- Joined
- Feb 7, 2018
- Messages
- 27
- Reaction score
- 10
- Points
- 1,661
It is hands on, yes.Thanks for the input guys! I also heard that cook county is hands on. Can anyone confirm?
At least your first externship should be hands on. Imagine if your top program asks you to take out a tooth or hand tie and you’re clueless.An attending at my home program always told me going to an externship purely bc its hands on is sort of silly. Sure, if you're interested in this program, go for it. But you get a good grasp on how to do most things your intern year anyways, so justifying an externship because you'll get to pull 25 teeth and close a neck just doesn't make sense. After going on my externships, I definitely agree with this. Go to the program you want to learn most about. Some were more hands on than others, but most importantly I learned of some programs that I really really wanted to now apply to and could see myself at, and others that I might not even apply to now.
Our program lets their own students be pretty hands on so I never really though about that, so thats pretty fair for students at schools without an OMFS program or those without much experience in the OR.At least your first externship should be hands on. Imagine if your top program asks you to take out a tooth or hand tie and you’re clueless.
I’ve seen externs come to my schools home program and scrub in for the very first time. Yikes.Our program lets their own students be pretty hands on so I never really though about that, so thats pretty fair for students at schools without an OMFS program or those without much experience in the OR.
At least your first externship should be hands on. Imagine if your top program asks you to take out a tooth or hand tie and you’re clueless.
I am sure it's program-dependent, but some attendings may not want to teach every dental student how to scrub in. Why have you never scrubbed in at your home program? Why have you never sutured? It may be interpreted poorly and I wouldn't risk doing an externship at your top program first.Disagree completely. We’re dental students… programs know we’re not trained to do anything in the hospital. When I scrubbed in for the first time at an externship (at the program I actually ended up matching into, which was also my top program), the attending walked me through it. I also laid my first flap there with the interns and sutured for the very first time.
Residents and attendings don’t care if you don’t know how to do any of this since we all experience different levels of training at dental school.
You should extern at programs you want to match into to learn more about the culture and environment. Nothing more.
Some places just don't have the opportunity for students to come into the OR even if they show interest. I've talked to some people externing through my home program and they'll say that their school forbids dental students from going anywhere close to an OR. Definitely fortunate to come from a program where they make it a goal to teach us how to suture, hold instruments the right way, hand tie, scrub, etc., but not everybody has that. I've been told by attendings on externships that its very rare for an extern to come through and know how to hand tie, palm instruments, suture, etc. I would agree to not do an externship at your top program first even if you have done lots in the OR, but not for reasons such as having low surgical competency.I am sure it's program-dependent, but some attendings may not want to teach every dental student how to scrub in. Why have you never scrubbed in at your home program? Why have you never sutured? It may be interpreted poorly and I wouldn't risk doing an externship at your top program first.
Well, I had never scrubbed in because my home program was very strict with the COVID policy, and I had never sutured before because I took your "advice" and unintentionally had my first externship be a hands-on one at the start of my clinical D3 year. If anything, I suggest people to extern at an observation-only externship at first so they can get a feel for the hospital life.I am sure it's program-dependent, but some attendings may not want to teach every dental student how to scrub in. Why have you never scrubbed in at your home program? Why have you never sutured? It may be interpreted poorly and I wouldn't risk doing an externship at your top program first.
At least your first externship should be hands on. Imagine if your top program asks you to take out a tooth or hand tie and you’re clueless.
The argument is hands-on as your first externship, not top program first. I agree with you that you should save your top program for closer to the application cycle and not your very first one. I was rebutting your statement on the hands-on one being first, when I actually think an observation-only externship might be better as the very first. Regardless, it really doesn't matter. Just show up on time, be willing to learn, and act interested in everything while on the minimal sleep you will have that week.I wouldn't risk doing an externship at your top program first.
Oh, I would never argue with someone with a custom made SDN profile pictureWell, I had never scrubbed in because my home program was very strict with the COVID policy, and I had never sutured before because I took your "advice" and unintentionally had my first externship be a hands-on one at the start of my clinical D3 year. If anything, I suggest people to extern at an observation-only externship at first so they can get a feel for the hospital life.
Additionally, dude, the attendings are in academia -- they LOVE to teach. And if they don't want to teach a student how to scrub, then they will tell their resident to. And if the residents have a problem teaching a clueless dental student the absolute basics on how to scrub in, then that really isn't a program I want to train at (unless they were in a time crunch or something, of course).
The argument is hands-on as your first externship, not top program first. I agree with you that you should save your top program for closer to the application cycle and not your very first one. I was rebutting your statement on the hands-on one being first, when I actually think an observation-only externship might be better as the very first. Regardless, it really doesn't matter. Just show up on time, be willing to learn, and act interested in everything while on the minimal sleep you will have that week.