ang dali naman daw makapasok. Meron din daw na direct from high school to Medicine sa Australia, UK, Ireland, and even in the States, na mas mahirap pa ang entrance requirements. Sa UP daw, madali makapasok, ang nagpahirap lang daw kasi 40 lang ang kukunin! Kaya sabi nya, it's ridiculous, kasi they could choose 20 lang, or 10 lang, so does that make them special ? Napaka-arbitrary. Marami daw classmates nila sa Intarmed bumabagsak naman once they are in. Yung UPCAT daw hindi reliable predictor. Sa Chemistry daw ang daming bumabagsak na Intarmed students. Pero tuloy pa rin daw. Maraming brighter students na hindi nag-apply sa Intarmed. Pero what my brother and his friends didn't like, yung arrogance daw ng mga students sa UP Manila, and we compared the students from Princeton, Harvard and MIT, malayong-malayo. Sa Philippines lang daw ang UP, there is no comparison, not even a margin of comparison sa Ivy League schools dito. More so dun sa attitude and personality ng mga students. Ang comparison lang daw ng UP is with a 4th-tier university sa States, and malaki pa rin daw ang gap, as in malaking-malaki. Also, yung mga arrogant and conceited daw sa UP Med na kilala nila, they re-wrote their USMLE Steps more than once. Bagsak daw sa pre-clinical Steps, merong 3rd timer pa nga sa Step 2. Ang curriculum daw sa UP Med (and I don't know about other schools) is geared towards memorizing things and knowing raw facts, the danger is a lot of these facts will be obsolete as new research will supersede those that were previously known. Very weak daw sa research ang UP, and iba daw talaga ang approach ng mga students sa research. Iba pa rin daw ang thinking pattern. In preparing for USMLE, it takes a year, sometimes over a year mag-prepare yung UP Med students bago makapasa. Ang tagal, several months, a year or over a year, compared sa few weeks lang for other test-takers in the States. But most UP students are so cocky in an obnoxious way. My brother and his friends did not like the student atmosphere in UP. Kaya nag-masters silang lahat dito para mapatungan daw ng American degree yung degree nila sa Philippines. Yung entrance requirement lang daw ng UP ang source ng "perceived cream of the crop" ng mga students, pero mababang mababa pa rin daw compared sa International standards. Yung SAT daw, six times harder than UPCAT. My brother took SAT din. The entrance req in UP is higher than in other schools because it's taxpayers' money, very tight ang number of students na kukunin. But as university, for research and other aspects, UP is below mediocrity. This is from the views of people who have international exposure and experience. The clinical portion of UP Medicine is also very shallow, again by International standards.
And yung daw mga fil-am rich students sa UP ang nasasabihang mayayabang. But, it is the other way around. According to our fil-am family friends (who also went to UP), being a rich student in UP is perceived by local poor students as non-deserving. The rich students actually find the local poor ones very conceited, arrogant, assuming, and obnoxious. When confronted, the poor ones assume the "victim" status or "oppressed", when in fact, they started the act of provoking.
All these happen in third world country. I have lived on/off in the Philippines, and I just noticed that all my friends that I have invited sa Resort namin in the Philippines all came from wealthy families, that's by chance, because I actually select based on attitudes not on economic means. But it's probably by no chance, because local students who are not wealthy, who have no international exposure and experience, are the ones who show conceit, inappropriate attitude, lame arrogance, and pettiness. The fil-ams don't judge the locals, the locals judge the fil-ams. I'm just glad I didn't go to UP, coming from my brother and his friends who all went to UP from Intarmed to their MDs, they all prefer the students' attitude in the States, not cocky or arrogant, just plain and simple. Fil-ams who have lived in the States know what "quality" in education, attitude, and personality mean, and UP students shouldn't flatter themselves at that, because one has to go by international standards, and UP certainly is way way down in the list. A UP student who will make a contrary claim will only reinforce his/her ignorance of international standards that are in place. Viewed from outside Philippines, the quality is substandard. But it's the bargain that people are going after, knowing that beyond that, success becomes individual-based. The locals should acknowledge this reality (instead of bragging) and from here, how the health care system in the Philippines can be bettered (from being poor). It is ridiculous and sickening that a UP student mindset such as some found from this forum, perpetuates and continues to play out in governance and bureaucratic system in the country. From my brother's own words, who is a medical doctor from UP and public health specialist, the problem with the Philippines, amongst other things, is the problem of poor attitudes and mindsets of those who, while the taxpayers pay for their education, are missing the whole point of having a state university in the Philippines. Decades upon decades, this country has steadily been going downhill. The students' mindset says a lot and is but a mere reflection of the future of this country.
Fil-am