Inclined Plane as a non-ideal machine (EK in-class question)

[ELTURC0]

---

Members do not see this ad.

This question is about a NON-ideal inclined plane being used to lift a crate to 3 ms of height. The question (Question #83, UNit 4 Physics) asks which of the statements are true, and based on the answer key, the correct answer is : "The non-ideal inclined plane decreases the F required and increases W"

I understand why the Work increases, as a non-ideal inclined plane has frictional forces to be overcome. But by the same token, doesn't the force required also increase? Why is the force decreasing??

 

[exacto]

Im not sure to the answer because i dont have the question in front of me, but I believe its comparing different types of ramps to no ramps? maybe?

If so, then having no ramp will make a person lift the block straight up in the y coordinate plane. When you add a ramp, it adds a partial x coordinate as well as the partial y coordinate dispersing some of the force, thus causing the force to decrease when compared to no ramp.

if you add the full question/choices, it would help!

 

[sazerac]

You aren't comparing the force with a non-ideal plane vs the force on an ideal plane.

You are comparing the force of a non-ideal plane vs the force when there is no plane at all.

 

[ELTURC0]

Thanks you, that makes sense.