Interview Experiences

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

CaipirinhaQuinho

Senior Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2005
Messages
248
Reaction score
1
It seems like everyone is looking for some information on the interviews this year so here's my thoughts on a couple of the interviews I went on. I will try to be as honest as I can without being negative to the school. Essentially I'll talk about what I liked, disliked, and my overall feel of the school. Hopefully, everyone else will do the same.
 
NYU:
The NYU trip was very pleasant. It was my first interview and I didn't know what to expect. They put us up in a really metro-looking hotel called the Marcel. It was a few blocks away from the school so make sure you give yourself about 20min of walking time just to make it to the office early. They had bagels, juice, and coffee available when we got there to eat during the introduction to the program by Dr. Ulane. Dr. Ulane and Arlene are extremely nice and approachable. They seemed to really care about each student personally and put their all into the program. I think a strong support staff is going to be very important in such a long program. The interviews we also really laid back. I had 2 PhD interviews in the morning. I was amazed at how easy and relaxing they were. It was actually very enjoyable and I learned a lot about their research. They mostly talked about my research and asked some questions about my application, but nothing hard. Then we went to lunch with students and were back for another 2 interviews after lunch. My third interviewer really grilled me on my research, but after I weathered his flurry of questions he eased off and started to "sell" me his impressive lab. The last interview of the day was very relaxed and it seemed like the interviewer was just trying to get me out of there as quickly as possible which was fine with me. All in all there were 4 interviews which is a joy compared to the 11 I just had at UVa. There wasn't any specific "medical school" interview like I've had at other schools so I didn't get any traditional medical school questions. As for the dinners, they were both very enjoyable. The students are really cool and really just want to have a good time. We went to some metro-restaurants so you should dress like a new yorker if that means anything to you. All in all it was a really good time and if you like a city campus then you will love NYU. The students are very social and actually cool people. I had a great time.
 
👍 Make sure you submit your reviews to intransit as well.
 
Well, I just returned from my NYU interview. I submitted a full rambling review to intransit, but I thought I'd share some info that the director, Rod Ulane, told us. NYU MSTP expects 250-280 applications this year. They are about halfway through their interview season and plan to interview ~70 applicants. In December or early January, they will notify applicants of their status, and will extend offers of admission to ~35 for a class size of 10-12.

Dr. Ulane shared with us the results of an informal study he'd done on one class of MSTP graduates from several top programs. He let us know that he considered the few grads in private practice to be failures of the program, but that the majority of the graduates were working in academic medicine and he was pleased about that. People who ended up in other roles, like in govenmental positions, fell somewhere in the middle of his continuum of success.
 
*looks around for titan02*

hey titan, if you read this, how'd your WashU interview go?
 
stherling said:
*looks around for titan02*

hey titan, if you read this, how'd your WashU interview go?

All that I have to say is the WUSTL MSTP has the most well-organized administration that I have experienced to date. When I arrived at the MSTP office there was a pseudo-leather portfolio waiting for me (not one of those paper folders) filled with information on Wash U and St. Louis, a detailed list of my interviews, a comparison of the cost-of-living in St. Louis versus numerous other cities, and a list of the residency/postdoctoral appointments for the past five years. Brian and Andrew (the two administrators) are incredibly nice and calm your nerves about the dreaded "Committee interview" (more on that later). Even though the Wash U MSTP program is one of the biggest in the country (this year they have 30 MSTP 1st years) the administrators obviously take the time to get to know all of the students.

The first day was nice because it was casual (no suits and no interviews). It started at 1:15 with a general overview with Brian and Andrew and the Director of the program Dr. Daniel Goldberg followed by a facility tour with current MSTPs. That lasted until around 5:00 when all eight of us were whisked off to the Chase Park Plaza hotel. The Wash U MSTP is incredibly well funded and they are sure to flaunt their money throughout the interview. This includes the accommodations. I stayed in a two-bedroom suite where I had a living room, kitchenette, and a private bedroom and bath. They took us all out to dinner that night at a very nice restaurant in St. Louis where there was a "6 bottle limit" on wine. Needless to say, we had a good time.

The next day was filled with interviews. One 20 minute committee interview, one MD interview, four informal meetings with researchers and a wrap-up with a committee member. The committee interview gets a lot of hype, and it definitely has the most impact on your application, but it was actually kind of pleasant. It was intimidating seeing 12 people surrounding a board room table with their undivided attention focused on you, but after you get over that, the questions were very straightforward and fair. They start with "Why MD/PhD?" and then ask you to explain a research project. They interject with their comments throughout and try to probe the depth of your knowledge. But it's only twenty minutes which passes really quickly in such an intense atmosphere.

The MD interview was pretty low-key. I did get asked several ethical and HMO-type questions. The informal meetings with faculty were also very relaxed and simply an exchange of research interests. After these interviews the faculty write brief reports, but they don't bear the same weight as the committee evaluation. Finally there was the wrap-up interview. Mine was with Dr. Goldberg and he pretty much asked if I had any other un-answered questions. After the wrap-up you are taken back to the hotel and go out to dinner in two smaller groups, each "hosted" by two current MSTP students.

They say that they will phone you in two weeks if you are NOT accepted by the MSTP committee. However, if you are accepted by the MSTP committee it takes a few more weeks to hear the "formal" decision because you must be accepted by the MD committee which meets less frequently. Overall, it was a very enjoyable experience and everything was paid for, which is always nice. The trip definitely moved Wash U higher on my list.
 
thanks! that was really informative. 🙂 I'm still crossing my fingers for an interview...
 
WashU wrote me today and "encouraged" me to get my recommenders to send in their letters. What!? I thought VE was supposed to have my committee packet together 2 months ago when my secondary was complete. I'm pissed I used this VE site. I should have just sent in copies.
 
civic57 said:
WashU wrote me today and "encouraged" me to get my recommenders to send in their letters. What!? I thought VE was supposed to have my committee packet together 2 months ago when my secondary was complete. I'm pissed I used this VE site. I should have just sent in copies.
Same problem here. VE sux for MD/PhD committees.
 
Hey guys, I also did VE's... and I think you need to submit VE's to both the MD and MD/PhD programs at WashU. That's what I did at the beginning and I haven't had any problems with it. Also, the faculty when they do their little checklist thing about you may also simply upload another copy of the rec, which WashU also takes. 😉
 
Top