Thanks
Last edited:
Thanks. So there may be an even higher likelihood of going out in the fields and possibly overseas? Naive thought, but even if I do a residency in pediatrics?
I think I'm really leaning towards cancelling my app, though I'm still trying to research all the pros and cons.
I've heard the 3-year scholarships are more competitive and there aren't automatic acceptances, but if it's any help, my stats are 3.6 and a 32.
I don't know if that's good enough army-wise, so I might not even get it if I apply, which would make things simpler 😉.
I have thought about the Army Reserve as well, but I decided against it since they only pay back what you officially borrowed from banks/lenders. I'll have loans for my 3rd and 4th years, but my parents will be eating up their savings for my 2nd year.
Again, I know I really shouldn't do it for the money, but this would help my parents so much regardless of what they say. They aren't getting any younger, and I feel terrible that they still have to work so hard to help me.
Do it!!!! It's free money.
Hi everyone,
Sorry for an upcoming essay, but please bare with me.
I'm part way through my HPSP application, but after talking to my parents again, I'm having second thoughts. Also having second thoughts since everyone I've talked to outside the army has discouraged it.
I'm applying for the 3-year scholarship, and I'm one of the naive med students who were drawn in really because of the money. I also figured that since I'm really interested in family medicine, the residency time and later commitment wouldn't be too long. (3 year scholarship, 3 year residency, 3 years of pay-back after residency).
My parents are strongly discouraging it even though I know we are short on money. They state that they'd rather help me out with loans by double mortgaging their house than for me to commit myself to the army.
While they are afraid that I won't be happy with a super far out-of-state residency (which is true, but I'm not guaranteed to stay in state anyway), they're mainly afraid of where I'll be placed after my residency during my pay-back years of working. Working in San Antonio, Honolulu, or Washington is fine. But they're worried that for my three years, I'll be forced-shipped to work in Germany or somewhere out of the country for a year or two (I'm afraid of that too).
I know people say you shouldn't do this if you have any form of regret, and you definitely shouldn't do this because of the money, but I'd still love some more opinions. My current private school is really expensive (50k+ tuition. And housing is another $1000+ a month). Again, the money would help out my parents so much.
Any opinions would be great. I'm afraid of future regret even though the stipend and covered tuition will help a lot.
I'd also feel bad to let my recruiter down and telling him that I'm not doing this anymore after he did all the site visits and paperwork.
TLDR: Afraid of regretting signing up for HPSP. Really just afraid of forced working out-of-country during my pay-back years. Also, don't know how to tell my recruiter without really disappointing him after all the work.
Thanks!
My first assignment as an internist was in a very remote area where I was 90 miles from a small regional airport and 140 miles from a standard airport. The nearest Best Buy or mall was 90 miles away. The super center Walmart was the only place where I could grocery shop or buy supplies for my place.
I am not sure why your parents would take out a second mortgage for you for medical school. You should take out the loans. Professional loans will cover medical school tuition and living allowances. It's a bad idea for parents to take out loans for their kids, when their child can do so for themselves. From what you describe, it sounds like you are a bit of a home-body and a bit cuddled by your parents. The military will be a very poor fit. If you want to do primary care, there are plenty of awful locations within the U.S. that are remote. Before I specialized, I was internal medicine. My first assignment as an internist was in a very remote area where I was 90 miles from a small regional airport and 140 miles from a standard airport. The nearest Best Buy or mall was 90 miles away. The super center Walmart was the only place where I could grocery shop or buy supplies for my place. You will also deploy from anywhere from 4.5 to 9 months depending if your hospital can split a deployment billeting. On my last deployment, there was a FP guy from Germany. His base couldn't afford to send someone to split a tour with him, so he was there the entire 9 months. If you are away from family, you have to request leave (which can be denied) to travel 250 miles outside of your assigned base on your days off.
Like others have said, there are other options for loan repayment. If you don't mind the military, consider joining after residency into active duty or during residency into the reserves. You have a lot more control that way of where you'll be stationed if active duty.
words
Third: Stop worrying about money. You're going to be able to pay it all off.
I wonder if we crossed paths... I know those mileage markers too well.
Oi... "high price" compared to what? Folks justify HPSP by talking the doom and gloom of medical school loans, but I haven't heard a lot of good examples of more financially secure pathways.Lower paid specialties coupled with private med school compounded debt can be a very, very heavy burden. Med school + residency is a high price to pay for what may turn out to be a barely middle class existence for 10 years or more of loan repayment.
Sure. There are also folks with multiple mortgages and folks taking care of ill parents. There are many scenarios of deep debt. And in those scenarios, folks are almost always better off NOT going HPSP, as they will have much more freedom in selecting residencies and jobs with higher income potential.There are a fair number of people who exit residency with more than $300K of debt, particularly those with private undergrad + private med school loans.
True. The "average" medical school debt was something like $130K when I last looked. Family money (and HPSP and NHSC) definitely drive that down.Keep in mind that "average" med school debt looks reasonable, but it's not a normal distribution - there are a lot of people who finish with no debt (family money) and a lot of people with obscene debt.
And often a nightmare folks have to have some accountability for. I notice that folks with the $400K debt tended to go to private schools rather than their lowly state school. I predict that with the proliferation of DO schools and for-profits (and the fact that the young are more into immediate gratification rather than taking the slow-and-steady path) the number of grads with high debt will likely increase.The overlapping areas in that particular Venn diagram is the stuff nightmares are made of.
Agreed. I think it's important to emphasize this to folks. Go to a junior college and/or state school. Choose the cheapest medical school you can. And when all is said and done, it's going to suck paying it all back. Whether military or civilian.I'm simply pointing out that it's not exactly a luxurious path for the average FP grad who's leaving residency with the an extra $300K+ 10-yr mortgage at 6.8% and starting a job at $150K.
Noooooooooo. We got in on the IBR/PSLF through a loophole. That was never intended for physicians. And when 2017 rolls around and rather than teachers and social workers wiping out their $70K of debt, you have a bunch of docs making $200K trying to wipe out $200K of debt, you're going to see that thing close double-time. I'd strongly recommend folks not expecting IBR/PSLF to be a way to avoid their paying back what they've borrowed.There's a reason why there's such a thing as "income based repayment" for doctors, and the various serve-the-underserved loan reduction and repayment programs.
I think you're absolutely right, and would expect rich greedy doctors to be excluded when the day comes that the program comes up for revision.Noooooooooo. We got in on the IBR/PSLF through a loophole. That was never intended for physicians. And when 2017 rolls around and rather than teachers and social workers wiping out their $70K of debt, you have a bunch of docs making $200K trying to wipe out $200K of debt, you're going to see that thing close double-time. I'd strongly recommend folks not expecting IBR/PSLF to be a way to avoid their paying back what they've borrowed.
Reload.I am greedy... I need moar ammo.
I think you're absolutely right, and would expect rich greedy doctors to be excluded when the day comes that the program comes up for revision.
sorry if it seems like i'm hijacking your post but i'm kinda in a similar predicament. I did want to join the army or USMC after high school (b/c of all the brainwashing) but after college, i don't want to serve politicians that do all these effed up things. i still believe in supporting the troops though, as a good amount of my high school buddies joined the military and i would like to serve them and their families as a physician. i already got my HPSP app started with a recruiter but kind of regret it now. reading this forum makes me think that the cons of HPSP far outweigh the pros. do you know what you're gonna do?Hi everyone,
Sorry for an upcoming essay, but please bare with me.
I'm part way through my HPSP application, but after talking to my parents again, I'm having second thoughts. Also having second thoughts since everyone I've talked to outside the army has discouraged it.
I'm applying for the 3-year scholarship, and I'm one of the naive med students who were drawn in really because of the money. I also figured that since I'm really interested in family medicine, the residency time and later commitment wouldn't be too long. (3 year scholarship, 3 year residency, 3 years of pay-back after residency).
My parents are strongly discouraging it even though I know we are short on money. They state that they'd rather help me out with loans by double mortgaging their house than for me to commit myself to the army.
While they are afraid that I won't be happy with a super far out-of-state residency (which is true, but I'm not guaranteed to stay in state anyway), they're mainly afraid of where I'll be placed after my residency during my pay-back years of working. Working in San Antonio, Honolulu, or Washington is fine. But they're worried that for my three years, I'll be forced-shipped to work in Germany or somewhere out of the country for a year or two (I'm afraid of that too).
I know people say you shouldn't do this if you have any form of regret, and you definitely shouldn't do this because of the money, but I'd still love some more opinions. My current private school is really expensive (50k+ tuition. And housing is another $1000+ a month). Again, the money would help out my parents so much.
Any opinions would be great. I'm afraid of future regret even though the stipend and covered tuition will help a lot.
I'd also feel bad to let my recruiter down and telling him that I'm not doing this anymore after he did all the site visits and paperwork.
TLDR: Afraid of regretting signing up for HPSP. Really just afraid of forced working out-of-country during my pay-back years. Also, don't know how to tell my recruiter without really disappointing him after all the work.
Thanks!
What?? NO "nvm"??? Like HUNDREDS of other posts? You're slipping!!nevermind
i still believe in supporting the troops t........... do you know what you're gonna do?
I am not sure why your parents would take out a second mortgage for you for medical school. You should take out the loans. Professional loans will cover medical school tuition and living allowances. It's a bad idea for parents to take out loans for their kids, when their child can do so for themselves. From what you describe, it sounds like you are a bit of a home-body and a bit cuddled by your parents. The military will be a very poor fit. If you want to do primary care, there are plenty of awful locations within the U.S. that are remote. Before I specialized, I was internal medicine. My first assignment as an internist was in a very remote area where I was 90 miles from a small regional airport and 140 miles from a standard airport. The nearest Best Buy or mall was 90 miles away. The super center Walmart was the only place where I could grocery shop or buy supplies for my place. You will also deploy from anywhere from 4.5 to 9 months depending if your hospital can split a deployment billeting. On my last deployment, there was a FP guy from Germany. His base couldn't afford to send someone to split a tour with him, so he was there the entire 9 months. If you are away from family, you have to request leave (which can be denied) to travel 250 miles outside of your assigned base on your days off.
Like others have said, there are other options for loan repayment. If you don't mind the military, consider joining after residency into active duty or during residency into the reserves. You have a lot more control that way of where you'll be stationed if active duty.
sorry if it seems like i'm hijacking your post but i'm kinda in a similar predicament. I did want to join the army or USMC after high school (b/c of all the brainwashing) but after college, i don't want to serve politicians that do all these effed up things. i still believe in supporting the troops though, as a good amount of my high school buddies joined the military and i would like to serve them and their families as a physician. i already got my HPSP app started with a recruiter but kind of regret it now. reading this forum makes me think that the cons of HPSP far outweigh the pros. do you know what you're gonna do?
I'd LOVE myself a year's deployment to Germany. Or Japan.
Or Fort Riley? How about FLW? Far more likely.
Hi everyone,
Sorry for an upcoming essay, but please bare with me.
I'm part way through my HPSP application, but after talking to my parents again, I'm having second thoughts. Also having second thoughts since everyone I've talked to outside the army has discouraged it.
I'm applying for the 3-year scholarship, and I'm one of the naive med students who were drawn in really because of the money. I also figured that since I'm really interested in family medicine, the residency time and later commitment wouldn't be too long. (3 year scholarship, 3 year residency, 3 years of pay-back after residency).
My parents are strongly discouraging it even though I know we are short on money. They state that they'd rather help me out with loans by double mortgaging their house than for me to commit myself to the army.
While they are afraid that I won't be happy with a super far out-of-state residency (which is true, but I'm not guaranteed to stay in state anyway), they're mainly afraid of where I'll be placed after my residency during my pay-back years of working. Working in San Antonio, Honolulu, or Washington is fine. But they're worried that for my three years, I'll be forced-shipped to work in Germany or somewhere out of the country for a year or two (I'm afraid of that too).
I know people say you shouldn't do this if you have any form of regret, and you definitely shouldn't do this because of the money, but I'd still love some more opinions. My current private school is really expensive (50k+ tuition. And housing is another $1000+ a month). Again, the money would help out my parents so much.
Any opinions would be great. I'm afraid of future regret even though the stipend and covered tuition will help a lot.
I'd also feel bad to let my recruiter down and telling him that I'm not doing this anymore after he did all the site visits and paperwork.
TLDR: Afraid of regretting signing up for HPSP. Really just afraid of forced working out-of-country during my pay-back years. Also, don't know how to tell my recruiter without really disappointing him after all the work.
Thanks!