- Joined
- Jun 4, 2003
- Messages
- 63
- Reaction score
- 0
What are the actual differences in the residency (length, hours, call, etc.) between the 2?
jkin said:What are the actual differences in the residency (length, hours, call, etc.) between the 2?
GSresident said:It does seem strange, however, that those same people argue that the breadth and scope of a 'plastic and reconstructive surgery' practice demands a fully trained surgeon and not just a OMFS etc. .
Are you saying that you feel Oral and Maxillofacial surgeons are not fully trained surgeons? How does OMFS differ to ENT in that respect? Do you not consider an ENT to be a fully trained surgeon? They both may not be doing boob jobs or treating full body burn victims which obviously fall within the scope of plastics. But both are just as capable in handling head and neck oncology, trauma reconstruction, as well as head and neck cosmetic procedures. ENT just handles a bit more of the ear and sinus infections, tonsillectomies, and neck dissections; and OMFS handles more of the orthognathic, distraction, and cleft palate cases.GSresident said:It really depends on the program, but if you do the integrated route its 2 less years of general surgery call. That might be a good thing or it might be bad. Remember, the 2 years of general surgery that you would be missing are chief years - the years when you actually learn to operate in most programs. I don't know what it is like at other institutions, but at my institution chief call isn't as bad as intern or mid level call. Mostly we just sleep unless we go to the operating room. No floor calls and the midlevels handle most of the consults and traumas. We call staff and decide to go to the operating room and thats about it. There are those who say that the 2 years of general surgery aren't really applicable to plastic surgery. I don't know if they are right or wrong. It does seem strange, however, that those same people argue that the breadth and scope of a 'plastic and reconstructive surgery' practice demands a fully trained surgeon and not just a OMFS etc. I chose to complete 5 years of general surgery training so I am naturally biased. All I can say is that there is a HUGE difference between residents who have done 1200 cases and residents who have done 400. (400 being how many cases you will probably get by the time you finish your 3rd year.) There is a HUGE difference between residents who have done 750 cases and those who have done 400 for that matter. Oh well. I hope this doesn't just throw fuel on the age old debate. I don't really feel like getting flamed, so just keep in mind, this is just my opinion.