forum died hard

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
rads22222 said:
rads forum died hard in the aftermath of the ROL ordeal, lol. I've never seen a thread so quiet.

good luck in the match everyone
Click to expand...

I think honest mistakes were made by admin., but they tried to rectify. There is a valuable lesson to be learned here. I doubt anything like this would happen again, and Im sure they wish they could go back in time and act differently.

Are we beyond forgiveness? Lets hope not, bc all humans are prone to mistakes, right?

Zero chance you get banned: freedom of expression is intrinsic to SDN's fiber.
 
Last edited:
Light at end of tunnel said:
I think honest mistakes were made by admin., but they tried to rectify. There is a valuable lesson to be learned here. I doubt anything like this would happen again, and Im sure they wish they could go back in time and act differently.

Are we beyond forgiveness? Lets hope not, bc all humans are prone to mistakes, right?
Click to expand...
what are their plans to rectify this situation
 
The decision to remove the thread was incorrect. Winged Scapula and I have discussed it.

I apologize for this event and hope that members continue to support the nonprofit mission of SDN.

There are many forums available for students and doctors. SDN is the only forum created by students and physicians for the sole purpose of helping other students become doctors. We've fought for years and spent thousands in legal expenses to defend our members from schools, organizations, and residency programs that don't want honest and open discussion.

I know this decision was damaging and betrayed the trust of my fellow members. SDN must continue to be a place where all members can discuss openly, anonymously and free.

Please contact me if you have concerns or questions.
 
rads22222 said:
rads forum died hard in the aftermath of the ROL ordeal, lol. I've never seen a thread so quiet.

good luck in the match everyone
Click to expand...

Most people that were planning to post their ROL already did. It definitely created a lot of confusion when the thread was deleted but I think Lee and WS have done their best to fix things. Hopefully people will feel inclined to post after the match. SDN has been a great resource from pre-med til now, for me at least. Let's try to continue that for future applicants.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Yeah, I think the situation may have been blown out of proportion. It's sad to see the forum so dead with all this free 4th year time.
 
Really I think that the biggest issue is that most of the regular posters already put up their rank order list and right now there isn't much to talk about. I know that I didn't take incredibly detailed notes so it's also fairly difficult for me to give program reviews (despite me being fairly anonymous) this late after interview season; some people may have a better memory and post them once we match, but for now it doesn't seem to be a priority.
 
radsisrad said:
Wrong.
Click to expand...

You've gotta explain what you mean here.

Keep in mind that I had my account held for 2 weeks some time ago, so I have first hand knowledge of how it feels to be "censored."

But honestly, they have to draw the line somewhere and maintain forum decorum.

Otherwise, with the amount of flaming, trolling, and spamming that CAN happen with these types of public sharing sites, SDN would effectively cease to offer a meaningful forum at all.
 
Last edited:
Light at end of tunnel said:
You've gotta explain what you mean here.

Keep in mind that I had my account held for 2 weeks some time ago, so I have first hand knowledge of how it feels to be "censored."

But honestly, they have to draw the line somewhere and maintain forum decorum.

Otherwise, with the amount of flaming, trolling, and spamming that CAN happen with these types of public sharing sites, SDN would effectively cease to offer a meaningful forum at all.
Click to expand...
im curious, what did you do to warrant that sort of punishment? I've crossed many lines on forum so far and people gave me over 300 likes. some even PM me their pet's pictures.
 
I wanna know about the fiasco...
 
Light at end of tunnel said:
I'm confused. Are you saying you think cats/dogs should be consumed in the western world or that they should be held in higher regard?

I mean, if I were starving and I had no other choice...you do what you gotta do.
Click to expand...
consumed. my fellow americans and village folks in the western world continuously stereotype ppl from the east for eating dogs, etc, but they dont realize that folks are starvng and they will eat whatever animal they can find. im just amused at how ignorant and hypocritical the world is.
 
Beezlebub said:
in the past yeah. brah i can sense the bait a mile away. it makes no difference, if im starving with nothing to eat and there's a dog in front of me, it's BBQ time. common sense.
Click to expand...

Just stay away from my dog.
 
Beezlebub said:
in the past yeah. brah i can sense the bait a mile away. it makes no difference, if im starving with nothing to eat and there's a dog in front of me, it's BBQ time. common sense.
Click to expand...

Would you eat another human if you were starving? Serious question, same argument


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
RadGod1 said:
Would you eat another human if you were starving? Serious question, same argument


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
Click to expand...
i'd be significantly more deterred to eat my species. honestly, i cant answer that question, hopefully that scenario will never arise. i had this debate last night in another thread.

here's an interesting story about a group of people crash landed on the andes. had to resort to eating dead bodies b/c they had no other option in order to survive.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uruguayan_Air_Force_Flight_571

what would you do in order to survive?
 
I don't "get" this controversy. People were account sharing. You're not supposed to do that. It's not that hard. Separately, it's amusing to me how the radiology forum uses anonymous accounts so much and has large megathreads of program reviews, more than most/any other specialties. Why is that? There's also the weird obsession with program rankings and tiers.

Maybe I missed those threads in other forums.
 
meister said:
I don't "get" this controversy. People were account sharing. You're not supposed to do that. It's not that hard. Separately, it's amusing to me how the radiology forum uses anonymous accounts so much and has large megathreads of program reviews, more than most/any other specialties. Why is that? There's also the weird obsession with program rankings and tiers.

Maybe I missed those threads in other forums.
Click to expand...

Radiology people are nerds. Simple as that.
 
meister said:
I don't "get" this controversy. People were account sharing. You're not supposed to do that. It's not that hard. Separately, it's amusing to me how the radiology forum uses anonymous accounts so much and has large megathreads of program reviews, more than most/any other specialties. Why is that? There's also the weird obsession with program rankings and tiers.

Maybe I missed those threads in other forums.
Click to expand...
Are there really that few reviews in other specialties? I feel like that many rads programs aren't reviewed
 
What was the fiasco?
 
what is rol?
 
rank order list
 
If you all want to discuss programs and leave feedback for future applicants, there are urology and dermatology google docs that have been created that allow applicants to do this. One of you may want to consider creating one: it allows for an anonymous discussion and it does not get SDN in trouble
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Foot Fetish
Is radiology *hard* ?
Replies
3
Views
25K
scootad.
S
R
  • Poll Poll
PGY1 Preferences -- Elite/Hard Prelim vs. Ultra-Cush TY Internship
Replies
7
Views
3K
jake2
jake2
U
Bummed about my prelim spot. For those of you that did hard intern years...
2 3 4
Replies
155
Views
31K
elegantorchid
E
D
How hard is radiology to match into?
Replies
26
Views
30K
copes
C
F
Hardest case today...
Replies
0
Views
1K
futurdoc12345
F
Top Bottom