Kirby - Game Thread

[Boquise]

---

Members don't see this ad.

The vote built with very little substantiation. In my opinion it's highly likely a wolf jumped on the Pippy vote to look like they were doing something.

How would you rank the votes from towniest to scummiest, between Zenge, Genny and Dr. Wilgy?

 

[Boquise]

I've only gotten to skim because I'm imminently about to drive home, but I feel like pippy always gets sussed on D1 like this regardless of aff

I will have to look at old games but that's my initial feeling

If Pippy is a wolf this could be w/w tbh

 

[Boquise]

Speaking of Swedish indie music and unrelated to the game, my brother ran a live music thing at Folkparken for awhile in Stockholm. He said the live music scene isn’t quite the same as it is in the US?

i have no idea tbh sorry man
i have never seen live music in the us tbh

 

[DrWilgy]

Went through Moth's ISO rq just to see if there's really nothing of notation or if I just missed data, and it really feels empty.

0% threatened by JJJ rn

Something of note in the above quote, and likely I'm making a mountain of a molehill, but what may have seemed like a silly NAI post to Moth, having the thought of 'threat' in it makes me think it's from a wolf alignment.

Townies don't feel threatened.

Wolves do.

There's not much of note there. PSVs review on Moth backpedaling holds up. Would vote. I'd like to see what Moth thinks of their wagon.

 

[PippyPony]

I'm pretty sure Genny was one of the players that suggested a potential perspective slip from Pippy prior to this.

See #163

I know you don't know me, but I am really not that clumsy of a wolf.

 

[Boquise]

She's tricksy that one. Always using those shouty caps to get on people's good side.

How do you feel about her so far?

 

[DrWilgy]

I know you don't know me, but I am really not that clumsy of a wolf.

Alrighty then, so what's your PoE lookin like as it stands Pippy? How do you read me, do you think I'm genuine in thought re you?

 

[WildZoo]

I'm pretty sure Genny was one of the players that suggested a potential perspective slip from Pippy prior to this.

See #163

Ah I missed that post, happens on mobile

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Some concerns about moth (within spoiler):

Spoiler

Also hi whoever is trying to wolf read me.

I just woke up from second sleep like 45-ish mins ago and had the rest of my coffee from first wake up.

Are we coffee telling on SDN? Heh

0% threatened by JJJ rn

I think this is a read? I'm not sure, but it's the first distinctly read-adjacent comment from moth. I don't know why I would be 0% threatening or what that really means. I'm also not sure I believe it? That's not say moth lied and I am threatening, but I am not sure it's a genuine perspective.

Samac like, always dies d1 I think? Or was that SAR?

Anyhow, I l might be wolf leaning but I’m not gonna yeet on d1z

I’m waiting to see what Zenge does d2 to wolf lean either of them. Zenge is a quiet wolf usually.

I never said I wasn’t a dingus lol. But yea, not testing Samac or Zenge anytime soon

They don’t but I wouldn’t put it past the gods

Me too

PSV already beefed with this. While I wouldn't call it a "slip" as PSV did, I do think it's displays a strange perspective. To "wolf lean" samac and also hold off for Day 1 is perfectly valid. However, the posts that follow seem to suggest there isn't a wolf lean, so I don't know what the first post was meant to be.

The "me too" in response to PSV's pressure isn't great either. Slip or not, that doesn't strike me as someone putting out honest posts.

vote moth

 

[DrWilgy]

lv1 solve:
Moth, Mighty, Dina

 

[Boquise]

I have some personal reasons why I think Zenge's vote on me is just wrong vs wolfy. On top of that, as I've already stated, I have him at a slight village lean.

my first gut reaction is to town read this, but it might be because i have a bias - i have thought Pippy to be sorta townie
but then i remembered that some wolves like to be reasonable in the thread and react like reasonable people in the face of pressure.

so eh
i am mixed

 

[Boquise]

I don't like this post. I'm pretty against posts that seem villagey but don't actually contribute much to game solving.

At this point in threadstate, there were only 9 players contributing (including JJJ). This post basically says "I'll give everyone a village lean except Pippy and quiet players." However, it's dressed up in a way that seems fancier and more investigative than it truly is.

I find it hard to believe that wolves were all staying silent, and that alone tells me that JJJ's list has at least 1 wolf

i am glad that my adopted sidekick is town and that avatar reads are real
peace and the human rights have been protected once more tbh

 

[Boquise]

I wouldn’t kill Pippy at this point, and it’s too tempting not to make a tie, so…

Vote motheatenlysis

do you have any read of moth?

 

[Boquise]

w

*She, thanks 🤓

wait
are you moonie
i thought you were monstr
i am a clown and i am resigning tbh

 

[moonstermash]

do you have any read of moth?

Not really.

 

[Boquise]

I've caught up again.

I'm probably incorrect on several, so I'd not say this as a town vs scum list, more so would toss and wouldn't toss overboard.

Would toss: Nate, Boq, Genny, Pippy, Mayo, Moth

Someone explain why this is incorrect and why

why toss me, based on the post written before this was posted?

 

[WildZoo]

if I spoiler it ya jerks won’t read it soooo

Damn, she's onto me

 

[DrWilgy]

why toss me, based on the post written before this was posted?

Good point.

Great, not my entire PoE is ruined.

 

[Boquise]

Could be copypasta with my name substituted for Voxx. 🖖

im glad i can contribute to the memedom tbh

Boq town reads my town reads. I can deal with that.

how generous tbh!

Sell me on Dr. Wily tbh

 

[DrWilgy]

*Now my...


If I just keep correcting typos I won't need to be afraid of post count minimums.

 

[Zenge142]

I'm pretty sure Genny was one of the players that suggested a potential perspective slip from Pippy prior to this.

See #163

you know you can link the post numbers right? #163

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Yeet Tally
Zenge () -
Pippy (2) - Zenge 64, Wilgy 42
mayo (1) - samac 43
samac (1) - dubz 51
moth (4) - Pippy 38, PSV 30, moon 20, JJJ 68

8/15
yeet close in ~27 hours

 

[Boquise]

actually i might think dr wilgy is town

so far i have
mighty, my protégé, my favourite character of this show
zenge
genny
potentialshervet
moonster - maybe
dr wilgy - maybe
as town

i am mixed with Pippy. There are posts I consider town, there are posts I consider wolf

gonna sleep now tbh

 

[Boquise]

i guess my problem with pippy is that some posts sound like wolf salt, annoyed for being caught early, but a lot of that can also be read as vindicative town pushing back against the establishment

so idk

Yeet WildZoo tbh

 

[moonstermash]

w

wait
are you moonie
i thought you were monstr
i am a clown and i am resigning tbh

IDK that I've ever had anybody call me moonie before. 🤔 There's a chance you remember me from Anni '22, or maybe you specced S8SCI or Nate's and my hydra game, but otherwise I don't think we've played together.

 

[Zenge142]

IDK that I've ever had anybody call me moonie before

Moonie pls

 

[PippyPony]

you know you can link the post numbers right? #163

My little mobile-broken thumbs thank you for this

 

[WildZoo]

Why you no read me? You’re the only person I feel comfortable with reading me D1.

I don’t like this. Did you not read me early last game? Am I crazy?

She does

You picked it up my first post

Okay so I'm not nuts, I thought I remembered her reading you village pretty early last game.

Hmm.

Dubz feels alright.

👀

I've caught up again.

I'm probably incorrect on several, so I'd not say this as a town vs scum list, more so would toss and wouldn't toss overboard.

Would toss: Nate, Boq, Genny, Pippy, Mayo, Moth

Someone explain why this is incorrect and why

Was gonna comment on the lowposters thing but...that's been done. So just noting that was also my initial reaction.

So lowposters? Sounds like a winning strategy that never backfires!

Oho, same wavelength as genny, that seems promising

there is a lot of dancing around JJJ's alignment during the first few pages, and one player wondering whether JJJ and someone else (sorry, havent got used to the usernames yet and i am about to sleep) were doing w/w theatre. This was like on page 2 and I couldnt really follow that thought process due to the posts at hand.

It all feels rather mandatory, dancing around a slot that has apparently burned you recently and I don't really town read it. Feels like a topic that is said just to have it out of your way and not have to read JJJ right now. The approach is almost correct. Let ol' Boq help you with that. The pro strat isnt that you make legit reads on JJJ. No, you don't solve him and if he is alive, regardless of yeet results, at D4 you yeet him into the sun no matter what fancy, funny and charming words he says. Thats how you do it tbh

You're welcome tbh

Where were you to propose this strategy last game, smh

 

[WildZoo]

i guess my problem with pippy is that some posts sound like wolf salt, annoyed for being caught early, but a lot of that can also be read as vindicative town pushing back against the establishment

so idk

Yeet WildZoo tbh

For why?

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Three of four mafia in StardeWW 2 were below the median in post rate.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Spoiler: Quotes

What makes you village read pippy? Any reason you’re wolf reading genny other than the Pippy vote?

I don't village read Pippy per se. I just don't think she's screaming wolf. By the same token, genny is neutral. But gth if I had to point at one person on the Pippy wagon and say this is a wolf, that person is genny.

Have you played with pip? I forgot when she quit

I remember playing a speed game with her like a year ago?

Why you no read me? You’re the only person I feel comfortable with reading me D1.

I'm just not sure on you right now.

So I get what you’re getting at here, feels too easy. But ya know what felt too easy last game? Visc.

This is true, but I don't think it's fair to compare the Pippy situation to Vis.

They played Literary. That would be the only game.

Pippy played Literary?? Lol no memory of this.

Ok well, I feel the urge to take back my village read on you as everything is currently developing

...weird

 

[Zenge142]

Pippy played Literary?? Lol no memory of this.

Well since that’s the only game you have played with her, what game did you think you were remembering?

 

[WildZoo]

unyeet samac yeet Pippy

This post feels funky

Ok well, I feel the urge to take back my village read on you as everything is currently developing

And so far I can't find the games she's referring to when Zenge was wrong on her or pushed her while he was wolfing

 

[potentialsheltervet]

PSV feels funny but that’s par for the course for me on day 1 so that probably means she’s village.

Townie post coming from you

Dubz feels alright.

Idk about this. Does she?

And there were a couple other PSV posts I didn’t like

Awww, truly fitting in here

Do any of these players you say shuttling Samac into their Village specifically come across as TMI?

Not really. It's just surprising to me given there was a big influx of samac paranoia after she broke her no bussing meta a couple games ago. That is suddenly just poof gone and I'm surprised.

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Went through Moth's ISO rq just to see if there's really nothing of notation or if I just missed data, and it really feels empty.

Something of note in the above quote, and likely I'm making a mountain of a molehill, but what may have seemed like a silly NAI post to Moth, having the thought of 'threat' in it makes me think it's from a wolf alignment.

Townies don't feel threatened.

Wolves do.

There's not much of note there. PSVs review on Moth backpedaling holds up. Would vote. I'd like to see what Moth thinks of their wagon.

I had missed this before, so thanks for looking into it Wilgy. I had similar doubts about that post. I also appreciate that you said it before I did.

 

[WildZoo]

Madagascar - Pippy wolf, Zenge village. He pushed her correctly and died.

OWWlympics - Pippy wolf, Zenge village. Wasn't on her vote but was suspicious of her, talked about her d1 vote being sus

Worst idea - not super helpful because multiball lol Mafia!Zenge pushed Goo!Pippy

Goats - SK!Pippy, Village!Zenge. Zenge was on her vote d1



Am I missing any games you played together @Zenge142 @PippyPony ?


This isn't 100% about Zenge's read rate on Pippy, though it is good. It's more than it feels like Pippy misrepresented it when I asked about it, unless I'm missing games.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

How would you rank the votes from towniest to scummiest, between Zenge, Genny and Dr. Wilgy?

Zenge > Wiggles > Genny.

Well since that’s the only game you have played with her, what game did you think you were remembering?

Whaddya mean? I mentioned the speedgame but that doesn't especially count.

 

[potentialsheltervet]

@WildZoo You're very quiet on the mothy situation, aren't you? You shifted attention back toward Pippy based on one post to tie things back up when I gave mothy some attention, didn't ya?
Protecting a wolflet?

 

[WildZoo]

@WildZoo You're very quiet on the mothy situation, aren't you? You shifted attention back toward Pippy based on one post to tie things back up when I gave mothy some attention, didn't ya?
Protecting a wolflet?

Eh it just didn't inspire me. I read the things. They just seemed like...mothy things. She's got 4 votes already. It's boring.

And my Pippy vote is based on two posts and multigame background research, thank you very much.

 

[WildZoo]

Spoiler

And on sheeping Zenge

 

[potentialsheltervet]

Eh it just didn't inspire me. I read the things. They just seemed like...mothy things. She's got 4 votes already. It's boring.

And my Pippy vote is based on two posts and multigame background research, thank you very much.

Not convinced.

 

[WildZoo]

Not convinced.
View attachment 369094

Par for the course lol

 

[genny]

Three of four mafia in StardeWW 2 were below the median in post rate.

yeah but those 3 weren't highposters as villagers in other games. stardeww 1 had a wolf!dubz, and she kept up her highposter status. i'm not saying that lowposters shouldn't be considered for the chop, just that i think it's mostly NAI on this site.

 

[DrWilgy]

I had missed this before, so thanks for looking into it Wilgy. I had similar doubts about that post. I also appreciate that you said it before I did.

Oh no, I'm pocketed

 

[genny]

Protecting a wolflet?

i'm not seeing it.

 

[motheatenlysis]

Damn I go out for a few hours and come back and I'm dying. It's D1 on a holiday week/weekend (holy Saturday, Easter, and Passover) ((and also the first day above 40 degrees in MN for MONTHS)), so yeah, I went out and got some sun.

Is that all you're going to say? I have to admit, you feel like a wolf that slipped and is panicking trying to take it back.

No, but I'm also not going to take my phone or computer with me to reply when I'm out with friends when there's like 28 hours left in D1.

Yeet mothy

I wouldn’t kill Pippy at this point, and it’s too tempting not to make a tie, so…

Vote motheatenlysis

You're both yeeting village and not a wolf.

PSV's exchange with moth on the previous page looks quite town for PSV. I don't know that moth "slipped" per PSV's assessment, but the accusation looks authentic anyway. And perhaps moth was a bit sheepish in replying to it.

Not a slip. It's more a skill issue at WW/mafia in general. This is my 4th game and I'm honestly never good, and already regret playing.

Also @samac I didn't mean testing, I meant yeeting but autocorrect on my phone got me.

 

[motheatenlysis]

Eh it just didn't inspire me. I read the things. They just seemed like...mothy things. She's got 4 votes already. It's boring.

Oh we are sooooo going to call my skill issue mothy things from now on

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I’ll consider what you have to say, mothy. By all means, keep doing your thing.

And regardless of your affiliation, I’m glad you’re playing the game.

 

[motheatenlysis]

Went through Moth's ISO rq just to see if there's really nothing of notation or if I just missed data, and it really feels empty.

Something of note in the above quote, and likely I'm making a mountain of a molehill, but what may have seemed like a silly NAI post to Moth, having the thought of 'threat' in it makes me think it's from a wolf alignment.

Townies don't feel threatened.

Wolves do.

There's not much of note there. PSVs review on Moth backpedaling holds up. Would vote. I'd like to see what Moth thinks of their wagon.

It was an innocent mothy thing in that I find him amusing and found his posts here to be as such and was in agreement with PSV re: the video of him juggling. And now I know that every word you use in this game is looked at with a fine tooth comb.
Also, I'm not wolf aligned with JJJ (that would require me to be a wolf) so...
Yeet JJJ

 

[genny]

It was an innocent mothy thing in that I find him amusing and found his posts here to be as such and was in agreement with PSV re: the video of him juggling. And now I know that every word you use in this game is looked at with a fine tooth comb.
Also, I'm not wolf aligned with JJJ (that would require me to be a wolf) so...
Yeet JJJ

why that yeet?