- Joined
- Oct 26, 2008
- Messages
- 7,495
- Reaction score
- 4,183
I've had way too many discussions about this and way too many (vast majority) of pre meds (even med students/residents often have no clue) have no idea what they are talking about (in real life and here). I decided to start a thread to help you pre meds understand the money in medicine a bit better.
To keep it short, here are the take away points for MDs (I dont know DO's situation)
1) Doctors make good annual salary. But it is only ONE number. To determine financial health, or to compare financial health, you need a lot more than 1 number. A college student making 250k at age 22, is not the same as a doctor making 250k at age 33. The difference is MUCH MUCH larger than you think.
2) The cost to become a doctor is massive. More than you think. Because theres lost wages, and compounding on interests
3) It takes a lot to become a doctor, even if you might not agree. To become an attending, you wouldve already gone thru MANY selection processes. Many of you were top students in HS to get into good college, then excel in college, then do well on MCAT, get into MD, be smart/diligent enough to graduate and pass exams, get into residency/specialty of choice, +/- get into fellowship, then FINALLY find a job. Too many of you see a starting salary of 250k, then compare it to starting salaries in other fields. It's NOT comparable. At every step of the way, people get weeded out. Becoming an attending is perhaps comparable to someone getting promoted multiple times at another job so comparing our starting salary to an entry level salary is ******ed.
4) if you can make it all the way thru residency/fellowship, and become an attending making 250k. You are probably smart enough to do OK in other fields too. You probably wont be that person getting fired from a company cause you suck.
5) Your salary as a doctor will depend heavily on insurance reimbursement rates, which for sure wont be making large increases out of no where, but can have large decreases out of no where. Therefore, you wont be getting significant raises even after years of practice unless you increase your volume/hours worked. This differs from most other fields in that they reward you for your experiences which result in significant raises.
6) Where you want to live matters. Living in NYC will be a lower salary than middle of no where. For most other high paying fields, large city wages are higher to adjust for cost of living. Not true for medicine.
Not knowing this stuff will leave you very disappointed in the future if you care about $$$.
Also, every field is changing quickly. Medicine is not static. Asking your parents or some old attending about how much they liked the finances of medicine is not comparable to the current situation (yes the current may not apply to the future as well but it's more likely than the past). Those physicians lived in an era of very different purchasing power. Their salary went a long way. Plus no 250k debt dragging them down.
My advice to pre meds who care about $$. Consider it from all angles, not just a annual #, cause that # only tells a very small part of the story.
To keep it short, here are the take away points for MDs (I dont know DO's situation)
1) Doctors make good annual salary. But it is only ONE number. To determine financial health, or to compare financial health, you need a lot more than 1 number. A college student making 250k at age 22, is not the same as a doctor making 250k at age 33. The difference is MUCH MUCH larger than you think.
2) The cost to become a doctor is massive. More than you think. Because theres lost wages, and compounding on interests
3) It takes a lot to become a doctor, even if you might not agree. To become an attending, you wouldve already gone thru MANY selection processes. Many of you were top students in HS to get into good college, then excel in college, then do well on MCAT, get into MD, be smart/diligent enough to graduate and pass exams, get into residency/specialty of choice, +/- get into fellowship, then FINALLY find a job. Too many of you see a starting salary of 250k, then compare it to starting salaries in other fields. It's NOT comparable. At every step of the way, people get weeded out. Becoming an attending is perhaps comparable to someone getting promoted multiple times at another job so comparing our starting salary to an entry level salary is ******ed.
4) if you can make it all the way thru residency/fellowship, and become an attending making 250k. You are probably smart enough to do OK in other fields too. You probably wont be that person getting fired from a company cause you suck.
5) Your salary as a doctor will depend heavily on insurance reimbursement rates, which for sure wont be making large increases out of no where, but can have large decreases out of no where. Therefore, you wont be getting significant raises even after years of practice unless you increase your volume/hours worked. This differs from most other fields in that they reward you for your experiences which result in significant raises.
6) Where you want to live matters. Living in NYC will be a lower salary than middle of no where. For most other high paying fields, large city wages are higher to adjust for cost of living. Not true for medicine.
Not knowing this stuff will leave you very disappointed in the future if you care about $$$.
Also, every field is changing quickly. Medicine is not static. Asking your parents or some old attending about how much they liked the finances of medicine is not comparable to the current situation (yes the current may not apply to the future as well but it's more likely than the past). Those physicians lived in an era of very different purchasing power. Their salary went a long way. Plus no 250k debt dragging them down.
My advice to pre meds who care about $$. Consider it from all angles, not just a annual #, cause that # only tells a very small part of the story.
Last edited: