joonkimdds

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 30, 2005
2,780
2
Status
Pre-Dental
I think this sounds stupid but I am confused (and feeling high @[email protected];;) so I am sorry if this question sounds too stupid.

Does high boiling point mean high melting point? (I don't know why but I have been thinking that high boiling point means low melting point):scared:

I found a question asking for which one has the highest boiling point and the solution says we look for the one that can form the H bond and COOH was the answer.

And then I found another question but this time asked for highest melting point and the answer was the same.
 
Last edited:

doc3232

10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Feb 15, 2008
3,809
10
Status
Dental Student
I think this sounds stupid but I am confused (and feeling high @[email protected];;) so I am sorry if this question sounds too stupid.

Does high boiling point mean high melting point? (I don't know why but I have been thinking that high boiling point means low melting point):scared:

I found a question asking for which one has the highest boiling point and the solution says we look for the one that can form the H bond and COOH was the answer.

And then I found another question but this time asked for highest melting point and the answer was the same.
Ya, I am not sure, but I always did think that the two were correlated like that.
I like to think of a diamonds characteristics when I am confused. Works for me, might work for others.
 

Panther85

10+ Year Member
Aug 20, 2007
99
1
Status
Podiatry Student
higher mp is due to branching

higher bp is due to a straighter chain interaction

look at destroyer ochem #152
 
About the Ads

joonkimdds

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 30, 2005
2,780
2
Status
Pre-Dental
Unfortunately, my destroyer ochem stops at #117 :( (it's from yr 2006)
According to Kaplan
H bonding = inc BP and MP
unsaturation = inc BP
more branch = dec BP
longer = inc BP

That's all the info I could gather.

Panther85// you said higher MP is due to branching. But branching lowers BP. Does that mean BP and MP are not always correlated?
 

zuma35

10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Sep 6, 2008
128
0
Status
Dental Student
Higher boiling point usually goes with higher melting point, but not always. One exception, for example, is cis and trans. A cis isomer will have a higher boiling point and a lower melting point than its trans isomer. Another example is a very symmetrical molecule. Although branching usually decreases the melting pt (as it does to the bp), if a molecule is very symmetrical, like 2,2 dimethyl propane, the melting point will increase due to the molecule's ability to form into a perfect crystal.
 

joonkimdds

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 30, 2005
2,780
2
Status
Pre-Dental
I have one more question.
Does higher boiling point also mean higher solubility in H2O?

I learned from old thread of SDN that
solubility in H2O is
COOH>Phenol>Alcohol>Alkyne>Alkene>alkane

and then I learned from my other materials that
COOH has high BP, so does alcohol because of OH nature forming H bonding,
and then alkyne and alkene has higher BP than alkane.

so when I gather all these info, it seems
High MP, high BP, and high solubility in water.

and I think it also has something to do with acidity level.
 

Danny289

Member
10+ Year Member
Dec 2, 2006
1,523
4
Status
Pre-Dental
questions in DAT will be very clear. when you are comparing you must compare apple to apple! for example which one has higer boiling point?
1) n- pentane
2)2- methyl butane
3)Ethane
4) neo pentane (2,2 dimethyl propane)
here answer will be "n-pantane" no branch boiling point high, ethane is out because it is small molecule compare to pentane.
in above question, if ask about melting point answer will be neo pentane because the molecule will be fit better in solid form (draw it you will see)
maybe you notice we don't have any hydrogyn bond here( lack of , N, O, F )
now look at to this question?
which one has higher boiling ( melting point)
1)CH3-CH2-CH3
2) CH3-0-CH3
3)CH2-CH2-CH2-OH
4)CH2-CH2-COOH
the answer is "4" because hydrogyn bond (stronger hydogyn bond in acid compare to alcohol).
give a time to yourself to understand this subject cold.
good luck :thumbup:
 

Zubnaya Feya

Combinator
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Nov 13, 2008
971
2
Ann Arbor, MI
Status
Dental Student
I think destroyer had a good explanation about it (or maybe my old textbook?).

High melting point does not go with high boiling point.

The more possibility of molecules getting together (Van der Waals attractions) the higher the boiling point. Therefore, the less branching in a chain - the higher the boiling point.

Melting point increases with increasing branches because (I don't remember why) branching somehow favors crystallization.

I remember that for sure... and thinking now, it was in Destroyer.
 

Zubnaya Feya

Combinator
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Nov 13, 2008
971
2
Ann Arbor, MI
Status
Dental Student
I have one more question.
Does higher boiling point also mean higher solubility in H2O?

I learned from old thread of SDN that
solubility in H2O is
COOH>Phenol>Alcohol>Alkyne>Alkene>alkane

and then I learned from my other materials that
COOH has high BP, so does alcohol because of OH nature forming H bonding,
and then alkyne and alkene has higher BP than alkane.

so when I gather all these info, it seems
High MP, high BP, and high solubility in water.

and I think it also has something to do with acidity level.
I cannot come up with an example... but for some reason I doubt that higher boiling point is proportional to higher solubility.

Bigger polarity and higher probability of dissociating into ions go together with higher solubility in water.
 

joonkimdds

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 30, 2005
2,780
2
Status
Pre-Dental
I guess I should get the 2nd Destroyer ....
 

Danny289

Member
10+ Year Member
Dec 2, 2006
1,523
4
Status
Pre-Dental
I cannot come up with an example... but for some reason I doubt that higher boiling point is proportional to higher solubility.

Bigger polarity and higher probability of dissociating into ions go together with higher solubility in water.
boiling point related to the number of molecule(moles) in your solution.
for example one mole NaCl(58.5 gram NaCl) in one liter water has higher boiling point of one mole suger( 342.3 gram C12H22O11)in one liter water because NaCl dissolves in water and make 2 moles ions(NaCl===> Na+ + Cl-) but sugar makes just one(not ionized).

anyway this subject is covered in G chem not in organic chemistry.
 

joonkimdds

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 30, 2005
2,780
2
Status
Pre-Dental
Danny290, do you think higher boiling point is same as having higher water solubility?
 

doc3232

10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Feb 15, 2008
3,809
10
Status
Dental Student
Think diamonds, diamonds have a higher bp than nearly anything, but that doesn't dissolve in water.
 
About the Ads

joonkimdds

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 30, 2005
2,780
2
Status
Pre-Dental
Think diamonds, diamonds have a higher bp than nearly anything, but that doesn't dissolve in water.
ok:)
But if BP and solubility have different characteristics, what are they?
For example, characteristics we look for BP is branching, length, H bonding.
what characterestics do we look for solubility in water?

for example which one has higer boiling point?
1) n- pentane
2)2- methyl butane
3)Ethane
4) neo pentane (2,2 dimethyl propane)
here answer will be "n-pantane" no branch boiling point high, ethane is out because it is small molecule compare to pentane.
in above question, if ask about melting point answer will be neo pentane because the molecule will be fit better in solid form (draw it you will see)
I think destroyer had a good explanation about it (or maybe my old textbook?).

High melting point does not go with high boiling point.

The more possibility of molecules getting together (Van der Waals attractions) the higher the boiling point. Therefore, the less branching in a chain - the higher the boiling point.

Melting point increases with increasing branches because (I don't remember why) branching somehow favors crystallization.

I remember that for sure... and thinking now, it was in Destroyer.

Funny thing is I just read from Kaplan that says
inc chain length = inc BP, MP, density
inc branching = dec BP, MP, density

This info is different from what two of you said.

So I searched SDN and found two similar thread
it was
Kaplan vs. Destroyer http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=542327
and then
EK vs. TPR http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=111078

in the end, Kaplan and EK lost ... :D
 
Last edited:

Danny289

Member
10+ Year Member
Dec 2, 2006
1,523
4
Status
Pre-Dental
Danny290, do you think higher boiling point is same as having higher water solubility?
yes you can think that way kinda. read carefully my previous post. if you have more solubility, you will have more moles in your solution, pay attention in the same timeto the ionization of solute( like NaCl in my example).
 

Danny289

Member
10+ Year Member
Dec 2, 2006
1,523
4
Status
Pre-Dental
ok:)
But if BP and solubility have different characteristics, what are they?
For example, characteristics we look for BP is branching, length, H bonding.
what characterestics do we look for solubility in water?






Funny thing is I just read from Kaplan that says
inc chain length = inc BP, MP, density
inc branching = dec BP, MP, density

This info is different from what two of you said.

So I searched SDN and found two similar thread
it was
Kaplan vs. Destroyer http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=542327
and then
EK vs. TPR http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=111078

in the end, Kaplan and EK lost ... :D
open your Textbook! for a moment forger BB and destroyer and EK....!
 

doc3232

10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Feb 15, 2008
3,809
10
Status
Dental Student
inc chain length = inc BP, MP, density
inc branching = dec BP, MP, density

THIS IS correct.
But you must assume when you increase branching that you are not changing the number of carbons.
If you increase branching then the molecules can't stack as well and hence have a lower density. Also, they have less interactions and hence can "leave" each other in the form of gas (BP).
 

Zubnaya Feya

Combinator
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Nov 13, 2008
971
2
Ann Arbor, MI
Status
Dental Student
boiling point related to the number of molecule(moles) in your solution.
for example one mole NaCl(58.5 gram NaCl) in one liter water has higher boiling point of one mole suger( 342.3 gram C12H22O11)in one liter water because NaCl dissolves in water and make 2 moles ions(NaCl===> Na+ + Cl-) but sugar makes just one(not ionized).

anyway this subject is covered in G chem not in organic chemistry.
I thought we are talking about pure substances. Ochem covers this subject too.
 

doccure

10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
Oct 30, 2008
13
0
Status
inc BP= inc in chain and dec in branching
inc MP= inc in chain and dec in branching
inc solubility in water = short chain
Correct me if I am wrong
 

doc3232

10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Feb 15, 2008
3,809
10
Status
Dental Student
So I came across a tough question:
Which will have higher MP: cis or trans alkene?
Same question with BP

The answer is not what is expected...
 

joonkimdds

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 30, 2005
2,780
2
Status
Pre-Dental
inc BP= inc in chain and dec in branching
inc MP= inc in chain and dec in branching
inc solubility in water = short chain
Correct me if I am wrong
diff books are talking about it differently.
I decided to stick with what people here say which is
dec MP = dec branching

So I came across a tough question:
Which will have higher MP: cis or trans alkene?
Same question with BP

The answer is not what is expected...
tell us what the answer was :)
 

doc3232

10+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Feb 15, 2008
3,809
10
Status
Dental Student
So answer is: MP is higher if it is trans and BP is higher for cis.
cis because it is polar.
 
About the Ads