Personally I chose NYCOM due to location, friends, and family. I love the big apple and would want to be anywhere else. It is really up to you. Both are great schools and you will be great physician no matter which one you attend. I would look at what is important to you. Friends, family, location, tution, etc... That was how I chose a school and so far I have no complaints other than NYCOM's attendance policy. Good Luck. I am sure you will be a great physician.
PCOM. You can do ur 4th yr electives anywhere, and it doesn't depend on school. NYCOM does have a good matchlist, but I know PCOM has a really low number of people that go into primary care so I'm guessing it maybe better speciality wise, I don't know about location though or hospital rep. at where they match.
And NYCOM vs UMDNJ? UMDNJ would probably win
But if u want to stay in NY or close to NYC go to NYCOM, just remeber we have attendance.
go for the least expensive school...umdnj. (i hated the campus though) lol nycom has a very nice campus..that was worth a lot to me(as well as the ny rotations). spending two dreadful years on an ugly campus can suck...but then again...we didn't have mandatory attendance last year...