Lurking Beloww: Sea Monsters Sign Ups and Game Thread

[jaboo]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I also play from my phone 98% of the time. I'm not sure why people complain about it so much.

Don't like the kids book version of rainbow fish claim.

Not a claim, it’s what I am.

W/e guys, looks like we’re back to lynch Jboo ASAP

 

[PippyPony]

Did I miss close or are we extended? What's the tally at?

This jumped out at me:

What does that mean exactly? Because didn't genny say something similar (that genny was handing out gifts?)?

jboo gives out GIFS.

At least, she proved that to me -- used a phrase and then I got a gif in my mod PM with the same phrase.

 

[PippyPony]

W/e guys, looks like we’re back to lynch Jboo ASAP

Oh psssh. You lived for a decent amount of time in this game.

 

[jaboo]

Oh psssh. You lived for a decent amount of time in this game.

It’s D3

 

[katashark]

LYNCH CLOSED, RESULTS PENDING

 

[jaboo]

In case this counts for anything

Unlynch Snowy
Lynch SAR

Eta: guess not

 

[PippyPony]

It’s D3

...isn't it D4? Or am I hallucinating?

 

[KCgophervet]

jboo gives out GIFS.

At least, she proved that to me -- used a phrase and then I got a gif in my mod PM with the same phrase.

Ooooh right. I remember the previous claim now. Was very confused.

 

[PippyPony]

In case this counts for anything

Unlynch Snowy
Lynch SAR

Eta: guess not

Was this a real vote? Or a self prez vote?

 

[PippyPony]

And you never gave a target list. I was N2, who was N1

Or whatever nights, since I have lost track of time lol

 

[katashark]

FINAL TALLY! Check your votes

DVMD (1) - SOV,
SAR (4) - AM, Stagg, skimble, jboo
Snowy (1) - jboo
pippy (1) - kcough
kcough (1) -
jboo (5) - snowy, dolphin, SAR, BJ, pippy
dolphin ()

13/14 passengers accounted for

****I am allowing @johnnaboo's vote because lynch did not close on time.******

 

[jaboo]

And you never gave a target list. I was N2, who was N1

Or whatever nights lol

I TOLD YOU I FORGOT BC MY LIFE IS BUSY NOW

 

[PippyPony]

I TOLD YOU I FORGOT BC MY LIFE IS BUSY NOW

Yeah I just went back to PM and saw that. I had forgotten, I think I was Pipsy when I read it 😳

 

[PippyPony]

FINAL TALLY! Check your votes

DVMD (1) - SOV,
SAR (4) - AM, Stagg, skimble, jboo
Snowy (1) - jboo
pippy (1) - kcough
kcough (1) -
jboo (5) - snowy, dolphin, SAR, pippy, BJ
dolphin ()

13/14 passengers accounted for

****I am allowing @johnnaboo's vote because lynch did not close on time.******

Correct, except the order is swapped for me & bryndi on jboo. Not sure if that matters a whole lot, but in case people look at that sort of thing.

 

[katashark]

Correct, except the order is swapped for me & bryndi on jboo. Not sure if that matters a whole lot, but in case people look at that sort of thing.

fixed. thanks!

 

[PippyPony]

fixed. thanks!

(except you still have a phantom vote on KC haha)

 

[KCgophervet]

(and jboo is voting for both Snowy and SAR)

 

[PippyPony]

And if we're as close to Lylo as you keep implying we are (which I'm not conivnced of, cuz Maths), I'd rather play the odds.

As an aside... Are you not concerned that we haven't lynched a wolf yet?

Probably 3 wolves if they have a perpetual double kill, so:

If jboo is village... 13 players 10:3
Double kill overnight... 11 players 8:3
Lynch a villager... 10 players 7:3
Double kill overnight... 8 players 5:3

And it's obviously way worse if god forbid there are 4 original wolves or a conversion. How is that not concerning?

 

[katashark]

Attention, all passengers!
Please avoid Deck 3. The engine is currently overheating.
If your rooms are on that deck, your belongings will be moved shortly. ​

Captain's Log:
28/8/18– Today, passengers were still unable to surmise the identity of the creature or creatures who have been terrorizing the oceans as of late. Our journey continues. Unfortunately, although the culprit has not been found, another victim has... The engine room flooded today. Luckily, Capt. KD and I were able to find the leak and fix it. One of the crewmembers set up a fan to get the Main Auxillary Room dried out. We removed all passengers from the deck and their belongings.

After drying the room out for a couple of hours, Capt. KD, the crew and I went to check on the engines. What we found is not suitable for the eyes of children. In every grid space of the fan was a small chunk until the fan was so fouled, that it stopped working. We turned the fan off, but the parts were so mangled that it was impossible to identify the parts. All that remained was one shiny scale.

Conditions
Current - straight SW, 3 knots
Wind --- diving
Swell - 5.4ft

Supplies
Air - 70%
Fuel - 50%
Rations - 70%

Signed,

Dead is @johnnaboo, Rainbow Fish, The Rainbow Fish had beautiful, shiny scales that she was always willing to give away to friends.

ADJUST PMs ACCORDINGLY. Third watch begins at 0900 hours EDT.

Greenhorns
1. @SARdoghandler
2. @Animal Midwife
3. @SnowshoeDog143
4. @DVMDream
6. @allieh8607
7. @bryndiana.jones
8. @Stagg737
9. @kcoughli
10. @Skimble
13. @dolphin106258
14. @PippyPony
18. @StartingoverVet
19. @Crayola227

In a Watery Grave
12. capri1722 - Giant squid
17. Melchizedek - Candiru (1 shot vigilante)
5. CoffeeQuestionMark - Scylla and Charybdis (village blocker)
16. WildZoo - Cthulhu
11. genny - Ahuitzotl (item maker)
15. johnnaboo - Rainbow Fish (send a message)

 

[Animal Midwife]

@PippyPony Can I ask why you didn't move to DVMD when I mentioned the counterwagon? And which posts of SAR's are village?

 

[PippyPony]

@PippyPony Can I ask why you didn't move to DVMD when I mentioned the counterwagon? And which posts of SAR's are village?

Because I thought we had less than 20 minutes left and she only had 1 vote?

I'm not going to iso and pull a bunch of posts. I play on my phone these days; when I quote stuff it's because I'm re-reading of my own volition, not because I'm digging back through the thread at someone else's request.

 

[PippyPony]

You can't have seriously wanted me to launch a full counter wagon ****show waffle with less than 30 min before lynch close. We did that yesterday. It was no bueno.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Because I thought we had less than 20 minutes left and she only had 1 vote?

I'm not going to iso and pull a bunch of posts. I play on my phone these days; when I quote stuff it's because I'm re-reading of my own volition, not because I'm digging back through the thread at someone else's request.

She did have one vote, but the leaders only had three. I didn't mean you had to quote them. Just wanted to know a brief summary, if you remembered.

 

[Animal Midwife]

You can't have seriously wanted me to launch a full counter wagon ****show waffle with less than 30 min before lynch close. We did that yesterday. It was no bueno.

Why not? I don't believe in correlation = causation. Each result has the potential to be different.

 

[PippyPony]

She did have one vote, but the leaders only had three. I didn't mean you had to quote them. Just wanted to know a brief summary, if you remembered.

So would you have voted for DVMD? To bring it up to a 3 way tie? Yeah no thanks.

Edit: maths, you would have removed your vote. It's only D1 of school and I'm already too tired to think.

It was mostly her posts today; I felt like she was giving a balanced take on things that is more reflective of how I think of her as a villager.

 

[Animal Midwife]

So would you have voted for DVMD? To bring it up to a 3 way tie? Yeah no thanks.

It was mostly her posts today; I felt like she was giving a balanced take on things that is more reflective of how I think of her as a villager.

Who's she in this context?

 

[dolphin106258]

Okay so I’m sucking so far, I’m just gonna go with a cleanish slate for people (maybe not Pippy) and start from there. Why do people think SAR is sketch? I guess specifically @Animal Midwife since Stagg already gave more of a lengthy explanation. If you’ve already explained and I missed it just tell me what day or night that was and I’ll go back and find it myself, I don’t like making people dig for quotes.
@Skimble was it just feels for you? In regards to SAR.

Other than that I am going to go to bed soon and hopefully reread a good chunk of the thread with a fresh mind.

 

[PippyPony]

Why not? I don't believe in correlation = causation. Each result has the potential to be different.

That's nice

 

[PippyPony]

Who's she in this context?

SAR

It was the 2nd part of your 2 part question

 

[Animal Midwife]

SAR

It was the 2nd part of your 2 part question

Okay. Do you feel better about DVMD too?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Okay so I’m sucking so far, I’m just gonna go with a cleanish slate for people (maybe not Pippy) and start from there. Why do people think SAR is sketch? I guess specifically @Animal Midwife since Stagg already gave more of a lengthy explanation. If you’ve already explained and I missed it just tell me what day or night that was and I’ll go back and find it myself, I don’t like making people dig for quotes.
@Skimble was it just feels for you? In regards to SAR.

Other than that I am going to go to bed soon and hopefully reread a good chunk of the thread with a fresh mind.

She seems to just be letting me vote for her without resistance and I don't understand why.

 

[PippyPony]

Okay. Do you feel better about DVMD too?

No? Maybe? idfk.

I haven't sucked this bad in a long time, I'm not sure I know how to village anymore

 

[Animal Midwife]

No? Maybe? idfk.

I haven't sucked this bad in a long time, I'm not sure I know how to village anymore

RIP

 

[PippyPony]

I had another wacko theory today, but I kept it under wraps because I don't want to out another village PR. It's marginally better than the genny one, I think.

I did tell dolphin (the summary of I was thinking about, not the potential people involved), so you can ask her for details if I get killed.

Which I would be fine with at this time, btw. Hint hint woof woofs.

 

[PippyPony]

Hint: it's related to role name and known actions. I was hoping more people would bite on that. May be worth collectively pressuring people in PMs.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Hint: it's related to role name and known actions. I was hoping more people would bite on that. May be worth collectively pressuring people in PMs.

Bite on what? Your dolphin theory? Because I wasn't aware of it until a few minutes ago.

 

[PippyPony]

Bite on what? Your dolphin theory? Because I wasn't aware of it until a few minutes ago.

...I don't have a dolphin theory, her role name does not fit. I told her some stuff I was mulling over. So you can ask her what I told her if I die, if anyone cares to do so.

I was talking about asking about the role names earlier; I was hoping to try to narrow something down.

 

[PippyPony]

I'll probably tell SOV some undisclosed amount of it so there can be some fact checking later on if needed.

 

[PippyPony]

As an aside, at a certain point it is kind of a bummer if people won't share information on the thread. I can understand wanting to keep that stuff under wraps, but I feel like it can go way too far these days and detract from both wolf hunting and entertainment value.

We haven't found any wolves, maybe now is a good time for people to start coughing up what they know.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 1 Election Tally
allie (2) - allie, DVMD
Pippy (5) - Pippy, Skim, AM, SAR, capri
AM () - AM
genny (6) - genny, bryndi, Coffee?, Stagg, jboo, dolphin
Mel (2) - Mel, WZ

15/18
Missing: kc, SOV, Snowy

Day 2 Lynch Tally
SAR (4) - AM, genny, Skim, Pippy, genny, DVMD
kc (1) - Coffee?, Pippy
DVMD () - Pippy
bj (1) - Skim, WZ
Coffee? (5) - jboo, SOV, bj, Stagg, Snowy, SAR
Pippy () - kc
genny (1) - SAR, allie
jboo (2) - dolphin, Pippy
dolphin (1) - kc
Stagg () - genny
WZ (1) - bj

16/16

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Pippy (1) - DVMD, kc
Stagg () - jboo, genny
bj () - Pippy
Snowy () - AM
jboo (3) - Pippy, dolphin, SAR, bj, kc, allie, genny
dolphin (2) - Snowy, AM
allie () - Stagg
SAR (1) - Skim
genny (5) - Pippy, jboo, DVMD, SAR, Stagg

12/14
Missing: allie, SOV

Day 4 Lynch Tally
DVMD (1) - Pippy, SOV
SAR (4) - AM, Stagg, Skim, jboo
Snowy () - jboo
Pippy (1) - kc
kc () - Pippy
jboo (5) - Snowy, dolphin, SAR, bryndi, Pippy
dolphin () - SAR

11/14
Missing: Cray, allie, DVMD

 

[PippyPony]

People also should be sharing PM insights imo because this is a game where everyone can communicate. I think y'all need to start dishing, or we keep losing.

 

[PippyPony]

Day 1 Election Tally
allie (2) - allie, DVMD
Pippy (5) - Pippy, Skim, AM, SAR, capri
AM () - AM
genny (6) - genny, bryndi, Coffee?, Stagg, jboo, dolphin
Mel (2) - Mel, WZ

15/18
Missing: kc, SOV, Snowy

Day 2 Lynch Tally
SAR (4) - AM, genny, Skim, Pippy, genny, DVMD
kc (1) - Coffee?, Pippy
DVMD () - Pippy
bj (1) - Skim, WZ
Coffee? (5) - jboo, SOV, bj, Stagg, Snowy, SAR
Pippy () - kc
genny (1) - SAR, allie
jboo (2) - dolphin, Pippy
dolphin (1) - kc
Stagg () - genny
WZ (1) - bj

16/16

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Pippy (1) - DVMD, kc
Stagg () - jboo, genny
bj () - Pippy
Snowy () - AM
jboo (3) - Pippy, dolphin, SAR, bj, kc, allie, genny
dolphin (2) - Snowy, AM
allie () - Stagg
SAR (1) - Skim
genny (5) - Pippy, jboo, DVMD, SAR, Stagg

12/14
Missing: allie, SOV

Day 4 Lynch Tally
DVMD (1) - Pippy, SOV
SAR (4) - AM, Stagg, Skim, jboo
Snowy () - jboo
Pippy (1) - kc
kc () - Pippy
jboo (5) - Snowy, dolphin, SAR, bryndi, Pippy
dolphin () - SAR

11/14
Missing: Cray, allie, DVMD

Ok but what is your interpretation of this? There are zero wolves on this tally. It is essentially a whole lot of nothing.

 

[Animal Midwife]

...I don't have a dolphin theory, her role name does not fit. I told her some stuff I was mulling over. So you can ask her what I told her if I die, if anyone cares to do so.

I was talking about asking about the role names earlier; I was hoping to try to narrow something down.

Well, I wasn't saying people couldn't do that if they wanted, just that I didn't feel comfortable doing it myself.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Ok but what is your interpretation of this? There are zero wolves on this tally. It is essentially a whole lot of nothing.

The number of people not voting increases by the day. Everyone's out to get me.

 

[PippyPony]

Well, I wasn't saying people couldn't do that if they wanted, just that I didn't feel comfortable doing it myself.

Yeah, but that gives literally everyone else an excuse to pull the same crap. Hell, it makes wolves look MORE village because they can get all pissy about fishing.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Yeah, but that gives literally everyone else an excuse to pull the same crap. Hell, it makes wolves look MORE village because they can get all pissy about fishing.

I really shouldn't be able to override ideas just because I say I'm not interested. That's a groupthink issue.

 

[PippyPony]

Sorry for the grumpy post explosion; I strongly dislike losing and particularly don't like it when I feel like I am a major contributing factor. But I also feel like I can't operate optimally with the kind of cagey-ness and silence that is prevalent these days. And I think it is way less fun. Grumpity grump.

Plus I might be a little hangry + tired. I should probably eat something and go to bed lol

 

[PippyPony]

I really shouldn't be able to override ideas just because I say I'm not interested. That's a groupthink issue.

This is a world with groupthink problems, AM -- don't get me started on real life examples of this same stuff.

Edit: I should definitely eat a snack and go to bed haha

 

[Animal Midwife]

This is a world with groupthink problems, AM -- don't get me started on real life examples of this same stuff.

Edit: I should definitely eat a snack and go to bed haha

Thank you for more depressing real life lessons Pippy

 

[SARdoghandler]

She seems to just be letting me vote for her without resistance and I don't understand why.

Ive learned through many lynches that if I respond to one or two votes on me it'll get me lynched because I'm "too defensive". So I tend to let one or two votes lie unless they give reasoning I can respond to. Which you never do.

Also I've watched you consistently vote for the same person religiously in previous games and even if that person pusbes back you don't tend to move. So idk I try not to be reactionary and wasn't sure pushing you about your vote would actually be a useful endeavour. If I had been around for lynch today I likely would have because that was a closer lynch than I'm comfortable with