why are you so ultra pro USF? i have to say, it seems like your biased to it strongly, did you attend there school, are you planning on attending their school, i know there is something to this
Its not that I'm biased towards USF as I'd have a hard time deciding between Miami and USF if I got in both. Its that I know more about their program because as an undergrad I spent a lot of time shadowing and helping others to find shadowing experiences with physicians around here, I spent a lot of time talking with adcoms at med school forums to get a feel for the school and felt USF was very straight forward and friendly/approachable vs. some of the other schools. Miami was approachable/friendly and seemed like a nice place for med school too, but places like say UF don't really rub me the right way with their we are better then everyone else attitude and their way of dancing around the issues when you ask them simple questions or the fact that from my friends who've interviewed there I've heard that they went in there with good impression and left with a bad one. In one case the person had an interview from hell and in the other case the person told me that the school had a knack for putting down other schools including HMS.
Also, I think UF is good if you want to be an academic physician and researcher, but I don't think they have the clinical diversity of either Miami or USF and felt that at most of these forums and from everything people have told me, it seemed like their M1 and M2 clinical opportunities are not as great as, again, USF or Miami. Furthermore, where USF and Miami will ease you into the program and take more integrative approaches, I think UF takes a more "let's dumb the hardest stuff from day one" sort of approach in their curricula.
That's why I don't say much in favor of UF. As per FSU, I don't think I'd mind going there because they seem to have a good learning atmosphere, but the fact that they are relatively new and require you to leave Tallahassee and go somewhere way out far for the clinicals kind of concerns me a bit. They need to develop stronger relations with the hospitals in the Tallahassee area as well as other clinical facilities closer to their school instead of sending students all the way to Orlando and Sarasota amonsgt other places. So that's why you don't hear me say much in favor of them. Also, they were built with goals of producing primary care physicians and physicians for rural medicine, and I'm not sure that that is what I want to do, so that is another strike against why I don't speak much in favor of FSU.
I'd speak more about Miami if I had the same knowledge base as I do of USF's program, but I feel there are more qualified people to answer questions on Miami's program who are either undergrads and have met with the deans and staff there and done work with their med school in the form of research or volunteering in their hospitals, or better yet the students there. On the other hand, I tend to know a lot about USF both from friends and interaction with the adcom members.
If you wanted my opinion of schools though, I'd say I'm tied between Miami main campus and USF, then Boca, then FSU, and really don't like UF even if I had the stats to get in there because i've been given a negative impression of them one too many times both through my interaction with people from UF during med school forums and through what I've heard from other friends who interviewed there.