Fire HD or Kindle?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Spirit of the Student Doc

Worrying will never change the outcome
7+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
987
Reaction score
233
Has anyone used these effectively for any sort of studying or note taking? I'm on the fence about buying one (probably a fire hd 6 for reading) and I see some reviews talking about using this to study?

Members don't see this ad.
 
I have a kindle. I don't recommend it for studying. Kindle has a small screen so big textbooks don't work quite well. You have to zoom in/zoom out and kindle is very slow doing that . A real book is still better for studying. Kindle is only good for leisure reading. JMO.
 
I have a kindle. I don't recommend it for studying. Kindle has a small screen so big textbooks don't work quite well. You have to zoom in/zoom out and kindle is very slow doing that . A real book is still better for studying. Kindle is only good for leisure reading. JMO.

Yeah, I'm probably going to buy it for leisure reading and maybe streaming music.

I read about taking notes in class w/ this,with a stylus, and I'm not sure how realistic it is. Worst case I read a bunch of books on it 😉
 
Members don't see this ad :)
So I ended up buying a Kindle Fire HDX.... figure I can do some outside reading. Cost me $212 w/ case and stylus vs $150 w/ case and stylus for the 16gb Fire.... but I figure I got a decent deal.

Edit: Cost me $188... bought the 16gb Kindle Fire HDX and a case that comes w/ a stylus.

Mostly I want something I can use on long flights and to be able to read books w/

It was either this or the kindle paperwhite.... but I figure this has some extra uses.

-As for school, I really just wanted to be able to take notes and have access to google w/out having to pull my laptop out every time (I take notes by hand but occasionally for some classes that isn't feasible and sometimes I'm so far underground that I can't access the internet w/ my cellphone.)

-This lacks features like google play and the OS is laughable. But it's significantly cheaper than the competition the screen is amazingly well done and I wasn't about to throw down 400+ for something that's only playing second fiddle to my laptop (which I spent significantly more on... around $800).
 
Last edited:
Sounds like a decent choice. I'm not familiar with Kindles or Fires, but do they let you download from the Play store or just Amazon's App store? Android and Apple devices are much more useful than the black/white kindles if you plan to use it in medical school, especially due to the app stores. I use my Samsung Galaxy Note 8 for reading PDF textbooks (and you need color for some of the diagrams, histology, etc.), to pull up medical calculators, to quickly google info, to take UWorld exams and to connect to the hospital's EMR system via Citrix. Others have Netter's Anatomy installed. I doubt the black/white kindles are capable of that. This might be premature though if you're not yet in med school as they will probably come up with much nicer devices in a few years.

The Galaxy Note has a minor benefit in that it has a Wacom digitizer, which allows you to get more accurate handwriting vs. the nubby stylus used for other devices. Granted, it's still not very good at taking handwritten notes compared to paper and pen. For studying, reading PDFs tend to be very responsive, but paper is still more comfortable. It's great, however, when you need to search keywords.
 
Top