Alliecat, I know from previous encounters that you agree with a lot of what Knecht says and that is fine, you are entitled to your opinion, however, I am also entitled to mine. Just because this person sees doom and gloom doesn't mean I am not spending plenty of time around practioners that love their careers. I offered to bring out the info from AAHA which contradicts what he says WHEN I HAVE TIME to go through my files. I am sorry I am unwilling to drop everything to sort through all the stuff from this semester and last to find a detail that isn't a top priority to me when we start finals in 2.5 weeks. Occasionally, I have better stuff to do than track down citations.
I never attacked him personally, but I also know that employers and review committees are just as competent at playing with google as I am. Can you honestly say that you would want to spend your time, day in and day out, with someone who is unhappy with their profession? OK, maybe you would...there are individuals who love that stuff. I don't, and I didn't when i was the person hiring and reviewing applications. I know that if I came up with the negativity I found in 2 minutes of googling, it would be bottom of the pile. He is suggesting that we pursue other options...well, I am suggesting that he may find more happiness in his career if he reframes his perception of it and/or moves into a career that he would prefer.
Maybe he is right; I should turn around and go back to a career where I have already hit the top of the field, and there isn't much space to move in, where there are entire institutions closing down (strange, I haven't seen any vet school close), and where I can't be the actual owner. Or maybe finding a different field would be the right option for that individual, not necessarily for everyone else.
Also, why is your experience or this Dr's more relevant than anyone else's? Why keep comparing your personal experience with things like surgery if you don't know everyone else's? At this point, I have already performed 9 recovered surgeries and another half dozen that were terminated for research. After this semester ends, that number will increase by at least another half dozen. This summer will be more. That is more than any vet I have worked with had in the first year. I suppose it could all be tragic after this year, but I doubt that. Part of this is pursueing oppurtunities, much like pursueing research for Dr. Knecht. Why was that anyone's responsibility other than his? If that is his current road block, doesn't that reflect on what he did in school, not on whether the profession is failing? I guess I see that linked about as closely as ice cream and drowning.
You are correct, it isn't wrong to point out frustrations, it also isn't wrong to point out what may be the issue for an individual. You may come across as absolutly thrilled everywhere but on SDN, but that isn't true for Dr. Knecht; online he has gone to the extent of encouraging parents to discourage 12 year olds interested in this field. Actually, that sounds kind of like what you said in your post...and how on earth do you KNOW that every other career is likely far more lucrative and less headache? How many of these careers have you pursued?
And why even bring up your role on SDN?
Okay, totally IMHO and not as part of any pseudo-official role on SDN...but...
Yes, affecting change is the goal--but it's not wrong to point out why you're frustrated with the profession you once fell in love with.
Even though I haven't yet graduated, I can't say that I would actively encourage anyone with the slightest inkling to pursue a different career to go for veterinary school.
However, personally, if there's ANYthing else you can see yourself doing, that other career is likely to be far less of a headache and relatively more lucrative--for the vast majority of new veterinarians out there. (Specialty/industry veterinarians are a rather small percentage.)