Considering that we rounded three times a day on say 35-60 patients I felt I learned a lot as usually I would be following 5 of the patients personally and instructing the remaining students on what to go accomplish before rounds. Each of those 30 patients I would assess the diagnosis, post-operative day, blood cultures, review radiology in the computer, what antibiotics they were on, did they have pre-op labs done?, and vitals and had to run and check doppler's on vascular patients. And the ever popular getting a patient up at midnight to walk around the hospital because they won't and they have atlectasis and they are going to get a pneumoniae. Did you ask the radiologist if there any signs of air in the billiary system, is there any signs of necrosis, the residents will want to know. Do you know how to doppler for pulses? Let me go show you, . . . Just go do a blood draw for cbc, ua, the resident will want it anyway . . . By the end of the rotation I was evaluating patients on surgery consults in the ER, and paging the resident for the inevitable appendectomy quickly and efficiently because I had to go do the stupid list.
2-3 patients/student is a joke, when I wasn't doing the list it was 11-14 patients, and yes you do everything for them as a student from blood cultures to urine cultures to moving them around the hospital, most of us were collapsing from exhaustion when we left after 30 hours . . . 2-3 patients in a whole 24 hours sounds like a "holiday" surgery clerkship, unless you are talking an elective, I was pleased when I only had like 6-7 patients in the sicu that was a vacation and weird watching PGY-2 surgery residents that didn't have the strength to manage even 7 patients, sad, of course they know I did my surgery core at the big university hospital so that garnered instant respect as I was the one who "formerly did the list." Considering that I did 5-6 patients on my own and monitored 35-60 patients frantically and did *very* well on the shelf exam and surgery on step 2, I would say I learned more than you students who may have sleep during their call on surgery clerkship, something I never had the luxury to do.
That's a bit presumptuous, IMHO.
While I cannot comment on how much my students learned, please rest assured that if there was work to be done, traumas or consults to be seen, they were not sleeping. Given that they did well on their matches, I'd venture that they must have learned something and if their reports are to be believed, are doing well in residency despite the "vacation surgery rotation" they had with me (and my colleagues as my practice was shared by my fellow residents).
2-3 patients is not a joke when you may have only 10 or fewer patients on service or are dealing with SICU patients. Or if there are more patients, and plenty of residents and other students. It was dependent on a lot of things; students may have seen more patients on larger services such as trauma but it was unusual for us to go over 40 patients per service and it would be much much less for rotations like Transplant, Colorectal, Surg Onc, etc.
I'm sure your former residents would be pleased to know that you thought you managed the patients better than they. For a medical student to manage 6 or 7 SICU patients, seems a bit dangerous to me. Then again, I'm funny that way.
My goal was for students to know everything about their patients, to be in the OR with them (how do you round 3 times a day on 35-60 patients and be in the OR?) and follow them closely. Our attendings wanted the students in the OR and therefore, they were available for am and pm rounds but the rest of the day was in the OR.
If I and they felt they could handle more, then they got them, but most 3rd year students are not capable of rounding on 10 patients, writing 10 notes, and really understanding the concepts behind surgical management. All it takes is to read the A/P and see that it would degenerate into a rote "ambulate TID, advance diet to X, pain control prn and discharge planning" without any real thought as to how to manage THIS patient.
Rounding on more patients, collecting their vitals and labs and spending 2-3 hrs every day in front of the computer doesn't make for a better student or a better understanding of surgery. Perhaps you are better than the average; that may very well be the case but others may learn differently. Since you are not going into a surgical field and have experienced what kinds of students are out there, you shouldn't be suprised that others are not as interested or hard-working. Therefore, why should I ask a student who is only minimally interested in surgery to spend hours collecting data which doesn't teach him or her a significant amount of surgery? I'd rather they:
a) learn a skill which will help them in whatever career they may choose; so that entails learning how to suture, how to evaluate a wound for infection, healing problems, how to dress a wound, remove a drain and of course, how to evaluate a surgical abdomen and other potential surgical problems, when and how to call a consult;
b) have some fun. Most students enjoy the OR, even those who hate surgery.
I'm all for the team concept but when a student rounds on 10 patients, that's 10 patients the resident also has to examine and 10 notes the resident has to read (and we all know how long med student notes are) and co-sign. To paraphrase a famous House of God quote: "Show me a medical student who doesn't triple my work..."
Therefore, I'd much prefer that the student see a reasonable number of patients (which depends on census, student interest and ability), learn some detailed surgical concepts and a few key surgical skills. Using a medical student to lighten the resident's load is not appropriate and if you ask me, that's what the residents were doing to you.
It may not be clear to you, but I and others have recognized that your experience is not the norm for most students. It may have made you an excellent senior student but it is presumptuous that one needs to do what you did to excel on their rotation, Step 2 or to match into the specialty of their choice.
Lastly, I find it odd that you complain about being scutted and when I agree that your experience sounds like you were, you begin to defend it. Classic Stockholm syndrome.