This process seriously cannot be wholly predicted or understood by us mere mortals!
(emphasis mine)
This bears repeating. By the application to admission ratios, I was, oh, an order of magnitude more likely to get in to VMRCVM as a MD resident than to UC Davis as an OOS applicant, but I was waitlisted at VMRCVM and accepted to UC Davis. You can get a general sense of what is a good bet and what is not from looking at past applicant stats, etc., but do not count on the schools to fall in line with your expectations!
These are the criteria I used for selecting schools -- somewhat random, but, hey, you have to narrow it down somehow from 28 schools. I also posted a thread on here and got suggestions about where to apply.
1. Climate: I, too, did not think I wanted to live in the South for 4 years of school. For one thing, it gets too (expletive) hazy, hot, n' humid and stays that way for too much of the year. I'll take snow over 90* and 90% humidity. Davis, CA, may be a bit hot for me, but it's a dry heat,
so you can actually use evaporative cooling.
2. Preconceived (possibly ill-conceived?) notions about strength of equine programs and the general equine industry in certain states
3. Number of OOS applicants taken, with a few "reach" schools (they're all reach schools, really, just some more than others) thrown in just to see what happened
My list:
1. VMRCVM - IS, obvious choice
2. UPenn - relatively large fraction of class is OOS; New Bolton Center; close to home (closer than VA Tech); actually liked atmosphere around school when I visited!
3. Cornell - not likely to get in, but I liked the fact that they have a long-running, well-established PBL-based curriculum
4. Michigan - at least prior to economy going in toilet, had a growing horse industry; heard good things about equine people at VTH; decent # of OOS'ers
5. Minnesota - same as Mich.; also, does not take grades (my weak point) in to consideration for final admissions decisions
6. Iowa - new LA facility; large LA caseload; lots of OOS'ers
7. Illinois - same as Minnesota
8. CSU - why not? I could win the lottery, too, while I'm at it. Famous for equine sports med, etc. Close to sister.
9. UC Davis - um, dream school since I first talked to a friend who did her LA IM residency there, not that I'd have any chance of getting in, right?
There were others on my long list, too, like WI and Tufts, but I pretty much randomly cut it down to 9 after seeing how much work and money it was to do the supplementals, send test scores, etc.