Impressions during interviews

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

NoSz

Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2005
Messages
35
Reaction score
1
Points
4,531
I thought, I start a thread that might help next year's applicants or at least delight some of you. Maybe you can add more.

During my interviews I had some strange experiences with fellow applicants that I thought did not really let them shine (but of course, I have no idea whether that influenced their match).

- Quite a lot of guys were not able to sit straight, neither during pre-interview dinner nor during the interview day lunch or get-together with the residents. Some really lolled self-confidently in their chairs- legs wide open, head resting comfortably much too close to the seat. Looked like sitting in front of the TV watching adult-only stuff by themselves.

- Pre-interview dinner- Some people ordered lots of booze. That's fine for the residents, but I think it does leave a bad impression if you drink heavily the day before your interview. Also, some people cannot eat properly. Here again mother's rules: Keep your mouth closed while chewing, do not talk or spit or both while chewing, keep your hands on the table most of the time, don't touch all of the shared appetizers with your fingers before grabbing half of the plate for yourself.

- Some people vocalized very strong political opinions during the day(s). I remember this one guy high-jacking a nice chat with his thoughts about extramarital sex being the core of all problems while other residents and staff were present (in Southern California, not the bible belt).

- Yawning- Believe me, I was tired sometimes having jetlag and more. But some people just could not stop yawning at all. By all means- drink more coffee and please cover your mouth, it looks better.

Some positive surprises:

- I never saw any crazy makeup or daring hair-do in the female applicants. Most girls looked really plain. Very few skirts.

- Basically everybody wore black, some color daredevils dark gray or one even brown. I guess more color could really set you up from your fellow applicants. So if your steps are not that great maybe try dark green or blue.

All in all I really enjoyed meeting other applicants, neurologists are a really nice bunch of people (no prejudice here 🙂 ).

I also only had one strange interview, but the PD was sick that day and they substituted with a chief resident who must have read Iverson's right before the interview and asked all theses strange questions (What would you do if a junior resident complained about too much work? ---And then? ---And then? --- And then? - By the end, I nearly screamed at him- "Just kick that idiot out and take me instead of him, I would not complain if someone helped me that much".)

Hope we all match at the best places for us.
 
I agree in part with your comments on strange experiences with other applicants, but then I feel that you should be yourself on interviews and if that involves being anti pre marital sex and feel the need to voice it, so be it. If you end up offending people then you're probably not right for the program.

The most important advice I can give is be yourself.

I had the need to yawn on many conferences I sat through (but was able to suppress it). I drank booze but not heavily and I think I sat up straight but who knows? If a program rejects me because I slouch then they can kiss my A--!

I'm not a pretentious guy, and I feel that a program will accept me based on how well I've done in school and whom I am, and not whether I am a good yesman...
 
who must have read Iverson's right before the interview

It's Iserson's, and it's a good read.

Ladies - your suit really does look less professional with a girly purse draped over your shoulder. Use a portfolio instead. Don't use a scrunchy in your hair. And be prepared to walk quite a bit - yes, we can all tell you're limping in your cute shoes.

Men - cologne is great, but go lightly! Don't overdo the hair gel, either, and shine those shoes.
 
Iserson's really is the best advice. I thought most of it was obvious when I read it but apparently not because some people did some stupid things.
I agree... NO purses and guys shouldn't wear colonge at all. I got a headache sitting next to a few guys.
I saw some people make political jokes (different than stating opinions maturely), order 2 and 3 times as much food and drink then other people, complain about everything and slouch down in their chairs like they were taking a nap.
I couldn't believe how many people responded to little questions about their trip and the interviews season with complaint after complaint. I think it makes you look like a whiner and no fun to be around.

Another thing that amazed me and I would love feedback on is how almost every single girl I interviewed with wore no makeup, no jewlrey and pulled their hair straight back. Did I miss the memo? I am not criticizing, I am just surprised. Any thoughts on this? Iserson says not to look like you are hitting the bars or going on a date, but if you are someone who usually wears earrings (you can see the holes in their ears) or makeup why leave it all at home for an interview?
 
limits of common courtesy:

Be on time to the interview day...If you're staying at the same hotel as the other applicants and waiting for everyone to come downstairs to go to the interview together, fine...But don't let another applicant make you late, especially not 20 minutes after the PD has already started the introduction! 😎
 
penguins said:
Another thing that amazed me and I would love feedback on is how almost every single girl I interviewed with wore no makeup, no jewlrey and pulled their hair straight back. Did I miss the memo? I am not criticizing, I am just surprised. Any thoughts on this? Iserson says not to look like you are hitting the bars or going on a date, but if you are someone who usually wears earrings (you can see the holes in their ears) or makeup why leave it all at home for an interview?

We must not have interviewed together. Like other single women I interviewed with, I wore makeup and jewelry and let my hair down without looking like a tramp.
 
:laugh:
Good to hear. Seriously, I encountered 1 other girl on the trail who wore makeup/earrings, etc. Maybe it was regional.
I don't think small earrings and a necklace is gaudy but I was always the only one. 😕
 
Top Bottom