- Joined
- Jun 8, 2005
- Messages
- 152
- Reaction score
- 2
That's right. I don't know if I am a lone voice in the wilderness or what.
It seems like most everyone here uses either Secrets or Crush, same information right? Well, I just wanted to say for anyone who is looking at buying books right now that IMHO, Crush is too cursory. I don't mean like "you can only read Crush after you've done a pass through the material once because it's so high yield" (i.e. FA for Step 1). I mean like they leave out a ton of stuff that I think is probably pretty high yield (to judge from other review books and USMLEWorld), and they include stuff which is too basic.
I don't really like FA for Step 2 either, I think Boards and Wards is my favorite except the small type being hard on my eyes. Crush has a nice easy to read typeface and layout... if only it was as high yield as I wanted it to be.
Oh by the way, while I'm spouting off my opinion on books, I did most of Kaplan Qbook and I liked it for Medicine and Surgery (though not as much as UW) but thought their OB/GYN section was unbelievably poorly done. I got nearly every question right in the OB/GYN section of Qbook with about a half hour of material review, and then went on to completely suck on USMLEWorld for it (so clearly not much was learned from that whole experience). Hope that is helpful to someone out there.
It seems like most everyone here uses either Secrets or Crush, same information right? Well, I just wanted to say for anyone who is looking at buying books right now that IMHO, Crush is too cursory. I don't mean like "you can only read Crush after you've done a pass through the material once because it's so high yield" (i.e. FA for Step 1). I mean like they leave out a ton of stuff that I think is probably pretty high yield (to judge from other review books and USMLEWorld), and they include stuff which is too basic.
I don't really like FA for Step 2 either, I think Boards and Wards is my favorite except the small type being hard on my eyes. Crush has a nice easy to read typeface and layout... if only it was as high yield as I wanted it to be.
Oh by the way, while I'm spouting off my opinion on books, I did most of Kaplan Qbook and I liked it for Medicine and Surgery (though not as much as UW) but thought their OB/GYN section was unbelievably poorly done. I got nearly every question right in the OB/GYN section of Qbook with about a half hour of material review, and then went on to completely suck on USMLEWorld for it (so clearly not much was learned from that whole experience). Hope that is helpful to someone out there.