- Joined
- Jul 3, 2008
- Messages
- 584
- Reaction score
- 0
Ok, so I will hopefully be getting an invite for an interview at USUHS in the next couple of weeks and while there will have to make the important decision of ranking my choice of services. I could use the advice of those who have experience with mil med.
Specifically, assuming someone had their heart set on military medicine, which branch would you recommend? From my research and discussions on this site I have the following pros and cons of each service.
Army:
pros: the largest of the services with the greatest diversity and quantity of specialties. So if during clinicals you decide that pathology is your passion your best shot of matching into that residency would be with the army.
Cons: the longest deployments and the worst base locations, also deployments will likely be to Iraq and Afghanistan for the forseeable future so the odds of being killed are the highest of any service.
Conclusion: in the army you have the best chance of choosing your favorite specialty and doing what you love, though you may be doing it in places you hate and deployed to dangerous areas for long periods of time.
Air Force:
Pros: Has many nice base locations such as Hawaii, California and Florida and the bases themselves are supposedly very comfortable. Also has the shortest deployments.
Cons: The smallest service with the the least number of specialties so matching into which ever specialty you love most in clinicals could be very difficult.
Conclusion: a great pick for primary care, such as FP or IM, who will probably match easily and spend their careers in the poshest bases in some really nice locations. For those who fall in love with non primary care specialties however, they may spend their careers in posh, nicely located bases wishing they could be in a different specialty.
Navy:
Pros: The best locations by far, almost all coastally located and as the second largest service it does offer a good number of specialties such as rad and anesthesiology. Also, shorter deployments than Army, deployments aboard a ship can be a great adventure/life experience for those who have the right mindset/enjoy that short of thing.
Cons: GMO tour is done by 2/3 of folks who can't immediately match into their preferred residency.
Conclusion: For those who are planning a career in mil med and don't mind the 2 year residency postponement, post GMO navy docs are much more likely to get into the residency program of their choice. Thus, with a greater variety of specialty programs than AF and much nicer locations than Army and shorter deployments to safer areas, the Navy seems like a good compromise between the Army and AF that combines the strengths of both and minimizes the cons of both as well.
At least that is the sense I get from reading these forums for several months now.
I would appreciate the advice of people here who have experienced mil med first hand. Specifically my concern is with this fact:
Almost all med students start school planning on one specialty but change their minds after doing their clinicals. So that being the case and taking into account the positives and negatives of each service I would appreciate hearing everyone's opionion about which service offers the best chance to find a happy balance between, doing what you love everyday,(specialty) and doing it in a location you love,(base location) and doing it in nice facilities, (modernity/comfort of bases).
Any thoughts, advice or comments would be greatly appreciated.
Oh and if you don't feel like commenting please take part in the poll.
Thanks everyone for all your help and patience. I know I have gone a bit nuts at times but your wise words will hopefully allow me to launch a career that serves both my country, humanity and myself.
Please have a great weekend, a terrific summer and may you and yours know only health, joy and prosperity in the days to come.
Specifically, assuming someone had their heart set on military medicine, which branch would you recommend? From my research and discussions on this site I have the following pros and cons of each service.
Army:
pros: the largest of the services with the greatest diversity and quantity of specialties. So if during clinicals you decide that pathology is your passion your best shot of matching into that residency would be with the army.
Cons: the longest deployments and the worst base locations, also deployments will likely be to Iraq and Afghanistan for the forseeable future so the odds of being killed are the highest of any service.
Conclusion: in the army you have the best chance of choosing your favorite specialty and doing what you love, though you may be doing it in places you hate and deployed to dangerous areas for long periods of time.
Air Force:
Pros: Has many nice base locations such as Hawaii, California and Florida and the bases themselves are supposedly very comfortable. Also has the shortest deployments.
Cons: The smallest service with the the least number of specialties so matching into which ever specialty you love most in clinicals could be very difficult.
Conclusion: a great pick for primary care, such as FP or IM, who will probably match easily and spend their careers in the poshest bases in some really nice locations. For those who fall in love with non primary care specialties however, they may spend their careers in posh, nicely located bases wishing they could be in a different specialty.
Navy:
Pros: The best locations by far, almost all coastally located and as the second largest service it does offer a good number of specialties such as rad and anesthesiology. Also, shorter deployments than Army, deployments aboard a ship can be a great adventure/life experience for those who have the right mindset/enjoy that short of thing.
Cons: GMO tour is done by 2/3 of folks who can't immediately match into their preferred residency.
Conclusion: For those who are planning a career in mil med and don't mind the 2 year residency postponement, post GMO navy docs are much more likely to get into the residency program of their choice. Thus, with a greater variety of specialty programs than AF and much nicer locations than Army and shorter deployments to safer areas, the Navy seems like a good compromise between the Army and AF that combines the strengths of both and minimizes the cons of both as well.
At least that is the sense I get from reading these forums for several months now.
I would appreciate the advice of people here who have experienced mil med first hand. Specifically my concern is with this fact:
Almost all med students start school planning on one specialty but change their minds after doing their clinicals. So that being the case and taking into account the positives and negatives of each service I would appreciate hearing everyone's opionion about which service offers the best chance to find a happy balance between, doing what you love everyday,(specialty) and doing it in a location you love,(base location) and doing it in nice facilities, (modernity/comfort of bases).
Any thoughts, advice or comments would be greatly appreciated.
Oh and if you don't feel like commenting please take part in the poll.
Thanks everyone for all your help and patience. I know I have gone a bit nuts at times but your wise words will hopefully allow me to launch a career that serves both my country, humanity and myself.
Please have a great weekend, a terrific summer and may you and yours know only health, joy and prosperity in the days to come.