The DDx for a Caribbean grad is pretty off-putting: bad judgement, bad advice, ego, gullibility, overbearing parents, inability to delay gratification, IA's, legal problems,weak research skills, high risk behavior...
Bad grades and scores are the least of the deficits from a PD's standpoint.
A strong academic showing in a Caribbean medical school does not erase this stigma. It fact it increases the perception that the reason for the choice was on the above-mentioned list!
Well, fortunately, I don't have any of those problems (well besides overbearing parents, I don't have any IAs or legal problems and I'd like to believe I don't have an ego or inability to delay gratification)! I simply sometimes wonder if it's such a bad idea for someone who wasn't cut out to make it to a US MD/DO school. For example, my friend's friend graduated college with a 2 something GPA (lethal for MD and DO schools) but got a 30 on the MCAT. I think he went to AUC and is doing his residency now in CA.
Many do come back to the US but a huge amount don't. When you are spending upwards of 300k you don't want to have uncertain odds. Its a huge gamble. These schools exist to pad their own pockets they aren't ethical and don't care about you. DO schools value reinvention you can always get your app to the point where a DO school will take you if you are willing to work for it. Don't think about the carribean its a dead option. A poor mans gamble that will end in flames. A DO school will match almost there whole class. DO have an entire residency system to themselves.
I think it's completely unethical of them to take kids who aren't academically or morally qualified! I'm not entirely sure how this works but if they accept someone with a felony, doesn't that felony also come up in background checks during residency selection? They surely wouldn't get into a residency with a serious felony. That's got to be the most evil thing I've ever heard!
Yeah and that's exactly what I'm doing! I had a sub-par 3.0 GPA freshman year and because of the the super generous AACOMAS grade replacement policy I believe I will have around a 3.8 cGPA/3.7 sGPA. I would hope that MD and DO schools would value reinvention! Sometimes I think I do need to be more confident about my chances.
This sentence is far and away the biggest problem in your post.
I'm not entirely certain I understand what you mean. I am a junior in undergrad and I told my parents I am not going to apply this year because I simply would not be competitive enough. I just started some activities (clinical volunteering, research, etc.) and I just feel like that will look like I'm cramming if I applied this summer. Instead, I'm going apply summer 2016 because that would mean I have a chance to get a year's worth of better grades, more time for volunteering and research experience, more time to study for the MCAT, etc. By the time the app cycle is done, I will have invested probably 200-300K into all of this (entire undergraduate career, MCAT prep, application costs, etc.). I am taking a significant amount to prepare for the best possible application in 2016 and if that's not enough I'm not sure what it is. I'm not just sending a crappy application this cycle and re-applying the next cycle. I have been working really hard to atone for my sins (bad grades) from early on in college.
I think a lot of people can agree it's smart to intend to apply once with the best possible application.
I have the same mentality with my MCAT. Before I was like, "oh yeah, if I do bad I'll take it a 2nd or 3rd time" and I'm so glad I don't have that mentality anymore! I want to take the MCAT once and put my best effort into that. Of course if I do poorly, I would have to retake but a retake is not something I'm considering as part of my preparation for the MCAT.
I understand your fear of outright rejection from schools and your eagerness to start medical school. I also assume your parents are putting a significant amount of pressure on you which is making you have this above mentality. Parental pressure is a terrible reason to end up going to the Caribbean.
I feel sometimes SDN knocks down re-applicants too much. It certainly is never desirable, but it is not the kiss of death to your medical school aspirations. The re-applicants I know were successful because they found their weaknesses and addressed them before the next cycle. For some of them that meant taking a cycle off and taking a total of three gap years.
I am applying after graduation so I technically will have one gap year before matriculation if accepted. I did have to convince them to let me wait a year and they eventually agreed. It's just I'm already taking time now to address what I think would be weak parts of my application. If that doesn't work or isn't enough then I believe I have no option but the Carribean.
All in all though, I do sometimes feel hopeful about my chances and think I might have a shot here in the US. I'm not a crazy terrible position. The Carribean is my last resort. I'm just trying to be realistic!