Giving up dreams for another dream

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

def1

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2012
Messages
603
Reaction score
39
I want to preface this post by saying that I am exceptionally grateful to have been accepted into medical school and I can't wait to start, but it has dawned on me all the other dreams which must die off in the face of medicine now. From reading a lot of premed threads on here about being unsure about medicine or unsure about other fields, this made me think introspectively about my career choice in medicine. The following (way longer than intended) post is my personal means to vent about something I am struggling with and writing has always been my personal escape. Hopefully some of you will find it interesting.

Medicine was sort of an unexpected dream in that I was not like some premeds who wanted to do medicine since they were born. There was no truly revolutionary moment in which I can pinpoint what exactly decided my passion towards medicine. That is not to say that I don't have deep personal reasons for heading into a career in medicine but I find it meaningful to mention because before this decision to head into this path took hold, I had many other dreams which I wanted to pursue. Obviously, medicine overshadowed these dreams and was my reason for planning to commit myself to years of slave labor as a medical student and resident 😛 However, I can't help but feel disappointed by the withdrawal from my other dreams and aspirations. I don't regret my decision to choose medicine and I wouldn't even dare entertain the thought of leaving medicine, but I sort of envy non-trads who had time to explore other goals and reflect before deciding on medicine.

I think back though, and I know my decision was never really a choice. There was no free will in the matter, but only the will of medicine to draw me into its trenches. Although I'm sure that seems hyperbolic and metaphoric, that is honestly the best way I can describe why I am passionate about medicine. Yet as I type this, there is another passion pulling at me to regain its attention.

I'm sure on a premed forum this will seem a bit silly, but I had huge aspirations to have a career in boxing. I trained in boxing for the past several years, and the moment I started learning, I just couldn't get enough. I felt at home in the boxing gym. I picked up techniques and skills quickly, and everyday brought improvement. For me what drew me to the sport was the mastery of the art. I wanted to master the boxing technique to absolute perfection. I wanted to be the textbook example of what a boxer does and how a boxer does it. I think most people view boxing in overly simplistic ideas and don't realize the many intricacies of the sport and especially of the technique. I could spend the rest of my life boxing and I'm certain that there would still be more to learn the next day. I think that is what is making me so sad to leave boxing behind. I still have so much to learn and master, and I am leaving before being able to realize my true potential. The most difficult feeling for me is that I honestly believe I had the qualities to be a great participant in the sport. Its hard to leave something you are good at behind, especially when you feel like you could get even better and possibly reach your goal.

In a way, I think what I enjoyed about boxing is also what I will enjoy about medicine. The constant learning and the effort to become a master in a certain field of medicine. I also feel medicine is a much more fulfilling career, because I'd be helping people in the hospital instead of sending them there 😛 In all seriousness though, this has been incredibly tough on me. I think it finally hit me today that once medical school starts, boxing will start to become a distant memory of my youth. I know this is only one of the many sacrifices I will make as I enter medicine. Although my heart sinks at the thought of giving up one dream, it glows with joy knowing I'm entering a career I feel I was destined to do.

Picking a career in medicine can be scary and its not a decision that should be made without careful introspection. As I mentioned earlier, I don't really believe I had a personal choice in the matter and I don't think I could have chosen a different path if I decided to go back. Its hard to rationalize why, but I know in my heart that this is where I am meant to be. Its sort of like trying to explain why your favorite color is your favorite color.

So I guess my ending thought is that if you are trying to decide if medicine is worth it, you need to try to figure out if after giving away those things you love, will the thought of medicine comfort you enough to live without them.
 
haha just kidding. interesting post...

but is "There was no free will in the matter, but only the will of medicine to draw me into its trenches. Although I'm sure that seems hyperbolic and metaphoric, that is honestly the best way I can describe why I am passionate about medicine. Yet as I type this, there is another passion pulling at me to regain its attention."

really a good, solid reason for going into medicine? is it a reason at all or just a feeling?
 
If you were truly a competitive athlete back in the day, be glad that it will not be your career. The sacrifice of great athletes, maybe save for the first round pick basketball and baseball players, is much greater than people would have you believe, whether it's football, track, boxing, swimming, etc.

And remember, if you're a pro athlete, your body is your livelihood, and all it takes is one bad fall, one big hit, one mistake to ruin you financially, if not physically. Or you can grind and grind and never be good enough to "make it," and then you're left with a broken body and no usable skills except coaching acumen.

Life abounds with opportunity costs. Medicine gives me the chance to live/work where I want with residency matching, do what I want with a myriad of specialty choices, be the kind of person I want to be through contributing to society, and still gives me what I crave as an athlete, the endless pursuit of knowledge, honing of skills, etc.

I can be a doctor for 50-60 years, or until I die. Athletes cannot say the same, and despite the outward appearance, they will always wish for just one more go, one more championship, one more personal triumph. I feel like doctors don't necessarily have that carrot to chase...
 
OP, this is not meant as a slight at all, I am genuinely curious, how do you reconcile your love for a sport that by its very nature is predicated on punching, and inflicting bodily harm to, another human being, with your desire to heal others as a physician? Again, I am genuinely curious and mean no disrespect - on the contrary, I acknowledge that your post seems heartfelt and boxing is obviously meaningful to you. Just strikes me as a bit odd, that's all.
 
OP, if you ever are willing to watch old-school anime or read comics, give this title a whirl:

Ashi ta no Joe (Tomorrow's Joe).
 
Last edited:
haha just kidding. interesting post...

but is "There was no free will in the matter, but only the will of medicine to draw me into its trenches. Although I'm sure that seems hyperbolic and metaphoric, that is honestly the best way I can describe why I am passionate about medicine. Yet as I type this, there is another passion pulling at me to regain its attention."

really a good, solid reason for going into medicine? is it a reason at all or just a feeling?

That again I think comes down to when I say "Its hard to rationalize why, but I know in my heart that this is where I am meant to be." Its not so much a reason, I guess you could call it a feeling. I think of it, for lack of a better term, as a calling as cliche as that sounds.

I love medicine. I don't think love is entirely logical. Therefore its hard for me to give a logical reason for why its such a huge passion.

There are things I can point to that I like about medicine: Science, working with patients, mastering medical knowledge, figuring out puzzling problems, etc. But what makes medicine an uncontrollable desire to pursue is more challenging to get across.
 
OP, this is not meant as a slight at all, I am genuinely curious, how do you reconcile your love for a sport that by its very nature is predicated on punching, and inflicting bodily harm to, another human being, with your desire to heal others as a physician? Again, I am genuinely curious and mean no disrespect - on the contrary, I acknowledge that your post seems heartfelt and boxing is obviously meaningful to you. Just strikes me as a bit odd, that's all.

Totally understandable. I probably don't have a good answer for it. Too me boxing was just a competition, where the goal is to win by being a superior boxer. My goal was never to hurt anyone, that was collateral damage I guess. My love for the sport was always based on having superior technique and ability and mastering that skill.

I guess it also has to do with the fact that boxers get in there because they love to fight. They have that warrior spirit. A boxer gives his consent and knows exactly what he is going into before a fight. I don't see it as any different than running down a football field to tackle another player. It would be different if boxing involved fights between two people who didn't actually want to take the risks. I dunno thats probably not a good answer, but I never really gave much thought to it. Its like two completely different worlds.
 
This was touching. I don't use terminology like that very often so you know I mean it.

I personally had a similar situation. I went from not really caring much about my future, to randomly being in love with medicine. Love might be the wrong work. I'm absolutely obsessed with it as a science. But either way, it just came out of virtually nowhere. I pursued it for a significant portion of my youth until I just got incredibly burned out. I felt like the stress of school and the extra hoops you have to jump through were taking too much out of me and I abandoned it for a different career. I pursued that career for a significant period of time as well, but I always felt a little hole in me that only medicine seems to fill. I finally got back into the swing of things and am pursuing medicine once again. I feel a little guilty about the other areas of my life I will be sacrificing, but I feel I am making the right move.

Respect for you and your story.

Thank you and good luck with your venture into medicine 👍
 
OP, if you ever are willing to watch old-school anime or read comics, give this title a whirl:

Ashi ta no Joe (Tomorrow's Joe).

No 😍 for Hajime no Ippo?
 
Paul Gasol dropped out of medical school to play in the NBA.
Jay Sean dropped out of medical school to pursue a career in music.
s'all good
 
Totally understandable. I probably don't have a good answer for it. Too me boxing was just a competition, where the goal is to win by being a superior boxer. My goal was never to hurt anyone, that was collateral damage I guess. My love for the sport was always based on having superior technique and ability and mastering that skill.

I guess it also has to do with the fact that boxers get in there because they love to fight. They have that warrior spirit. A boxer gives his consent and knows exactly what he is going into before a fight. I don't see it as any different than running down a football field to tackle another player. It would be different if boxing involved fights between two people who didn't actually want to take the risks. I dunno thats probably not a good answer, but I never really gave much thought to it. Its like two completely different worlds.

Agreed, a lot of people look at boxing as nothing but "trying to inflict pain on another person" and I think that is narrow-minded and missing the point, yes it is true and the outcome may be pain but at the end of the day its a competition and its an art that in order to excel at, takes technique, poise and balance. Just like football, wrestling etc.. medicine isn't a competition. That's comparing apples and oranges.

I could never box myself and I would totally force my future kids to do it if I wasn't so afraid of the dangers and consequences of childhood head injuries. But I have an enormous respect for the sport.

I'll probly force them to do wrestling just to be safer 😛 although the two sports have major differences.
 
Paul Gasol dropped out of medical school to play in the NBA.
Jay Sean dropped out of medical school to pursue a career in music.
s'all good

A million other Joe Schmos dropped out of medical school to pursue a career in sports/acting/music. After not hitting the "lottery" of making it, they now work unfulfilling jobs to make ends meet. *Insert exception, not the rule quote here*

OP, decide which of these careers is the one that you might look back on someday and think "wow I wish I would have given that a chance". Go for that one. If boxing is seriously so important to you that you can't go on without trying to do it professionally, then do it. Just know there's nothing wrong with it being just a hobby.

Anecdotal/somewhat relevant... I played a Division 1 sport and was a starter as a freshman/sophomore (somewhat rare). After poor grades my first two years due to the time commitment, I decided to quit the sport and focus on school. My grades have went up tremendously and I hope to go to med school in a couple years, which was what I've always wanted to do. Though I miss that sport every single day, I knew which I wanted more, so I made an important decision. You have to make the same. Good luck to you on your journey!
 
I don't see why you can continue to box while in med school. I mean, sure you'd have to cut back, but you certainly don't have to quit it completely.

This. I remember watching a cross training competition on ESPN and one of the best competitors was a medical student.

Also, I had no idea Jay Sean was a med student. I knew Pau Gasol was interested in medicine... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0DLHGesEMXM
 
I don't see why you can't continue to box while in med school. I mean, sure you'd have to cut back, but you certainly don't have to quit it completely.

I gotta keep my brain sharp for that Step score 😎

I might continue to train here and there, but its completely different to train and to compete.
 
Agreed, a lot of people look at boxing as nothing but "trying to inflict pain on another person" and I think that is narrow-minded and missing the point, yes it is true and the outcome may be pain but at the end of the day its a competition and its an art that in order to excel at, takes technique, poise and balance. Just like football, wrestling etc.. medicine isn't a competition. That's comparing apples and oranges.

I could never box myself and I would totally force my future kids to do it if I wasn't so afraid of the dangers and consequences of childhood head injuries. But I have an enormous respect for the sport.

I'll probly force them to do wrestling just to be safer 😛 although the two sports have major differences.

I think amateur boxing is safer than a lot of other sports. Its definitely a great discipline to learn.
 
Top