Just met an Ortho with 1.3 Mil in Debt

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

PerioDont

Resident Periodontist
7+ Year Member
Contest Winner!
Joined
Jun 7, 2015
Messages
2,644
Reaction score
2,480
Expensive, private schools for undergrad, Masters, Dental School, and Ortho Residency. this is only student loans at 1.3 million dollars.

This is madness. This person may just be the record as far as I know.

Please do not do this. There is no career that is worth this much debt.

Members don't see this ad.
 
Kenny Rogers Gambling GIF


Good thing there's no way to file for bankruptcy and if I die, the loans will go to my family 👍

Shouts out @StudentLoans
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Expensive, private schools for undergrad, Masters, Dental School, and Ortho Residency. this is only student loans at 1.3 million dollars.

This is madness. This person may just be the record as far as I know.

Please do not do this. There is no career that is worth this much debt.
You got it all wrong. Its about passion they have 🙂
 
To become an orthodontist, one doesn’t need to go to an expensive private (or out-of-state) undergrad college nor have a MS degree. A lot of time and money were unnecessarily wasted. He/she wouldn’t be in this big financial mess, if he/she obtained the information and guidances from other people who had gone through this process before him/her. The problem is a lot of young 18 yo HS kids think they are so smart that they think they don't need to take advice from others. And sadly, a lot of the parents also think their kids are smart and let their kids make all the decisions.
 
To become an orthodontist, one doesn’t need to go to an expensive private (or out-of-state) undergrad college nor have a MS degree. A lot of time and money were unnecessarily wasted. He/she wouldn’t be in this big financial mess, if he/she obtained the information and guidances from other people who had gone through this process before him/her. The problem is a lot of young 18 yo HS kids think they are so smart that they think they don't need to take advice from others. And sadly, a lot of the parents also think their kids are smart and let their kids make all the decisions.

Sometimes students don't have options like many others. Personally, I have to spend +35K in order to get a master's to improve my academic portion. Life is challenging for some especially when you don't have financial support. Some people have to work fulltime and be a student fulltime. This places them in a terrible position where they have to climb an academic mountain twice as big. It's not about being stubborn but it's about how the cookie crumbles. This specialist took his/her chances when they landed and continued to battle through challenges. No one wants to be in 1.3M debt, but that's how life unfolded for this person.
 
Sometimes students don't have options like many others. Personally, I have to spend +35K in order to get a master's to improve my academic portion. Life is challenging for some especially when you don't have financial support. Some people have to work fulltime and be a student fulltime. This places them in a terrible position where they have to climb an academic mountain twice as big. It's not about being stubborn but it's about how the cookie crumbles. This specialist took his/her chances when they landed and continued to battle through challenges. No one wants to be in 1.3M debt, but that's how life unfolded for this person.
The top 2 boys at my son’s high school declined the offers from the cheap local UC (Univ. of CA) schools and went to Duke and Northwestern….they didn’t care about the cost. Sadly, there are many of the top honor kids in HS who think like these 2 guys. They think they are too smart to go to these cheap local state schools. They want to go to schools far away from home so they can get the “college/life experience.” The tuitions at most cheap local state schools are only a fraction of what Duke and other expensive private schools charge their students. And if you are dirt poor like me (when I was a college student), you should be qualified for some government grants and your undergrad education should be almost free. If you live with your parents and eat at home, you shouldn’t have to borrow any loan. If you work full time, then you should make enough to pay for your undergrad education and not have to borrow any loan. I went to one of the UC schools in CA. I worked part time during my college years and I lived with my parents. And my undergrad loan was $0.

My nephew was an average HS student but he’s a very obedient boy. His mom (my wife’s sister) was totally clueless about college and asked my wife to help. He took my wife’s advice and took classes at a community college. He got 4.0 GPA there. Two years later, he transferred to a UC school. His GPA went down a lot (because classes were more difficult at the UC school) but it was still high enough for dental school. He is currently a 2nd year dental student. His dental school is a very expensive private school but at least he didn’t owe any money nor waste any year in undergrad.
 
The top 2 boys at my son’s high school declined the offers from the cheap local UC (Univ. of CA) schools and went to Duke and Northwestern….they didn’t care about the cost. Sadly, there are many of the top honor kids in HS who think like these 2 guys. They think they are too smart to go to these cheap local state schools. They want to go to schools far away from home so they can get the “college/life experience.” The tuitions at most cheap local state schools are only a fraction of what Duke and other expensive private schools charge their students. And if you are dirt poor like me (when I was a college student), you should be qualified for some government grants and your undergrad education should be almost free. If you live with your parents and eat at home, you shouldn’t have to borrow any loan. If you work full time, then you should make enough to pay for your undergrad education and not have to borrow any loan. I went to one of the UC schools in CA. I worked part time during my college years and I lived with my parents. And my undergrad loan was $0.

My nephew was an average HS student but he’s a very obedient boy. His mom (my wife’s sister) was totally clueless about college and asked my wife to help. He took my wife’s advice and took classes at a community college. He got 4.0 GPA there. Two years later, he transferred to a UC school. His GPA went down a lot (because classes were more difficult at the UC school) but it was still high enough for dental school. He is currently a 2nd year dental student. His dental school is a very expensive private school but at least he didn’t owe any money nor waste any year in undergrad.
*this* Being from NC I find it even harder to fathom that people choose Duke over other schools here or even out of state. I mean, my COA for this year is cheaper than the undergrad COA at Duke, that’s ridiculous.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
*this* Being from NC I find it even harder to fathom that people choose Duke over other schools here or even out of state. I mean, my COA for this year is cheaper than the undergrad COA at Duke, that’s ridiculous.
But look how pretty the piece of paper you'll get is. Totes worth it.

DukeHVDiploma_H_original.png



Big Hoss
 
Don't forget that selfie in the Duke hoodie!!
There was a recent story in The Chronicle, Duke's student newspaper, that Duke students have an average of 8.7 more followers on Instagram than UNC students. It would be interesting to see what extent the Duke hoodie selfie has on this.

Big Hoss
 
There was a recent story in The Chronicle, Duke's student newspaper, that Duke students have an average of 8.7 more followers on Instagram than UNC students. It would be interesting to see what extent the Duke hoodie selfie has on this.

Big Hoss
Why am I giving Duke a hard time?! They don't even have a dental school. I need to get back to bashing NYU, USC, Midwestern, ASDOH...

Big Hoss
 
Sometimes students don't have options like many others. Personally, I have to spend +35K in order to get a master's to improve my academic portion. Life is challenging for some especially when you don't have financial support. Some people have to work fulltime and be a student fulltime. This places them in a terrible position where they have to climb an academic mountain twice as big. It's not about being stubborn but it's about how the cookie crumbles. This specialist took his/her chances when they landed and continued to battle through challenges. No one wants to be in 1.3M debt, but that's how life unfolded for this person.
The sad truth people are too blind to see because they had a completely different experience growing up with different types of support as they became a dentist.

regardless, not sure how their debt hit 1.3 million even with all those degrees. It’s a two-sided story sooo
 
  • Like
Reactions: 9ss
regardless, not sure how their debt hit 1.3 million even with all those degrees.
It’s stupidly simple these days. Go to a school like UPenn for dental school and ortho residency and that’s easily pushing $800,000 to $900,000. Tack on a pricey undergrad and masters with some accrued interest sprinkled on top for good measure, and presto!

Big Hoss
 
The top 2 boys at my son’s high school declined the offers from the cheap local UC (Univ. of CA) schools and went to Duke and Northwestern….they didn’t care about the cost. Sadly, there are many of the top honor kids in HS who think like these 2 guys. They think they are too smart to go to these cheap local state schools. They want to go to schools far away from home so they can get the “college/life experience.” The tuitions at most cheap local state schools are only a fraction of what Duke and other expensive private schools charge their students. And if you are dirt poor like me (when I was a college student), you should be qualified for some government grants and your undergrad education should be almost free. If you live with your parents and eat at home, you shouldn’t have to borrow any loan. If you work full time, then you should make enough to pay for your undergrad education and not have to borrow any loan. I went to one of the UC schools in CA. I worked part time during my college years and I lived with my parents. And my undergrad loan was $0.

My nephew was an average HS student but he’s a very obedient boy. His mom (my wife’s sister) was totally clueless about college and asked my wife to help. He took my wife’s advice and took classes at a community college. He got 4.0 GPA there. Two years later, he transferred to a UC school. His GPA went down a lot (because classes were more difficult at the UC school) but it was still high enough for dental school. He is currently a 2nd year dental student. His dental school is a very expensive private school but at least he didn’t owe any money nor waste any year in undergrad.

I blame their parents for spoiling their kids too much. I think they need to let them take out student loans and teach them a lesson..
 
As long as folks keep paying the fare………the tuition will continue to rise.
 
I’d rather be an orthopod making 600+ with 1.3 mil debt than a vet making 40k with 200k debt
 
I’d rather be an orthopod making 600+ with 1.3 mil debt than a vet making 40k with 200k debt
We're not talking orthopedic surgeon, we're talking orthodontist. Big difference. Our ortho is more likely making $220,000/year working at a corporate dental chain. They'll have to pay $85,000/year just to cover their interest to keep their loans from snowballing. Which means, they have to earn $110,000/year just for interest because Uncle Sam always takes his cut first. He's a greedy SOB that way. There is no way this ortho is ever going to touch their loan principal.

Big Hoss
 
To become an orthodontist, one doesn’t need to go to an expensive private (or out-of-state) undergrad college nor have a MS degree. A lot of time and money were unnecessarily wasted. He/she wouldn’t be in this big financial mess, if he/she obtained the information and guidances from other people who had gone through this process before him/her. The problem is a lot of young 18 yo HS kids think they are so smart that they think they don't need to take advice from others. And sadly, a lot of the parents also think their kids are smart and let their kids make all the decisions.
Probably this person wasn't competitive enough to get into cheaper schools. That's usually how it goes.
 
We're not talking orthopedic surgeon, we're talking orthodontist. Big difference. Our ortho is more likely making $220,000/year working at a corporate dental chain. They'll have to pay $85,000/year just to cover their interest to keep their loans from snowballing. Which means, they have to earn $110,000/year just for interest because Uncle Sam always takes his cut first. He's a greedy SOB that way. There is no way this ortho is ever going to touch their loan principal.

Big Hoss
Right, and if they go for a loan forgiveness program (PAYE), they may end up having to pay 2 million or more as a tax bomb. This person is absolutely screwed. They'd be better off faking their own death and fleeing to Mexico rather than taking on 1.3 million in student loans.

Mike Meru, the orthodontist famous for having over 1 million in student loan debt had only $600,000 of debt when he graduated his ortho program. He will end up paying 1.6 million total with his PAYE program.

Imagine how screwed this individual is.
 
Right, and if they go for a loan forgiveness program (PAYE), they may end up having to pay 2 million or more as a tax bomb. This person is absolutely screwed. They'd be better off faking their own death and fleeing to Mexico rather than taking on 1.3 million in student loans.

Mike Meru, the orthodontist famous for having over 1 million in student loan debt had only $600,000 of debt when he graduated his ortho program. He will end up paying 1.6 million total with his PAYE program.

Imagine how screwed this individual is.
I saw the Dave Ramsey video of Justin, another orthodontist who was 1 million in the hole.

One of the comments said:

kid growing up: I want to be a millionaire.

UNO REVERSE CARD 🤣 🤣
 
We're not talking orthopedic surgeon, we're talking orthodontist. Big difference. Our ortho is more likely making $220,000/year working at a corporate dental chain. They'll have to pay $85,000/year just to cover their interest to keep their loans from snowballing. Which means, they have to earn $110,000/year just for interest because Uncle Sam always takes his cut first. He's a greedy SOB that way. There is no way this ortho is ever going to touch their loan principal.

Big Hoss
Ok yes then he is very screwed at 220k a year. 500k in student debt would be feasible with paye and just saving for a fat tax bill in 20 years. 1.3 million is still not a death sentence, but he will be working into his 70s to fund the same retirement of a 62 yo dentist
 
1.3 million is still not a death sentence
Close to it. This person is going to have to pay $115,000/year for TWENTY YEARS to pay this thing off. Can you imagine having to earn $150,000/year just for your student loans?! Never mind all of life's other expenses...

The sad part is way too many predents reading this thread will still be lining up to pay $600,000+ just for dental school. Go to the cheapest school you get into! If you happen to only get into a ridiculously priced school, you had better really understand what you're getting yourself into. There is no way I would pay $500,000+ for a piece of paper that says DDS on it.

Big Hoss
 
Close to it. This person is going to have to pay $115,000/year for TWENTY YEARS to pay this thing off. Can you imagine having to earn $150,000/year just for your student loans?! Never mind all of life's other expenses...

The sad part is way too many predents reading this thread will still be lining up to pay $600,000+ just for dental school. Go to the cheapest school you get into! If you happen to only get into a ridiculously priced school, you had better really understand what you're getting yourself into. There is no way I would pay $500,000+ for a piece of paper that says DDS on it.

Big Hoss
Incorrect. The government is very lenient on repayment. What I mean is they only require 10% of your income per year. Pay 10% a year for 20 years… then the remainder is forgiven (which is taxable income)
 
if you die the loans are discharged
Yes, this is true, but only for government student loans. This does not apply to private student loans. If you are able to get the government alone to give you $300k+ in student loans and not deal with any outside lenders, please call me.

In the case of private loans, the co-signer is often responsible if the primary party dies, and in regard to student loans, that's almost always your parents.

- Alex
 
Incorrect. The government is very lenient on repayment. What I mean is they only require 10% of your income per year. Pay 10% a year for 20 years… then the remainder is forgiven (which is taxable income)
Where to start...

If they only pay 10% of their adjusted income that will be what, $20,000/year. They have to pay at least $85,000/year to cover their interest. Since they aren't even covering their interest, their loan balance will increase $65,000 that first year alone! That $65,000 added the first year will itself have accrued $140,000 in interest when they hit 20 years! By the time the 20 year mark hits they could have a balance well over $5,000,000 I imagine. Their tax bill will be in the 7 figures! I am glad that you think the IRS is lenient. Maybe when this ortho loses their house they can crash at your place, because they sure aren't staying with me.

Big Hoss
 
Last edited:
Where to start...

If they only pay 10% of their adjusted income that will be what, $20,000/year. They have to pay at least $85,000/year to cover their interest. Since they aren't even covering their interest, their loan balance will increase $65,000 that first year alone! That $65,000 added the first year will itself have accrued $140,000 in interest when they hit 20 years! By the time the 20 year mark hits they could have a balance well over $5,000,000 I imagine. Their tax bill will be in the 7 figures! I am glad that you think the IRS is lenient. Maybe when this ortho loses their house they can crash at your place, because they sure aren't staying with me.

Big Hoss
Yeah, when I was doing rough calculations I was figuring they'd likely pay over 2 million in a tax bomb. Plus 20k to 40k a year in minimum payments (10% of income). You looking at close to 3 million dollars that this person will have to pay when you add everything up. Basically their entire life's work will be going into paying student loans. What a sad, pathetic reality.
 
Yes, this is true, but only for government student loans. This does not apply to private student loans. If you are able to get the government alone to give you $300k+ in student loans and not deal with any outside lenders, please call me.
Well, actually the government WILL lend you the money for it. All of it. There is no restrictions on the amount of money you can borrow in student loans. The way it currently is, some genius could come along and charge $1,00,000 per year for an ortho residency, idiots would sign up, and the government would lend the money with no questions asked.

And that's why we're in this situation right now.
 
Well, actually the government WILL lend you the money for it. All of it. There is no restrictions on the amount of money you can borrow in student loans. The way it currently is, some genius could come along and charge $1,00,000 per year for an ortho residency, idiots would sign up, and the government would lend the money with no questions asked.

And that's why we're in this situation right now.
Hey maybe then op’s guy could pay his loans back if he did this. That’s the best shot he’s got
 
I have never understood how so many people get even $40k in debt for undergraduate and are OK with that.
If I didn't qualify for poor people grants and the scholarships I got, I never would have even went to undergraduate.
 
I have never understood how so many people get even $40k in debt for undergraduate and are OK with that.
If I didn't qualify for poor people grants and the scholarships I got, I never would have even went to undergraduate.
Because they're young, idealistic, likely never held a full time or even part time job, are impressionable so blindly follow the advice that they have to go to college, have no concept of money, etc. It's infinitely harder to financially dupe a 35 year old than an 18 year old.
 
Well, actually the government WILL lend you the money for it. All of it. There is no restrictions on the amount of money you can borrow in student loans. The way it currently is, some genius could come along and charge $1,00,000 per year for an ortho residency, idiots would sign up, and the government would lend the money with no questions asked.

And that's why we're in this situation right now.
So are we considering loans from independent financial organizations that have been assigned to me via FAFSA to be government backed? I'm actually serious, like are these considered gov't vs private?

No matter what, I think we may be onto something here with that premium priced ortho residency program 🤔
Now to find a prime location in the Caribbean and fringe applicants 👍
 
Probably this person wasn't competitive enough to get into cheaper schools. That's usually how it goes.
It’s probably due to not having a clear plan as well. One must know that the pathway to become a dentist or a doctor is a very long (at least 7-8 years after HS), difficult (undergrad GPA of at least 3.5 + a good DAT score) and expensive one. Therefore, one needs to have a clear plan and set a goal on how to get there as early as possible… preferably during the junior/senior years in HS. You can’t just go any expensive college….living in a 1 bed apartment all by yourself….partying with friends…wasting many years to explore different career options…..and then finally, you decide that you want to become a dentist. A lot of time and money were wasted. The orthodontist in the OP’s story wouldn’t have wasted so much money if he/she obtained some advice and guidance from people who went through the same process before him.

My nephew didn’t have competitive stats either. He didn’t even take Calculus in HS. He told my wife and me that he wanted to be a dentist like us. He listened to my wife's advice and took classes at a community college…he then transferred to a 4 yr-University 2 years later…..and he got accepted to a dental school without wasting any year. My wife also went to a community college. If my nephew decides to specialize is matched to Georgia Ortho, his total debt will still be way under $1 million.

New-Vegas, I see that you are currently an ortho resident. Congrats! Ortho is a wonderful profession. You will love it.
 
Ok yes then he is very screwed at 220k a year. 500k in student debt would be feasible with paye and just saving for a fat tax bill in 20 years. 1.3 million is still not a death sentence, but he will be working into his 70s to fund the same retirement of a 62 yo dentist
One way to get out of this financial mess is to increase the income…..pay off debt and get out of the PAYE program ASAP. The orthodontist who only makes $220k/year at the corp probably doesn’t work there full time and doesn’t want to travel to work at more offices to make more. Most orthodontists I know travel to work at multiple offices. With the $1300/day pay, which is slightly below the national average, one can easily bring home $350k/year if he/she works 5 days/week…….2-3 times more if he/she owns an office + working P/T for corp office on the side.

Signing up for PAYE and making a tiny payment amount every month should NOT be used as a long-term method to pay off debt. It should only be used short term (4-5 years) to allow the new grads with large debt and low rookie income to save a lot of money fast…..and then they can use that saving amount to set up their own office without having to borrow additional loan. It’s actually a good method if they have the discipline to save money and to continue to live like a student for a few years. When their offices start making 2-3 times more than what they used to earn working as associates, they should be able pay off the debt a lot sooner…..and not have to rely on the loan forgiveness and face the tax bomb.
 
Last edited:
First, and in my opinion, federal loans (unsubsidized & Graduate PLUS loans) need aggregate limits. Without aggregate limits, schools (ie, dental, med, pharm, vet, law) have an unlimited source of revenue and naïve borrowers leverage their financial futures. Having said that, the Income Driven Repayment (IDR) plans are probably the approach to take to manage this debt. I hope the screenshots are somewhat self-explanatory.

1628164331330.png


1628164408285.png
 

Attachments

First, and in my opinion, federal loans (unsubsidized & Graduate PLUS loans) need aggregate limits. Without aggregate limits, schools (ie, dental, med, pharm, vet, law) have an unlimited source of revenue and naïve borrowers leverage their financial futures. Having said that, the Income Driven Repayment (IDR) plans are probably the approach to take to manage this debt. I hope the screenshots are somewhat self-explanatory.

View attachment 341634

View attachment 341635
I would also guess that income based repayment is likely the only way to go for this person
 
First, and in my opinion, federal loans (unsubsidized & Graduate PLUS loans) need aggregate limits. Without aggregate limits, schools (ie, dental, med, pharm, vet, law) have an unlimited source of revenue and naïve borrowers leverage their financial futures. Having said that, the Income Driven Repayment (IDR) plans are probably the approach to take to manage this debt. I hope the screenshots are somewhat self-explanatory.

View attachment 341634

View attachment 341635
You were definitely generous with the amount of money they would be making here toward the 20 year mark of their career. To make that kind of money, you likely need to be a practice owner, and I'm not sure if you could get a loan for that if you are 2 million dollars in debt. That's why my estimate of what this person would pay back is so much higher.
 
Last edited:
At year 2025, I assume an annual increase of 1.5%, which isn't even keeping up with inflation. If I discount their 2040 income of $412,420 at an inflation rate = 2%, their current dollar income is $277,547. Inflation can ruin many a plan.
 
Last edited:
Top