- Joined
- Aug 1, 2007
- Messages
- 346
- Reaction score
- 3
Anyone care to share their experiences? What is the best way to recover/cope? I think this would just kill my confidence and make me perform even worse.
what are you expecting to be asked that you have no idea how to answer?
if they're asking about you, you should always know the answer
yeah, I had a guy tell me his interview involved some guy asking him to give his impressions on some artwork he had around his office.Do a search for oddest interview question or look through the SDN interview feedback page. They do ask some very strange questions sometimes. You don't always discuss you at the interview. Any topic is fair game. I think alot of people have problems when given an ethical question they haven't considered.
yeah, I had a guy tell me his interview involved some guy asking him to give his impressions on some artwork he had around his office.
I guess I just don't have a problem with saying I don't know the answer to something.
the question i had a hard time answering was "so you want to be a doctor, huh?"
obviously i can write a 5300 characters on this, but when it actually came to saying it out loud, i just froze. i mean, i had practiced and everything. sometimes the luck isn't there...
👍 I dont know if it ends up looking good, but since most of the interviewers claim the questions are open-ended, I have no problem rephrasing a question myself...hehe. That happened at my last interview. He asked "if not a physician, what would you do?"...i wasnt prepared to dance around the issue that I would do anything to find a way into healthcare, so I said "well, if the medical field never existed, I would..." 😎 It was awesome, he went with it, and the way I answered it really helped me better answer his counter "so you wouldnt do research?" (I have a research background).Anyway, a more directed question like "how did you get from your prior career to medicine?" gives me less trouble for some reason. Maybe I should just pretend that's what I've been asked.
it really is the hardest question to answer. how do you describe a natural instinct or something like that?the question i had a hard time answering was "so you want to be a doctor, huh?"
obviously i can write a 5300 characters on this, but when it actually came to saying it out loud, i just froze. i mean, i had practiced and everything. sometimes the luck isn't there...
That's what I'm afraid will happen at my first interview. I'm a non-trad, and have a lot of ground to cover with my answer to that question, and I'm worried that I'll just..... Ugh. And yes, I've done a mock interview with someone from my pre-health committee (they said I did well) and have practiced. I thought I had it nailed, and then recently when I went to practice my answer with my mom, I...well, kind of talked myself into a corner and froze. I needed to go back farther in my history, I think. Anyway, a more directed question like "how did you get from your prior career to medicine?" gives me less trouble for some reason. Maybe I should just pretend that's what I've been asked. Regardless, I obviously need to practice more. But this is why I'm a firm believer that if it's at all possible, try not to have one of your top choices be your first interview.
thanks, I dont feel like much of an idiot anymore.it really is the hardest question to answer. how do you describe a natural instinct or something like that?
It seems like a lot of people have that one special incident that miraculously convinced them to spend the rest of their 'prime years' in school, acquire massive debt, work upwards of 60 hrs/wk (after the 80+hrs/wk in residency), etc. This is a major commitment in life with plenty of pros and cons, and it's not exactly something you can easily summarize at an interview without sounding superficial (I love science, I love helping people, etc).
wtf is "Tell me about yourself" supposed to be? that's the biggest BS question I've ever seen
I wrote an entire essay and filled out 12+ pages of an application telling you about me.
If I was interviewing someone, I'd rather they look a little nervous, stutter a bit sometimes, and actually seem like they are fishing around for their answers once in a while. I'm sure they are pretty sick of the perfect pre-meds who waltz in all fat and cocky with their programmed responses; I know I would be. I'd accept someone who is giving me who they really are in the interview, even if if means they choke a little, over some guy/girl whom I can't read because they practiced what they were going to tell me 15 times with mommy.
Sometimes the interviewers don't get to see that.wtf is "Tell me about yourself" supposed to be? that's the biggest BS question I've ever seen
I wrote an entire essay and filled out 12+ pages of an application telling you about me.
Not that I practiced with my mom, but there's no need to be condescending to people who are well-prepared for this. It would be stupid to go into a med school interview cold, without any preparation, and I don't feel sorry for someone who doesn't get accepted if they didn't bother to prepare themselves at least a fair amount. This is like saying that we should all take the MCAT without studying in advance.because they practiced what they were going to tell me 15 times with mommy.
Just don't pull a miss teen usa if you're drawing a blank!!
anybody else youtube it? f-ing hilarious!
That's what I'm afraid will happen at my first interview. I'm a non-trad, and have a lot of ground to cover with my answer to that question, and I'm worried that I'll just..... Ugh. And yes, I've done a mock interview with someone from my pre-health committee (they said I did well) and have practiced. I thought I had it nailed, and then recently when I went to practice my answer with my mom, I...well, kind of talked myself into a corner and froze. I needed to go back farther in my history, I think. Anyway, a more directed question like "how did you get from your prior career to medicine?" gives me less trouble for some reason. Maybe I should just pretend that's what I've been asked. Regardless, I obviously need to practice more. But this is why I'm a firm believer that if it's at all possible, try not to have one of your top choices be your first interview.
You GOTTA rehearse the answers to the most common questions (and by rehearse, I mean actually say it out loud - don't just think about it in your head. Practice with a friend, a family member, even in front of a mirror!):
*Why do you want to be a doctor?
*Why are you applying to our school?
*What are your strengths and weaknesses?
*Tell me about yourself.
*Where do you see yourself in 10-15 years?
*What will you do if you don't get into medical school this year?
Practice, practice, practice!
wtf is "Tell me about yourself" supposed to be? that's the biggest BS question I've ever seen
I wrote an entire essay and filled out 12+ pages of an application telling you about me.
My trick, OP. Nod, smile, look pensive and ask if you can come back to the question later. The catch is that you really DO have to answer the question before you leave and you better answer it well when you do since you've been given some extra time.
My trick, OP. Nod, smile, look pensive and ask if you can come back to the question later. The catch is that you really DO have to answer the question before you leave and you better answer it well when you do since you've been given some extra time.
anyone else every do this? i didnt think that was ok to do
Well okay perhaps I should use an example.I wouldn't recommend doing that if the question is "Why medicine?" Regardless, I'd rather repeat the question to buy a little more time, look pensive for a moment, and then just give it my best shot. But that's me.
I think humor is the best way to handle it. If you freeze or say something silly, then laugh, and tell the interviewer something along these lines: "You can obviously see that I'm really nervous, because I really want to come to this school." And then you can steer the discussion toward something to do with what you like about the school.Anyone care to share their experiences? What is the best way to recover/cope? I think this would just kill my confidence and make me perform even worse.
Oh, and I'm surprised no one else has mentioned this yet, but you should also read the interview feedback for that school on SDN. In my experience, the same questions from previous years tend to be repeated, so you'll have a pretty good idea of what to expect if you do that.humor fosho
i froze up a bit at my first interview. i'm not talking bad though. i stopped to think for a few seconds before answering instead of spewing out a prethought answer.
you shouldn't even get to this point unless they ask some vague unexpected questions. mine weren't the typical questions that we prep for.
if you freeze up on why medicine and describe yourself, that could be trouble.
Jolie, what weird questions have you gotten so far?
Probably because they went through the process so recently, student interviewers tend to expect BS, and aren't as likely to believe a sincere response.
Wow. That sucks. I'm sure your doing great, though! Good luck for the rest of your (multitudes of) interviews. I hope you don't get any more jaded and snarky students!
plus, when i talked about it to other interviewees they were like totally freaked out. like "i don't stand a chance if these are the people i'm interviewing with"
Well, I certainly wouldn't want to be the one walking into the interviewer's office after you walked out.... 😉