- Joined
- Jan 26, 2016
- Messages
- 125
- Reaction score
- 89
Last edited:
Hi Everyone,
This post is long overdue and I’m going to keep it as short as possible. I’ve been lurking around this forum over the last few years so I really do appreciate all of your guys’ insight.
As of now I’m one year out of undergrad and just received my mcat score. I’m trying to figure out my next steps and was hoping you guys could point me in the right direction.
My questions:
1) Do I have a shot at DO schools?
2) Do I have a shot at MD schools?
3) Does a post-bacc make any sense at all given the number of units I've taken
I tentatively plan on applying to medical school in June 2018.
I failed out of a large public university my freshman year, retook all of the science and math courses I failed along with pre-req classes at a community college and subsequently graduated with a degree in biochemistry from a private institution.
MCAT
September 2015 501: 126/125/125/125
June 2016 512: 129/125/128/130
GPA
oGPA (no grade replacement) 3.13
sGPA (no grade replacement) 2.96
I did some math and assuming I take one year (45 quarter units) of upper division science courses through a post-bacc and earned a 4.0, my sGPA moves from 2.96 to 3.17 and my oGPA moves from 3.13 to 3.26. This seems like a pretty big commitment for something that is not guaranteed and frankly doesn’t improve my by much. I don’t think this is a good option for me. What are your guys’ thoughts on a post-bacc in this situation?
**If you can take a look at the PDF I've attached which has a breakdown of my GPA over the course of my undergrad career, as it gives you a better idea of my progression. I I'm not sure how to embed the graph and chart into my post, sorry for this. **
ECs
I won’t delve into too much detail here.
- Worked as an inpatient diet technician for 5 years ( approx. 5400 hours of working hospital experience)
- 1 year of benchtop chemistry research (final year of undergrad)
- Will have 2 years of meaningful clinic research experience by the time I submit my app. (Should have pubs by then if that matters)
- Non-medical volunteer work
Thank you in advance for taking the time to read through my post. I realize these posts are a dime in a dozen but I really do value your insights very much.
Best,
JDs
Your stats are too low for admission this year. Some people will say "go for the new schools," and this is true - they're your best shot - but it's still a pretty long shot. Your GPA and MCAT are both on the very low end of the "acceptable for DO" range, and your history and ECs show nothing special. The smart money is on "gets soundly beat by better applicants."
You need at least something on your application to stand out. Ideally you'd retake the MCAT, But failing that your best bet is to raise your GPA. I strongly suggest doing a masters of Biomedical science, or some other (hard science) masters, to give yourself a shiny new grad GPA while having a backup in case med school doesn't work out. A post-bac like you describe will work, but your MCAT is still pretty low, and MCATs that low really need a very high GPA to go compensate. An SMP with linkage is a very risky option, but if you're a goddam amazing student it will pay off.
Hi Peach,Your stats are too low for admission this year. Some people will say "go for the new schools," and this is true - they're your best shot - but it's still a pretty long shot. Your GPA and MCAT are both on the very low end of the "acceptable for DO" range, and your history and ECs show nothing special. The smart money is on "gets soundly beat by better applicants."
You need at least something on your application to stand out. Ideally you'd retake the MCAT, But failing that your best bet is to raise your GPA. I strongly suggest doing a masters of Biomedical science, or some other (hard science) masters, to give yourself a shiny new grad GPA while having a backup in case med school doesn't work out. A post-bac like you describe will work, but your MCAT is still pretty low, and MCATs that low really need a very high GPA to go compensate. An SMP with linkage is a very risky option, but if you're a goddam amazing student it will pay off.
Hi Dial1010usa,Your MCAT is way above for DO schools. I think you meant MCAT 512 for June 2017 not 2016, right?
Some schools sGPA cut off is 2.75. I would email schools and ask them what do they suggest.
Hi Parslea,Did you see his 512 MCAT? Yes if averaged he has a 506.5 but I have not heard of retaking a 512. The general sentiment of your post is certainly reasonable, though. Just think referring to 512 as "pretty low" is brutal.
Your stats are too low for admission this year. Some people will say "go for the new schools," and this is true - they're your best shot - but it's still a pretty long shot. Your GPA and MCAT are both on the very low end of the "acceptable for DO" range, and your history and ECs show nothing special. The smart money is on "gets soundly beat by better applicants."
You need at least something on your application to stand out. Ideally you'd retake the MCAT, But failing that your best bet is to raise your GPA. I strongly suggest doing a masters of Biomedical science, or some other (hard science) masters, to give yourself a shiny new grad GPA while having a backup in case med school doesn't work out. A post-bac like you describe will work, but your MCAT is still pretty low, and MCATs that low really need a very high GPA to go compensate. An SMP with linkage is a very risky option, but if you're a goddam amazing student it will pay off.
Hi Peach,
Thank you for taking the time to reply. Regarding my mcat score, it is my understanding that 512 is on the higher end for do schools. Although it does seem like do averages are rising every year.
The MBS sounds like a good option; however, don't schools give weight to your undergrad gpa vs. grad gpa for admissions? Perhaps because my undergrad gpa is so impacted with units, showing a higher separate grad school gpa might be beneficial?
Looking forward to hearing back from you!
Hi Everyone,
This post is long overdue and I’m going to keep it as short as possible. I’ve been lurking around this forum over the last few years, I made a similar post a few years back while I was in school and felt now was a good time to follow-up. This forum has been invaluable for me over the years, I really do appreciate all of the knowledge that makes this community so great.
I’m one year out of undergrad and just received my mcat score. I’m trying to figure out my next steps and was hoping you guys could point me in the right direction.
My questions:
1) Should I consider a post-bacc/mbs/smp? My biggest concern here is with the number of units I've already completed, a year of course work may not have a dramatic impact. I have retaken the science and math courses I scored less than a B in, although it doesn't really show without grade replacement.
2 As I currently stand, do I have a shot at DO schools?
b) Do I have any chance at schools like: western, rvu, kcumb, ccom, dmu?
3) Is the MD door totally shut?
I tentatively plan on applying to medical school in June 2018.
I failed out of a large public university my freshman year, retook all of the science and math courses I failed along with pre-req classes at a community college and subsequently graduated with a degree in biochemistry from a private institution.
MCAT
September 2015: 501 - 126/125/125/125
June 2017: 512 - 129/125/128/130
GPA
oGPA (assuming no grade replacement) 3.13
sGPA (assuming no grade replacement) 2.96
I did some math and assuming I take one year (45 quarter units) of upper division science courses through a post-bacc and earned a 4.0, my sGPA improves from 2.96 to 3.17 and my oGPA improves from 3.13 to 3.26. This seems like a big commitment for something that is not guaranteed and frankly doesn’t improve my gpa as much as I would have hoped. I'm personally weary that additional courses would show something adcoms haven't seen in my 5+ years of undergraduate transcripts. What are your guys’ thoughts on a post-bacc in this situation?
LizzyM goes from 63.3 to 64.6 assuming a 4.0 in a full time year long post-bacc.
**Please take a look at the PDF I've attached, which has a breakdown of my GPA over the course of my undergrad career, a graph of my gpa trend, along with a chart that shows which classes I've retaken and the new grades earned. I can also post or message my transcripts if that's helpful for anyone. I apologize for not knowing how to directly post the graph and table into my post.**
ECs
I won’t delve into too much detail here.
- Worked as an inpatient diet technician for 5 years ( approx. 5400 hours of working hospital experience)
- 1 year of benchtop chemistry research (final year of undergrad)
- Will have 2 years of meaningful clinical research experience by the time I submit my app. (I anticipate I'll have one pub by the time application time rolls around, if that matters at all.)
- Non-medical volunteer work
Thank you in advance for taking the time to read through my post. I realize these posts are a dime in a dozen but I really do value your insights very much.
Best,
JDs
Did you see his 512 MCAT? Yes if averaged he has a 506.5 but I have not heard of retaking a 512. The general sentiment of your post is certainly reasonable, though. Just think referring to 512 as "pretty low" is brutal.
The sGPA is the problem. You'd be autorejected at my school and a good number of others. Even LUCOM has standards.Hi Everyone,
This post is long overdue and I’m going to keep it as short as possible. I’ve been lurking around this forum over the last few years, I made a similar post a few years back while I was in school and felt now was a good time to follow-up. This forum has been invaluable for me over the years, I really do appreciate all of the knowledge that makes this community so great.
I’m one year out of undergrad and just received my mcat score. I’m trying to figure out my next steps and was hoping you guys could point me in the right direction.
My questions:
1) Should I consider a post-bacc/mbs/smp? My biggest concern here is with the number of units I've already completed, a year of course work may not have a dramatic impact. I have retaken the science and math courses I scored less than a B in, although it doesn't really show without grade replacement.
2 As I currently stand, do I have a shot at DO schools?
b) Do I have any chance at schools like: western, rvu, kcumb, ccom, dmu?
3) Is the MD door totally shut?
I tentatively plan on applying to medical school in June 2018.
I failed out of a large public university my freshman year, retook all of the science and math courses I failed along with pre-req classes at a community college and subsequently graduated with a degree in biochemistry from a private institution.
MCAT
September 2015: 501 - 126/125/125/125
June 2017: 512 - 129/125/128/130
GPA
oGPA (assuming no grade replacement) 3.13
sGPA (assuming no grade replacement) 2.96
I did some math and assuming I take one year (45 quarter units) of upper division science courses through a post-bacc and earned a 4.0, my sGPA improves from 2.96 to 3.17 and my oGPA improves from 3.13 to 3.26. This seems like a big commitment for something that is not guaranteed and frankly doesn’t improve my gpa as much as I would have hoped. I'm personally weary that additional courses would show something adcoms haven't seen in my 5+ years of undergraduate transcripts. What are your guys’ thoughts on a post-bacc in this situation?
LizzyM goes from 63.3 to 64.6 assuming a 4.0 in a full time year long post-bacc.
**Please take a look at the PDF I've attached, which has a breakdown of my GPA over the course of my undergrad career, a graph of my gpa trend, along with a chart that shows which classes I've retaken and the new grades earned. I can also post or message my transcripts if that's helpful for anyone. I apologize for not knowing how to directly post the graph and table into my post.**
ECs
I won’t delve into too much detail here.
- Worked as an inpatient diet technician for 5 years ( approx. 5400 hours of working hospital experience)
- 1 year of benchtop chemistry research (final year of undergrad)
- Will have 2 years of meaningful clinical research experience by the time I submit my app. (I anticipate I'll have one pub by the time application time rolls around, if that matters at all.)
- Non-medical volunteer work
Thank you in advance for taking the time to read through my post. I realize these posts are a dime in a dozen but I really do value your insights very much.
Best,
JDs
Did you see his 512 MCAT? Yes if averaged he has a 506.5 but I have not heard of retaking a 512. The general sentiment of your post is certainly reasonable, though. Just think referring to 512 as "pretty low" is brutal.
Brah... this guy retook the MCAT and got a 512 which is like getting a 32 on the old MCAT!
Disregard Peach's advice, he must have misread your post or something cause your MCAT score is extremely good. The issue you have right now is that sub 3.0 sGPA. Is it possible to raise that GPA up before your apply? I think once you have done this you should be okay.
Don't do an SMP yet. I suggest trying one cycle to see who will take you. Aim for the newer schools (ex. UIW, BCOM, Rocky Vista-utah, KCU-Joplin, etc.) and the schools that have been around for 8-40 years (ex. WVSOM, KYCOM, ATSU-SOMA, PCOM-GA, etc.). However, please try to see if you can raise that sGPA before you apply. If not, then make sure of which schools have an auto screen of any GPA below 3.0.
Good luck
I would go ahead and apply and see what happens. Apply to SMPs and Post-Baccs later on in the winter if you haven't heard anything back.
1)
1) If I were you I would apply primarily to SMPS, like this cycle. Clearly taking more UG classes isn't going to help your GPAs at this point. You need to demonstrate that you can handle med school like coursework and that is the most effective way at doing so for someone in your situation. With your MCAT I suspect you would get into good SMPs.
2) I don't want to be a downer but truthfully you have little chance at DO schools like DMU, western, CCOM. Yes, your MCAT is high, but both of your GPAs are far too low. These schools often get applicants who have MCATs in your range with average to above average GPAs. I do think you could be successful at one of the new programs this year, but if it were me I would do an SMP to open more doors for yourself.
3) MD is totally shut as of right now but if you do an SMP, especially one through an MD program, then you'd have a chance.
Truthfully I'm not well informed about the different types of SMPs out there but I'm in a summer class with a guy who did well in one and has gotten interest from MD schools this cycle.
Hi Islandstyle808,
Thank you for your message and I appreciate the love regarding improved MCAT. I looked at Goro's thread regarding grade replacement and learned that math courses interestingly don't factor into accomas sGPA like they do for amcas. Without math courses my sGPA moves up from 2.95 to 3.10 which is nice. It was an a painless way to raise that sGPA to above 3.0. New numbers without any grade replacement are sGPA 3.10 and oGPA 3.13, which are still on the low end.
I'll take a look at the schools you've listed. Would you happen to know (and I will do my own search as well) if there are any schools that historically are willing to overlook a low gpa for a high(ish?) mcat? Perhaps my thinking is flawed, but because RVU-utah and KCU-joplin are affiliated with already well established schools I feel relatively comfortable giving them my money/attending them. Would you agree with this assessment?
Hi HanSoloYolo,
I think that would be a good way to go, just don't want to put my app out there if I won't be taken as a serious candidate.
Hi Workaholic,
You're not being a downer, you're being realistic which is exactly why I posted on here. I can rationalize my improvement over the years all I want, but ultimately this is a numbers game and if I haven't improved my numbers enough I won't even get an interview.
My reason for not applying to an SMP during my final year of undergrad came down to two things:
1. I gave my final two years of undergrad my best effort and was in the 3.3 - 3.6 range over those two years. I feel comfortable saying that is the kind of student I am, if that's not good enough I may honestly not be medical school material, which is ok with me. I'm not sure how much more an SMP would reveal about my abilities to an admissions officer? Also, just how common at 3.8+ gpa's in a a good SMP?
2. I did speak to a few SMP/BMS representatives and it felt like they were giving me sales pitches and wanted to make money off me rather than explaining just how I was a good fit for their program and how they could help me get to where I want to go. For example, one advisory recommended I retake gen chem/physics/ organic chem which just seemed bizarre to me. What would me retaking gen chem for the third time prove to an admissions advisor?
I should consider the right SMP, especially if it opens significantly more doors for me. The thought of leaving my job which I started a little over a year ago is very tough though...
Thank you for your thoughtful response Workaholic!
I do think there are a lot of SMPs out there that prey on people who are desperate to improve their app. With that said there are definitely a lot of good ones; I'm applying to Temple's ACMS this year when it opens in addition to MD/DO. I would absolutely go to it if I got in. There are a lot of other reputable programs you could find.
I can't really say how common it is for people to do well in SMPs. It's up to you man! I'm sure whatever you decide will be fine. If you think you can walk away from this path without it really eating at you, then I certainly understand and respect that.
Hi @Goro ,
I'll be the first to admit I had a bit of a fanboy moment when I saw you replied to this thread. Thank you for taking the time to read through and respond to my post as well as for being such an invaluable source of information for those of us trying to find our way through this process.
I vividly remember sitting at this very cubicle back in early January scrolling r/premed and seeing a post about grade replacement no longer being a thing, I immediately hopped over to sdn and looked for what you had to say. At the time I certainly felt dejected. I took some time today to re-look through your thread, and played with the idea of academic reinvention throughout my workday today. I also realized this morning that my aacomas gpa isn't equal to my amcas gpa. My aacomas sGPA is actually 3.1 and oGPA still remains 3.13.
My question for you Goro, if I were to get past your schools filter and you looked at my app, would you consider me someone who was able to reinvent them-self? What additional information would completing a one year MBS/SMP reveal about who I am or my academic abilities.
Steps I have taken towards reinvention:
1) I retook a C/C-(s)/ and F(s) in my courses and earned B(s) in all of them except for programming which was an A.
2) Show consistent improvement and ability to maintain a competative-ish gpa over a period of time. This evening I edited my original post to include my o/sGPA breakdown for each yea of undergrad (along with some other information including my complete transcripts and more details about my EC experiences). I'll post the GPA breakdown this post as well:
Large Public School 2010-2011: sGPA 1.43, oGPA 1.53
JC 2011-2012: sGPA 3.0, oGPA 3.11
JC 2012-2013: sGPA 3.0, oGPA 3.29
JC 2013-2014: sGPA 4.0, oGPA 4.0 (I took two sciences courses and a bunch of GE's in 2013-2014)
Private 2014-2015: sGPA 3.37, oGPA 3.47
Private 2015-2016: 3.43, oGPA 3.46 (Every course except for one was an upper division science course in 2015-2016)
3) Improve from 501 to 512 on the mcat.
4) Right after failing out of school, seeking employment and gaining practical experience in the health care field. Keeping that job for five years and accruing 5000+ hours of working experience.
Perhaps the reinvention hasn't happened yet, maybe I am still very much the caterpillar in the cocoon, and there is still much work to be done before I can burst out as a butterfly.
"You cannot disrespect the caterpillar and rave about the butterfly" - Marc Jackson
If your schedule permits, I would really appreciate if you could take a look at my updated original post as well. I have since included more information which may or may not be helpful in giving some additional background on me. A very sincere thank you for your time, Goro.
@Goro ,I think if you apply broadly, you can get some love from DO schools.
That's a mandate!
That's a mandate!
Hi Islandstyle808,
Thank you for your message and I appreciate the love regarding improved MCAT. I looked at Goro's thread regarding grade replacement and learned that math courses interestingly don't factor into accomas sGPA like they do for amcas. Without math courses my sGPA moves up from 2.95 to 3.10 which is nice. It was an a painless way to raise that sGPA to above 3.0. New numbers without any grade replacement are sGPA 3.10 and oGPA 3.13, which are still on the low end.
I'll take a look at the schools you've listed. Would you happen to know (and I will do my own search as well) if there are any schools that historically are willing to overlook a low gpa for a high(ish?) mcat? Perhaps my thinking is flawed, but because RVU-utah and KCU-joplin are affiliated with already well established schools I feel relatively comfortable giving them my money/attending them. Would you agree with this assessment?
Hi Islandstyle,There are previous interview/acceptance threads you can look up on here where applicants put their stats and where they interviewed and got accepted at. I myself cannot really say which school overlook a low GPA.
Good luck
Hi Islandstyle,
I'll forsure take a look at those threads. How's the process going for you?
@IslandStyle808
I'm glad to hear that, I hope you first year went well! Thank you for taking the time to point me in the right direction.
Are the interview/acceptance threads you mentioned the same thing as the yearly "school specific" discussion threads?
Thank you!They will be located in pre-DO subforum itself. Look for old threads similar to this one below.
***The Official 2017-2018 Osteopathic Underdawgs***
Can I just say that the data here is absolutely beautiful?