You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Funny Question
Started by dat_student
dat_student said:We have 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3]2- in a solution. What is the molarity of the solution?
H2CO3 -> H+ + HCO3- -> H+ + [CO3]2-
Is the answer 1 M?
seoul said:I think [H2CO3]=4.46 x 10^18 M would be more likely if I understand your question correctly...
No, How can one have 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3 ]2- and get 446000000000000000000 M solution????!!!!!!!!
1 M is also wrong.
Hint: "funny question"
dat_student said:No, How can one have 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3 ]2- and get 446000000000000000000 M solution????!!!!!!!!
1 M is also wrong.
Hint: "funny question"
Question is not clear (whether 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3]2- serve as starting materials or something already in equilibrium with the parent acid) ...
What's your own reasoning?
seoul said:Question is not clear (whether 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3]2- serve as starting materials or something already in equilibrium with the parent acid) ...
What's your own reasoning?
I'd like to give everybody a chance to think about it. I'll post something [at some point in the future].
Just going to toss out a guess: 4 M.
Where's the answer? 😀
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
OK, OK, I'm dumb. Someone want to explain this to me? 😕
seriously ... what's so "funny" about this question? Seems like a typical chemistry question.
I'd say that the answer doesn't exist. My reasoning is that all chemistry is fake. It's a hoax that a bunch of science and math nerds came up with. It's all complete crap.
We have 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3]2- in a solution. What is the molarity of the solution?
H2CO3 -> H+ + HCO3- -> H+ + [CO3]2-
all we gotta do is find molarity of H and CO3 then add them up.
It's that simple.
I think it's very funny, because I would laugh so bad if this shows up on DAT, since this is piece of cake.
H2CO3 -> H+ + HCO3- -> H+ + [CO3]2-
all we gotta do is find molarity of H and CO3 then add them up.
It's that simple.
I think it's very funny, because I would laugh so bad if this shows up on DAT, since this is piece of cake.
joonkimdds said:We have 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3]2- in a solution. What is the molarity of the solution?
H2CO3 -> H+ + HCO3- -> H+ + [CO3]2-
all we gotta do is find molarity of H and CO3 then add them up.
It's that simple.
I think it's very funny, because I would laugh so bad if this shows up on DAT, since this is piece of cake.
No. Wrong answer [don't laugh too much] 😉
Is it even possible to have two different molarities in one solution? This question is really weird. I'm not going to post anything else because it's just frustrating me now. 😡
Flipper405 said:Is it even possible to have two different molarities in one solution? This question is really weird. I'm not going to post anything else because it's just frustrating me now. 😡
It's possible. You can assume that 2H+ combine with 1 [CO3]2-. In that case, you'll be left with 1 M H+ and 1 M H2CO3 which has a low dissociation constant.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
dat_student said:We have 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3]2- in a solution. What is the molarity of the solution?
H2CO3 -> H+ + HCO3- -> H+ + [CO3]2-
This is totally just a guess but:
H+ is a strong acid, and (CO3)2- is a very strong base. In solution, equilibrium will shift towards the formation of the weaker conj. acid and base which would be HCO-, but since H+ is in excess H2CO3 will form. The formation of H2CO3 will use up two moles of H+, there will still be 1 mol of H+ left and 1 mol of the newly formed product H2CO3. If they are already in solution together as a 1L soln then the molarity would be 2M, because 2 moles of solute in 1L of solution.
mccarth2 said:This is totally just a guess but:
H+ is a strong acid, and (CO3)2- is a very strong base. In solution, equilibrium will shift towards the formation of the weaker conj. acid and base which would be HCO-, but since H+ is in excess H2CO3 will form. The formation of H2CO3 will use up two moles of H+, there will still be 1 mol of H+ left and 1 mol of the newly formed product H2CO3. If they are already in solution together as a 1L soln then the molarity would be 2M, because 2 moles of solute in 1L of solution.
No, if that were the case the question wouldn't be funny, bb in 1-2 hr(s)
dat_student said:No, if that were the case the question wouldn't be funny, bb in 1-2 hr(s)
We have 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3]2- in a solution. What is the molarity of the solution?
H2CO3 -> H+ + HCO3- -> H+ + [CO3]2-
first of all....there are couple of errors in this problem
the equation has two arrows , it should only have 1 arrow. I've never seen an equation with two arrows. that's just wrong.
2nd of all.. u said 3M, what does M mean?
dat_student said:We have 3 M H+ and 1 M [CO3]2- in a solution. What is the molarity of the solution?
H2CO3 -> H+ + HCO3- -> H+ + [CO3]2-
H2CO3 is going to dissociate very fast to H2O and CO2. This acid is not stable at all.
bump
