Is that the reason you were waitlisted?
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CuqaaGFx4gM[/YOUTUBE]How about a D in a non-prereq science?
I'm sorry but there's no reason why a person capable of completing medical school, passing 3 steps of board exams, etc. etc. should get a D in any class.
I am graduating, just found out I got a D...
I'm sorry but there's no reason why a person capable of completing medical school, passing 3 steps of board exams, etc. etc. should get a D in any class. Makes me wonder if the OP is fit for the rigors of medical training/career.
I hate to say this (gulp) but I kinda agree.
I got a couple of C's. Organic Chemistry II and German.
Orgo was hard and I just didnt get it.
German...well, I dont speak German, as my grade proved. I still dont speak German.
Did you have problem with biochem in medical school because of orgo...I could not get orgo too...ended up with B...my only B in prereq... I am afraid that I'll not get biochem....
I disagree entirely. I got a 32 percent on a calc II exam and withdrew from the course... eventually retook it to get a B-... I guess I'm not capable of success in medical school.
No doubt about it, the D was careless. That said, I got a C in a 400-level medical microbiology course this semester. First recorded C in college -- had two C+'s before it. I could see how senioritis could lead to a D but you should have kept that in C range. Oh well... I say retake the course if you feel that you need to...
Orgo in med school??...ROFLMAO.
QUOTE]
Nobody said that.
I disagree entirely. I got a 32 percent on a calc II exam and withdrew from the course... eventually retook it to get a B-... I guess I'm not capable of success in medical school.
No doubt about it, the D was careless. That said, I got a C in a 400-level medical microbiology course this semester. First recorded C in college -- had two C+'s before it. I could see how senioritis could lead to a D but you should have kept that in C range. Oh well... I say retake the course if you feel that you need to...
I'm sorry but there's no reason why a person capable of completing medical school, passing 3 steps of board exams, etc. etc. should get a D in any class. Makes me wonder if the OP is fit for the rigors of medical training/career.
yes there are. Major illness (like cancer) being one.
Still not. Take responsibility and withdraw from the classes.
Hey, I didn't want to be a quitter! Plus, I didn't know what was happening to me until the tumor was literally popping out of my neck Spring of freshman year.
yes there are. Major illness (like cancer) being one.
Well then, you weren't feeling the symptoms of the tumor? I don't see a reason for making a D then.
And why the heck am I explaining it to you? You're infamous for baiting people, and you're not on any adcom panels so your opinion means squat to pretty much everyone here.
Sweetheart, how do you know the physiology of what was happening to me and when?
And why the heck am I explaining it to you? You're infamous for baiting people, and you're not on any adcom panels so your opinion means squat to pretty much everyone here.
I disagree entirely. I got a 32 percent on a calc II exam and withdrew from the course... eventually retook it to get a B-... I guess I'm not capable of success in medical school.
You say you didn't know you had a tumor until it was protruding from your neck. No vomiting, no other effects from the tumor. Tell me, was this tumor even malignant?
Now, if you had major problems related to the tumor, sure, I could "let you slide." However, in any case, you should have withdrawn (unless it "happened" towards the end of the spring semester -- in which case you didn't say so, either.)
Things like this are excempt of course.
But you take a person who is capable of completing medical school and becoming a physician...well, there is no reason that they cannot perform well enough academically to at least hit a C...minimum.
Of course...I have met a few medical students over the years who probably had a hard time learning to tie their shoes.
Someone who is going to be a physician should allow senioritis to result in a D.
You say you didn't know you had a tumor until it was protruding from your neck. No vomiting, no other effects from the tumor. Tell me, was this tumor even malignant?
Now, if you had major problems related to the tumor, sure, I could "let you slide." However, in any case, you should have withdrawn (unless it "happened" towards the end of the spring semester -- in which case you didn't say so, either.)
Looks like you'll find out shortly, eh?
My original comment was both a challenge to the OP and a complement to those who've finished medical school/post-doc training. I don't give a rip about how someone managed to achieve a D (no matter the course) or why someone else dropped a course... I'm just saying that I'd be surprised if I came across a doctor who actually did that poorly in an undergraduate course given that medical students and physicians are typically intelligent AND self-motivated people. In the event that the person hadn't even started medical school, I would question their academic intelligence and/or their self-motivation - and therefore, there ability to meet the challenges of a formal medical education.
Am I way off base here? Somebody help me out if you think I am!
So I guess all physicians since the dawn of time have been this way, from when they were born until the day they died?
Now youre getting ridiculous.
So I guess all physicians since the dawn of time have been this way, from when they were born until the day they died?
I worry about the same. I got a D in my Calc class....
Maybe, but that's perceived so much differently from making one in your senior year, after applying and interviewing at med schools. Upward trends= good.
My cousin, who failed out of college after his freshman year, bounced back, scored a 38S on his MCAT, graduated 2nd in his class in med school, scored outstanding on his boards, and is now a surgical resident at Jefferson, and is doing awesome.
So to say that someone who got a D in college shouldn't be a physician is simply untrue and a pretty ridiculous statement.
You are now officially the reigning biggest dick on all of SDN *hands over crown* Even I wouldn't sink that low.....
You say you didn't know you had a tumor until it was protruding from your neck. No vomiting, no other effects from the tumor. Tell me, was this tumor even malignant?
Now, if you had major problems related to the tumor, sure, I could "let you slide." However, in any case, you should have withdrawn (unless it "happened" towards the end of the spring semester -- in which case you didn't say so, either.)
I'm sorry but there's no reason why a person capable of completing medical school, passing 3 steps of board exams, etc. etc. should get a D in any class. Makes me wonder if the OP is fit for the rigors of medical training/career.
Looks like you'll find out shortly, eh?
My original comment was both a challenge to the OP and a complement to those who've finished medical school/post-doc training. I don't give a rip about how someone managed to achieve a D (no matter the course) or why someone else dropped a course... I'm just saying that I'd be surprised if I came across a doctor who actually did that poorly in an undergraduate course given that medical students and physicians are typically intelligent AND self-motivated people. In the event that the person hadn't even started medical school, I would question their academic intelligence and/or their self-motivation - and therefore, there ability to meet the challenges of a formal medical education.
Am I way off base here? Somebody help me out if you think I am!
Maybe you have forgotten what you posted. Although you did not say directly some one with a D should not be a physician you distinctly said you wondered if they could handle medical school.
Yes, you are off base. I know two doctors personally (One I shadowed and one who was a family friend) who both got D's in undergrad. One even got an F. Both are practicing physicians. One is a derm, the other is in an internal medicine residency and thinking about a cardiology fellowship.
And you think it's unreasonable to wonder? How is wondering about someone's abilities (based upon their own performance) anything like barring them from matriculation. Wondering about items, good and bad, on an application essentially defines what ADCOMS do!!!
...I know two doctors personally (One I shadowed and one who was a family friend) who both got D's in undergrad. One even got an F...
I think forming an opinion about someone solely based on the idea of one or two grades is a joke...hence why I was accepted to med school I guess...
That's not the point at all because the OP had already gone through interviews, was waitlisted at a couple of schools, and THEN got a D in the last semester of school. MOst med school acceptances are conditional-- conditional on the fact that you continue to make good grades. Making a D in the last semester (without having a really darned good reason) is enough to have your acceptance revoked.
Yes, it's possible to get in with a D or F, but having one early in your career as a college student is not necessarily bad. Showing that you were able to "buckle down" and improve your grades may actually be a good thing. Showing that you got to the end and slacked off (if that is the case) is NOT a good thing.
Are you even reading my posts?? Seriously...read them again.