M.D. vs. D.N.P.

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, like the doctors of osteopath can attest to, if DNP become aligned more to medicine, with a background in hard sciences, and the equivalent residency, DNP's stand a greater chance.

DO's came to call themselves equal after they changed their curriculum (OMM comprises only a tiny fraction of the curriculum, all else being identical), had a similar application system and entrance exam, 4 years of school, and the same residencies. Do you know how long that gradual change took? Well over 100 years. You'll still find older MDs (and premeds on SDN) that think that DOs are chiropractic witch doctors.

DNP is realistically not a viable degree if nurses aim to one day claim it as an equivalent degree. It's just not worth the time or energy. If you want become a physician and care for patients in the same capacity, it will be much easier to just go to an MD/DO school. In fact, most DOs will still advise you to go MD to save yourself the headache.
 
😆
Frankly, I think the majority of you are self-glorified arseholes. My plan is to finish with DNP, which for the record will be a practicing diagnostic doctorate, and not a theoretical Ph.D. The success or capability of a DNP or MD is not a matter of program, hours, or clinical path alone. A lot of it has to do with an individual's intelligence and innate analytical ability. There are plenty of stupid MDs in America. Being a book worm, or able to study like no-one's bussiness does not somehow make you a God. I did 2 years of Bio, 2 years of Chem, 1 of Physics, finished Pre-Calculus, and had a near perfect SAT score in HIGH SCHOOL. Need I go into details of where I started college with my multiple AP courses? I also did my boyfriend's Med. School applications, which according to several interviews was his saving grace. He is now finishing his 3rd year, thanks, in part, to me. So why DNP and not MD? Because being an MD is not only considered one of the most stressful career choices, but because I will walk pretty in my Louboutin heels as an R.N. without the $250k in debt. And when my hospital pays for the post-graduate degrees, it sure makes it easy to save up and open my own clinic. Am I going to be a surgeon? No, but I don't need to cut anyone open. Am I going to make just as much money with a wellness and dermatology center? Oh you bet your dimes I will. A smart "doctor" doesn't need to waste half of their life paying for a white coat. Lets be honest, 90% of patients do not care what your title is as long as you are capable of performing the job.

LOL 😆 😆
 
DO's came to call themselves equal after they changed their curriculum (OMM comprises only a tiny fraction of the curriculum, all else being identical), had a similar application system and entrance exam, 4 years of school, and the same residencies. Do you know how long that gradual change took? Well over 100 years. You'll still find older MDs (and premeds on SDN) that think that DOs are chiropractic witch doctors.

DNP is realistically not a viable degree if nurses aim to one day claim it as an equivalent degree. It's just not worth the time or energy. If you want become a physician and care for patients in the same capacity, it will be much easier to just go to an MD/DO school. In fact, most DOs will still advise you to go MD to save yourself the headache.

Thanks for the post. As I stated, I'm not looking for equality, rather just a place, other than "mid level". Also, I stated, for my colleagues looking for equivalence, they will need to align to medicine, and it won't happen in my lifetime.
 
Thanks for the post. As I stated, I'm not looking for equality, rather just a place, other than "mid level". Also, I stated, for my colleagues looking for equivalence, they will need to align to medicine, and it won't happen in my lifetime.

Well you're definitely not high level, that's for sure.
 
I am currently working on my Nursing Degree, and in no way do I believe MDs and DNPs are equal, however, once I graduate with my Doctorate in Nursing, I will expect to be addressed as doctor. People with their Doctorate in Education are addressed as Doctor, so, why is it so difficult to address a nurse who is so passionate about their work that they went as high as possible, as Doctor? Again, I do not place DNPs in the same category as an MD, but my hard work will not be belittled due to an MDs inability to recognize an advanced practice DNP. DNPs should be respected on the fact that they have chosen to obtain their Doctorate in the field they love to practice, just as the MD has, regardless of the hours spent getting there.
 
the problem isn't with DNPs in general, it is with DNPs claiming they are equivalent to physicians. And until they can back it up, they shouldn't be saying it. They want to be called doctor in the hospital, and I agree with anegron. It is detrimental to the patient.
How is a DNP being addressed as doctor detrimental to the patient? If the patient needs something that the DOCTOR OF NURSING PRACTICE cannot do, its the same as a BSN RN, "I will get the physician for you". DNPs are not equal to MDs, however, they are still healthcare professionals with advanced education. And as an MD, you should be proud to address a DNP as Doctor because with nurses, whether they be BSN RNs or DNPs, MDs could not do their jobs because they would have to act as the nurse and the doctor. MDs should be proud to have a DNP under them. That shows how much that RN cares about providing care to patients that they want to get as much knowledge of how to do so. Hospitals would be chaotic without nurses, RN or DNP. And quit frankly, MDs would loose their minds without them. Physicians Assistants are Masters Degree level, and they get more respect than DNPs. Why do MDs have such an issue with nurses? Nurses at all levels are constantly putting up with MDs thinking they know it all. You may have a Doctorate in Medicine, but that is all. You know about the body in scientific ways. Nurses know the science and spirit of patients. Nurses are taught these things. So you can find a life threatening illness or condition, the nurse is the one who spends time with the patient while the patient fights it off. MDs say "I'm Sorry" and walk out. They have no emotional support to offer their patients. Nurses do. My rant is over now.
 
How is a DNP being addressed as doctor detrimental to the patient? If the patient needs something that the DOCTOR OF NURSING PRACTICE cannot do, its the same as a BSN RN, "I will get the physician for you". DNPs are not equal to MDs, however, they are still healthcare professionals with advanced education. And as an MD, you should be proud to address a DNP as Doctor because with nurses, whether they be BSN RNs or DNPs, MDs could not do their jobs because they would have to act as the nurse and the doctor. MDs should be proud to have a DNP under them. That shows how much that RN cares about providing care to patients that they want to get as much knowledge of how to do so. Hospitals would be chaotic without nurses, RN or DNP. And quit frankly, MDs would loose their minds without them. Physicians Assistants are Masters Degree level, and they get more respect than DNPs. Why do MDs have such an issue with nurses? Nurses at all levels are constantly putting up with MDs thinking they know it all. You may have a Doctorate in Medicine, but that is all. You know about the body in scientific ways. Nurses know the science and spirit of patients. Nurses are taught these things. So you can find a life threatening illness or condition, the nurse is the one who spends time with the patient while the patient fights it off. MDs say "I'm Sorry" and walk out. They have no emotional support to offer their patients. Nurses do. My rant is over now.

I love this post. I love everything about it. I was having a bad day but now I can't stop laughing. Whoever you are, thank you.
 
Nurses know the science and spirit of patients.

Oh dear. Just as physicians don't have a monopoly on patient care, nurses don't have a monopoly on understanding "the spirit of patients".

Also, it's generally considered poor form to insist on being called Dr. even when you have a doctoral degree outside of the traditional professional circumstances. I cannot tell you how much shade and disdain was thrown toward a high school teacher with a PhD I had who insisted (and had a fit of someone slipped up) on being called Dr. LovesTitles.
 
Oh dear. Just as physicians don't have a monopoly on patient care, nurses don't have a monopoly on understanding "the spirit of patients".

Also, it's generally considered poor form to insist on being called Dr. even when you have a doctoral degree outside of the traditional professional circumstances. I cannot tell you how much shade and disdain was thrown toward a high school teacher with a PhD I had who insisted (and had a fit of someone slipped up) on being called Dr. LovesTitles.
Just playing devils advocate here, but isn't a DNP's professional setting in a hospital? So wouldn't it be okay to call them doctor?
 
How is a DNP being addressed as doctor detrimental to the patient? If the patient needs something that the DOCTOR OF NURSING PRACTICE cannot do, its the same as a BSN RN, "I will get the physician for you". DNPs are not equal to MDs, however, they are still healthcare professionals with advanced education. [...] Why do MDs have such an issue with nurses? Nurses at all levels are constantly putting up with MDs thinking they know it all. You may have a Doctorate in Medicine, but that is all. You know about the body in scientific ways. Nurses know the science and spirit of patients. Nurses are taught these things. So you can find a life threatening illness or condition, the nurse is the one who spends time with the patient while the patient fights it off. MDs say "I'm Sorry" and walk out. They have no emotional support to offer their patients. Nurses do. My rant is over now.

:troll:
 
Just playing devils advocate here, but isn't a DNP's professional setting in a hospital? So wouldn't it be okay to call them doctor?

There is unfortunately a conflict between the tradition of only physicians being called doctor in the healthcare setting and the tradition of calling people with doctoral degrees doctor. I have no idea how to solve it, but I certainly understand the branding issue physicians have with the term doctor when it carries the assumption of a certain (large) amount of training and knowledge and scope of practice in the healthcare setting and the persons wishing to be called doctor in more recent times do not have as much training, knowledge, or as large scope of practice.
 
Just playing devils advocate here, but isn't a DNP's professional setting in a hospital? So wouldn't it be okay to call them doctor?

Yeah everyone is a doctor now a days (DPT, DPM, OD). I think that's why MD/DO's have strayed away from the term and settled with physician.

To me it's all about ego. Do you really want the title doctor simply because you earned it? Or because you want to flaunt it around and have yourself be addressed as such so you can feel "like a real doctor".

Hell, I want my patients, colleagues, and nurses in the future to just call me on a first name basis of "Meow the Magnificent". I mean even the co-chair of neurosurg at my alma mater want's to be called on a first name basis.
 
Yeah everyone is a doctor now a days (DPT, DPM, OD). I think that's why MD/DO's have strayed away from the term and settled with physician.

To me it's all about ego. Do you really want the title doctor simply because you earned it? Or because you want to flaunt it around and have yourself be addressed as such so you can feel "like a real doctor".

Hell, I want my patients, colleagues, and nurses in the future to just call me on a first name basis of "Meow the Magnificent". I mean even the co-chair of neurosurg at my alma mater want's to be called on a first name basis.
I think DPM should not be put in the same category with these other healthcare professionals that want to be called doctors... MD/DO/DPM/DDS/DMD are doctors in healthcare settings...
 
I am currently working on my Nursing Degree, and in no way do I believe MDs and DNPs are equal, however, once I graduate with my Doctorate in Nursing, I will expect to be addressed as doctor. People with their Doctorate in Education are addressed as Doctor, so, why is it so difficult to address a nurse who is so passionate about their work that they went as high as possible, as Doctor? Again, I do not place DNPs in the same category as an MD, but my hard work will not be belittled due to an MDs inability to recognize an advanced practice DNP. DNPs should be respected on the fact that they have chosen to obtain their Doctorate in the field they love to practice, just as the MD has, regardless of the hours spent getting there.

 
Here is something you can do! Find the curriculum of any PA program and compare it to your DNP program, you will understand why PA got more respect...
LOL!!! You do know that you need to be a baccalaureate prepared registered nurse and a Board Certified Advanced Practice Nurse Practitioner before enrolling in a DNP program? Do you know it takes 8-9 years (6-7 of which are from an undergrad/master's degree IN NURSING) and thousands of hours of clinical before you get a DNP? Don't forget that RN's work their way up the ladder, whereas PA's can get a bachelor degree in English/Bio/Chem/BasketWeaving/HealthStudies/etc and throw in some patient contact hours in order to get into a two year Masters Degree program. And on top of that complain that they do "4 years of med school in 2 years". Complete BS! Nurse practitioners come out of school with vast amounts of knowledge and hit the floor running. PA's on the other hand need to be taken under the wing of a physician and be told what to do. I mean you have to have an MD/DO on your prescription pad and you can't open your own practice... Says a lot. Cheers!
 
LOL!!! You do know that you need to be a baccalaureate prepared registered nurse and a Board Certified Advanced Practice Nurse Practitioner before enrolling in a DNP program? Do you know it takes 8-9 years (6-7 of which are from an undergrad/master's degree IN NURSING) and thousands of hours of clinical before you get a DNP? Don't forget that RN's work their way up the ladder, whereas PA's can get a bachelor degree in English/Bio/Chem/BasketWeaving/HealthStudies/etc and throw in some patient contact hours in order to get into a two year Masters Degree program. And on top of that complain that they do "4 years of med school in 2 years". Complete BS! Nurse practitioners come out of school with vast amounts of knowledge and hit the floor running. PA's on the other hand need to be taken under the wing of a physician and be told what to do. I mean you have to have an MD/DO on your prescription pad and you can't open your own practice... Says a lot. Cheers!
why is this being bumped? This topic was discussed 2 years ago.........................................
 
A doctor is a doctor whether or not they're a PhD, EdD, JD, PharmD, DVM, DMD, DDS, DPM, DNP, etc... end of story. I love reminding medical students that most Nurse Practitioners mentor the MD/DO residency students around the country as well, just look at Stony Brook University, for example. NP's are also the head of Rapid Response Teams, Code Blue Teams, Stroke Code Teams, they work in ER/Trauma, Acute/Critical Care, Primary Care, Hospice/Palliative Care, Pain Management, Mother/Baby, Neonatal/Pediatric, Specialty Care, Surgery, Cosmetics/Plastics, Anesthesia, and they're also CNO's, Professors, researchers, and scholars. Oh, and don't forget that without nurses there wouldn't be hospitals... Patient's come to a hospital for 24/7 Nursing Care, after all nurses are the eyes and ears of the doctors, who aren't at the bedside constantly. I really love it when an MD/DO or PA collaborates with us nurses and/or asks us for advice on certain things. I find it quite funny seeing a lot of "medical students" comment with such negativity for nurses on here. When all of us nurses are board certified, some, like me, dual board certified and licensed to practice nursing and are going to school for post grad advanced practice and doctoral degrees. Don't belittle a nurse because one day you medical students and residents will be on the night shift alone... without an attending physician, and you better hope they don't walk out on your during a code or serious event. On another note NP's who have a DNP/PhD/DNS can say "Hi, my name is Dr. Doe" but they must tell patient's that they're a nurse practitioner immediately after or they can be charged with impersonating a medical doctor and legal action will be taken against them. I definitely do not want to be a medical doctor, but you better respect my profession as we respect yours. You don't want to be the doctor that everyone hates and won't work with. Cheers!
 
Last edited:
why is this being bumped? This topic was discussed 2 years ago.........................................
Who cares if it was discussed two years ago... is it a rule that we can't comment on threads from the past? I wasn't on this site 2 years ago..................... Get over it.
 
Nurses running residency programs hahaha

And that's one of the least stupid things said
The most *****ic thing I've seen today is your avatar picture. How unprofessional.
 
The most *****ic thing I've seen today is your avatar picture. How unprofessional.

Guess you haven't encountered a mirror yet
Zing!

P.S. you coming here and trying to spread your nonsense propaganda is what's actually unprofessional. Don't come here and try to sell us your crap. Everyone knows physician assistants get much better training than nps who can easily finish their schooling before age 25. An np is a doctor like dr dre is a doctor except that dr dre doesn't pretend to practice medicine
P.P.S. my avatar owns
 
Last edited:
Guess you haven't encountered a mirror yet
Zing!

P.S. you coming here and trying to spread your nonsense propaganda is what's actually unprofessional. Don't come here and try to sell us your crap. Everyone knows physician assistants get much better training than nps who can easily finish their schooling before age 25. An np is a doctor like dr dre is a doctor except that dr dre doesn't pretend to practice medicine
P.P.S. my avatar owns

Hah... Propaganda? You're a disgrace to the healthcare professions. You clearly don't know what you're talking about. You seem quite uneducated. Please cite your references about NP's before making false statements. Have a good day!
 
Last edited:
@Psai I like your avatar so much I stole it, forever stored in the annals of my hard drive.
@CL87 That's annals, not anal. I'm presupposing your supposition of a supine penetration of a suppository like sensation.
 
Guess you haven't encountered a mirror yet
Zing!

My coffee went out my nose when I read that.

But seriously, you need to respect the rigor of NP training so I'll talk about the most rigorous one in my state.

First of all, you have to have a year of critical care experience. That can mean lots of things, like working at a busy trauma hospital or working night shift at a small community hospital that keeps people in the ICU that would just be on telemetry at any normal place. I've met several who've gotten the year done working part time in fast track in the ER while taking the courses for the BSN.

Then they have to go through the grueling application process of...filling out the application. But I mean...you have to spell you're name right and everything. You also might have to take the GRE, unless you have a GPA above 3.0 overall in which case it's an auto accept (I know someone who got an auto acceptance >15 minutes after applying because she had a 3.2 GPA. I'm not making this up). Also keep in mind that means if you have Cs in anatomy or general chemistry you can pull it up by having As in courses like "Transitioning into the role of the advanced nursing warlock", and "The Leadership requirements of asking what an abnormal lab value means" and still get that auto accept.

Then there's the grueling coursework. Online discussion boards, unproctored tests, and research papers about following algorithms in uncomplicated ideal patients to get the same results as those fools arrogant enough to call themselves doctors even though they don't have a DNP degree. They're only allowed to fail (with a D) 4 classes in the whole program to still pass. For finals, they have to go to a testing center for the true test of their mettle: a 150 question test that's multiple choice, with only open book, notes, and printed off PowerPoint slides. No google! With only 6 hours to go through all those pages, you don't even wanna see the paper cuts you get from flipping back and forth.

But didactics aren't everything guys. There's also clinical education. You know how long it takes to find a doctor (the outdated kind with an MD/DO degree) that agrees to fill out the form and won't be mean? Hours! After that grueling shadowing experience where you may or may not ever see your own patients, congrats you're an NP! You don't practice medicine, you practice advanced nursing magic. Obviously better. That's why the vast majority over treat, over image, and over refer--because their over doctors.

I respect nurses, but NP education is garbage and the only people that don't admit it are NPs. Most nurses that have worked with NPs and PAs (and aren't considering going NP) will tell you that PAs stomp all over them.
 
A doctor is a doctor whether or not they're a PhD, EdD, JD, PharmD, DVM, DMD, DDS, DPM, DNP, etc... end of story. I love reminding medical students that most Nurse Practitioners mentor the MD/DO residency students around the country as well, just look at Stony Brook University, for example. NP's are also the head of Rapid Response Teams, Code Blue Teams, Stroke Code Teams, they work in ER/Trauma, Acute/Critical Care, Primary Care, Hospice/Palliative Care, Pain Management, Mother/Baby, Neonatal/Pediatric, Specialty Care, Surgery, Cosmetics/Plastics, Anesthesia, and they're also CNO's, Professors, researchers, and scholars. Oh, and don't forget that without nurses there wouldn't be hospitals... Patient's come to a hospital for 24/7 Nursing Care, after all nurses are the eyes and ears of the doctors, who aren't at the bedside constantly. I really love it when an MD/DO or PA collaborates with us nurses and/or asks us for advice on certain things. I find it quite funny seeing a lot of "medical students" comment with such negativity for nurses on here. When all of us nurses are board certified, some, like me, dual board certified and licensed to practice nursing and are going to school for post grad advanced practice and doctoral degrees. Don't belittle a nurse because one day you medical students and residents will be on the night shift alone... without an attending physician, and you better hope they don't walk out on your during a code or serious event. On another note NP's who have a DNP/PhD/DNS can say "Hi, my name is Dr. Doe" but they must tell patient's that they're a nurse practitioner immediately after or they can be charged with impersonating a medical doctor and legal action will be taken against them. I definitely do not want to be a medical doctor, but you better respect my profession as we respect yours. You don't want to be the doctor that everyone hates and won't work with. Cheers!
My sister is a NP (at a Stony affiliate actually). She talks about how when residents start in July, they flop around and the nurses get a kick out of it. Then by the end of the year she says how proud she is of the "babies" and how impressed she is by how much more they can do/know. She said that she will never be able to do what a MD does nor would she ever want the level of responsibility that a MD does (which makes sense, if she wanted the knowledge and scope of practice as a MD she would have gone to med school). NPs are valuable, but their knowledge is more limited than that of a MD. Recognizing a difference in education =/= belittling. MDs should acknowledge the expertise of NPs, just as NPs should recognize where their expertise ends and the expertise of a MD comes in- it is a two-way street

If a NP is so petty that they would walk out on a code to spite a doctor, they do not belong in the health field. It would be extremely immature to risk a patient's life because of a tantrum.

Why do you find it funny that MDs collaborate with NPs? We are a healthcare team. We are supposed to consult each other! Would you prefer for MDs to completely ignore NPs? You can't have effective healthcare without effective communication, so kudos to the MDs for having the maturity to work well on a team.

As for the NPs calling themselves doctors, I don't care. But I do think it can cause unneccesary confusion for patients
 
I don't think that many people realize how much pressure is on doctors and PA's to keep up to date on information for their continuing certification. As someone eloquently put it, one of the reasons why PAs might "smash" an NP out of the water is because they need to constantly study information in various fields in order to pass PANRE. Doctors have specialty boards that they also retake every ten years. For PAs they are required to have in-depth knowledge on all sub-specialties and not just their own. The exams are notoriously known for getting harder every iteration which is why there are many popular prep materials: Lange's PA Review Series, CME4LIFE, etc. As far as I'm aware NP's just need to log in the required CME courses needed. PA's need to do CME and also pass PANRE in order to maintain their position. Doctors take an exam [Step 1] at the end of their second year which could potentially dictate their entire life regardless of how they complete the last two years of school. It's not just the NP curriculum on the first-go basis that potentially causes a discrepancy in shelf knowledge but also the comparative need between the three professions on how much time goes into reviewing and keeping up to date with clinical information.
 
A doctor is a doctor whether or not they're a PhD, EdD, JD, PharmD, DVM, DMD, DDS, DPM, DNP, etc... end of story. I love reminding medical students that most Nurse Practitioners mentor the MD/DO residency students around the country as well, just look at Stony Brook University, for example. NP's are also the head of Rapid Response Teams, Code Blue Teams, Stroke Code Teams, they work in ER/Trauma, Acute/Critical Care, Primary Care, Hospice/Palliative Care, Pain Management, Mother/Baby, Neonatal/Pediatric, Specialty Care, Surgery, Cosmetics/Plastics, Anesthesia, and they're also CNO's, Professors, researchers, and scholars. Oh, and don't forget that without nurses there wouldn't be hospitals... Patient's come to a hospital for 24/7 Nursing Care, after all nurses are the eyes and ears of the doctors, who aren't at the bedside constantly. I really love it when an MD/DO or PA collaborates with us nurses and/or asks us for advice on certain things. I find it quite funny seeing a lot of "medical students" comment with such negativity for nurses on here. When all of us nurses are board certified, some, like me, dual board certified and licensed to practice nursing and are going to school for post grad advanced practice and doctoral degrees. Don't belittle a nurse because one day you medical students and residents will be on the night shift alone... without an attending physician, and you better hope they don't walk out on your during a code or serious event. On another note NP's who have a DNP/PhD/DNS can say "Hi, my name is Dr. Doe" but they must tell patient's that they're a nurse practitioner immediately after or they can be charged with impersonating a medical doctor and legal action will be taken against them. I definitely do not want to be a medical doctor, but you better respect my profession as we respect yours. You don't want to be the doctor that everyone hates and won't work with. Cheers!
See you in the physician lounge!😛
 
Might be helpful. After all @Psai has a better understanding of the BSN/MSN/DNP pathway than the person whose supposedly pursuing it.

I've taken nursing classes (joke). Dated someone taking nursing classes (joke). Saw what a bsn degree actually entails (lots of bs writing assignments about how great nurses are). Looked at requirements for dnp (joke)

What do you bring to the table kiddo?

The people who are the most gungho about being a dnp are the students who want to be one or just started. I've seen what people actually in the programs say about it on allnurses and it's very unimpressive. Their understanding of pathophysiology is unimpressive. Their patient care is unimpressive. Just unimpressive overall
 
LOL!!! You do know that you need to be a baccalaureate prepared registered nurse and a Board Certified Advanced Practice Nurse Practitioner before enrolling in a DNP program? Do you know it takes 8-9 years (6-7 of which are from an undergrad/master's degree IN NURSING) and thousands of hours of clinical before you get a DNP? Don't forget that RN's work their way up the ladder, whereas PA's can get a bachelor degree in English/Bio/Chem/BasketWeaving/HealthStudies/etc and throw in some patient contact hours in order to get into a two year Masters Degree program. And on top of that complain that they do "4 years of med school in 2 years". Complete BS! Nurse practitioners come out of school with vast amounts of knowledge and hit the floor running. PA's on the other hand need to be taken under the wing of a physician and be told what to do. I mean you have to have an MD/DO on your prescription pad and you can't open your own practice... Says a lot. Cheers!

🙄:bullcrap:

Makes me wonder what some of my undergrad classmates did to get accepted to DNP programs straight out of undergrad without ever working as a RN, or some of the nurses I worked with prior to med school who were accepted into DNP programs with only a few months of working on a general med/surg floor in a small community hospital....

I also worked with a nurse who after finishing a 2 year AA in nursing, did a several month RN to BSN program online, then applied and was accepted to a (primarily online) DNP program. Its been ~8 years since I took calc, but I'm pretty sure that adds up to just under 3 years, not 6-7.

Also, DNPs fall under the category of advance practice nurse i.e., its not a pre-req to be admitted into a DNP program

So at this point you're either a) a troll or b) grossly misinformed about your own field.

I have the utmost respect for nurses, so long as they reciprocate. My wife is a nurse, and both she and a number of her classmates from nursing school are very outspoken about what a joke nursing and DNP education is. She has considered the possibility of becoming a mid level and looked pretty extensively into DNP and PA programs. If she ever went back to school she’d go the PA route hands down due to higher and more consistent standards, education, and training.
 
Last edited:
I've taken nursing classes (joke). Dated someone taking nursing classes (joke). Saw what a bsn degree actually entails (lots of bs writing assignments about how great nurses are). Looked at requirements for dnp (joke) What do you bring to the table kiddo? The people who are the most gungho about being a dnp are the students who want to be one or just started. I've seen what people actually in the programs say about it on allnurses and it's very unimpressive. Their understanding of pathophysiology is unimpressive. Their patient care is unimpressive. Just unimpressive overall
I made that statement at face value.
 
🙄:bullcrap:

Makes me wonder what some of my undergrad classmates did to get accepted to DNP programs straight out of undergrad without ever working as a RN, or some of the nurses I worked with prior to med school who were accepted into DNP programs with only a few months of working on a general med/surg floor in a small community hospital....

I also worked with a nurse who after finishing a 2 year AA in nursing, did a several month RN to BSN program online, then applied and was accepted to a (primarily online) DNP program. Its been ~8 years since I took calc, but I'm pretty sure that adds up to just under 3 years, not 6-7.

I have the utmost respect for nurses, so long as they reciprocate. My wife is a nurse, and both she and a number of her classmates from nursing school are very outspoken about what a joke nursing and DNP education is. She has considered the possibility of becoming a mid level and looked pretty extensively into DNP and PA programs. If she ever went back to school she’d go the PA route hands down due to higher and more consistent standards, education, and training.

I know, he said that and I was like "uh no."

Same here. My wife is pretty outspoken when she talks about DNPs and stuff. While some NP programs are actually fairly good at training their students for working in a mid-level environment DNP programs are a complete joke. She even told me the other day to never let a CRNA do her anesthesia in case she can't consent for some reason. A lot of nurses are really good at what they do and a great asset to the hospital and doctors they work with, it is unfortunate that some of their leadership and other nurses are so ridiculous. They give the rest a bad name
 
A doctor is a doctor whether or not they're a PhD, EdD, JD, PharmD, DVM, DMD, DDS, DPM, DNP, etc... end of story. Just look at Stony Brook University, for example. NP's are also the head of Rapid Response Teams, Code Blue Teams, Stroke Code Teams, they work in ER/Trauma, Acute/Critical...

When all of us nurses are board certified, some, like me, dual board certified and licensed to practice nursing
and are going to school for post grad advanced practice and doctoral degrees.

Don't belittle a nurse because one day you medical students and residents will be on the night shift alone... without an attending physician, and you better hope they don't walk out on your during a code or serious event.

I definitely do not want to be a medical doctor, but you better respect my profession as we respect yours. You don't want to be the doctor that everyone hates and won't work with. Cheers!

I have a few points:
1) Oh I have seen some of these NPs heading the RRT and code teams (at a very well regarded hospital). It is an unmitigated disaster. Anything beyond the simplest thing gets a consult to cardiology. On the cardiology side, we won't allow them to run our RRTs or code teams.

2) Oh you're board certified? You went to medical school and residency and passed some specialty board? Yeah you're not board certified. You may be licenesed or certified but not board certified. Don't act like something you're not, especially to a board of real doctors and doctors in training. I myself am REALLY dual board certified. But thanks for playing.

3) This has nothing to do with bedside nurses and everything to do with NPs thinking they have the skill and training to be the leader of the team. Almost everyday I am reminded that they clearly do not- this is also in a very well known place which would bring the best and brightest of the NP world. Can they work well within their scope- definitely. However I think our ideas differ on what the correct scope of practice should be.

4) Respect must be earned. As a whole the lax entry requirements, multiple fluff courses, the online coursework , and very few clinical hours do not lend itself to respect of the NP or DNP- especially from someone who has spent literally 10x the amount of hours in training that an NP does. Some NPs will get my respect with their work product. Many will not.
 
🙄:bullcrap:

Makes me wonder what some of my undergrad classmates did to get accepted to DNP programs straight out of undergrad without ever working as a RN, or some of the nurses I worked with prior to med school who were accepted into DNP programs with only a few months of working on a general med/surg floor in a small community hospital....

I also worked with a nurse who after finishing a 2 year AA in nursing, did a several month RN to BSN program online, then applied and was accepted to a (primarily online) DNP program. Its been ~8 years since I took calc, but I'm pretty sure that adds up to just under 3 years, not 6-7.

Also, DNPs fall under the category of advance practice nurse i.e., its not a pre-req to be admitted into a DNP program

So at this point you're either a) a troll or b) grossly misinformed about your own field.

I have the utmost respect for nurses, so long as they reciprocate. My wife is a nurse, and both she and a number of her classmates from nursing school are very outspoken about what a joke nursing and DNP education is. She has considered the possibility of becoming a mid level and looked pretty extensively into DNP and PA programs. If she ever went back to school she’d go the PA route hands down due to higher and more consistent standards, education, and training.

Good floor (and ICU) nurses are worth their weight in gold.

Unfortunately so many of them are just biding their time til they get accepted to NP/CRNA school. It's a horrible brain drain.
 
@Ho0v-man

What?! Are you really putting all Nurse Practitioners in one category, based on what seems like your little experience and bizarre interactions from within your state? What state are you in? I've never heard anything of the sort.


First of all, BSN nurses need at least one year of nursing experience in the field of study they choose to pursue (i.e. Pediatrics, Critical Care, ER/Trauma, Medical/Surgical, Anesthesia, Psych, Mother/Baby, Neonatal, etc…). It’s not solely based on critical care experience, although that would be nice, it just makes no sense.


If you get below a B+ in any subject in my NP program (in New York) you’ll get kicked out. The ANCC and AANP board certification accredited agencies DO NOT allow any paper work or open book nonsense that you’ve described above.


Associate degree RN’s, who are working towards their BSN have taken most of their clinical rotations and classes already including, chem 101, bio 101, English 101, psych 101, soc 101, physiological chem, anatomy and phys 1 and 2, microbiology, pathophysiology, pharmacology, and etc. But like YOUR undergrad bachelor degree, and ALL other undergrad degrees (thanks to our ancient Greek friends) we must take liberal arts classes; like history, math, music/art, gym, and more philosophical nursing courses in leadership, health promotion and patient education, community health, research, and so on. I’m not going to lie, some of it was complete BS, but interesting in itself.


The fact that you talk down about a fellow health care profession is quite honestly deplorable. Nursing’s scope of practice is very different than that of medicine; actually, it’s completely different and not comparable. The BSN focuses more on leadership, management, research, and education. Licensed registered nurses already know, or should know, what lab values, medication treatment, and technical skills required to do their job.


Nurses do not truly learn medicine until their Masters education begins. But kudos to those nurses who had to work part time/full time while in school, who probably had to ensure their priorities were in order, like for example, raising a family, a mortgage to worry about paying, or even if they wanted to simply pay out of pocket for their schooling. I’m proud of them and their ambitious endeavor to better themselves while also helping to facilitate the movement towards professionalization in nursing!


Then after at least one year of experience, (almost no one gets accepted into the program with only ONE year of experience) you get to graduate school. There you’ll have to submit three letters of recommendation from nurse leaders, physicians, or other nurse practitioners. You’ll also need to write a five-page paper that includes all of the following below;


“The mission of the School of Nursing is to provide accessible, high quality undergraduate and graduate education to diverse student populations for the development of nurse leaders at all entries of practice. The mission will be accomplished through:

• Innovative programs that reflect the needs and current trends in healthcare of neighboring communities and the wider geographic regions;

• Provision of state-of-the-art healthcare and serve as a resource to the surrounding and global communities;

• Research that advances the scientific and theoretical foundations of nursing.


The essay question or personal response, needs to address the following topics:

• Discuss the personal qualities and attributes that you think will be useful as well as those that you feel need further development in preparation for the nursing profession.

• Provide your own definition of cultural competence, ethical sensitivity, leadership and life-long learning as well as how you may incorporate these concepts in your professional practice.

• Discuss how a graduate education in nursing will impact your future career goals.”


Then go through an extensive interview process because Stony Brook University is one of the top ranking universities in the world and they only accept the best of the best. The university gets around 34,110 applications a year and only 13,981 were accepted.

Here’s the link if you don’t believe me, http://www.stonybrook.edu/sb/fastfacts/



We’re also recommended to continue working as RN’s, so that we keep learning and growing as a profession. So we can take a part time or full time route but the program must be completed within 5 years. Just look up the NP programs at Stony Brook and what they require... You most definitely cannot compare our program to med school and residency but it’s not easy. Then after taking 46-56 credits and graduating we can sit for our national board certification and hopefully pass the first time.


After we pass our exam we can either work for a few years or go back for our doctoral degrees; write another big essay, and more interviewing, along with 42 more credits of doctoral work, clinical hours, and handing in an evidence based clinical project and which requires tireless hours of research, which will take about another 3-5 years to complete. But I think you get the point… I’m done writing everything out. But please do look up the requirements for the NP -DNP/PhD program at Stony Brook University as it’s quite intense, but again, not as intense as medical school, I’ll give you that!


All I know is that nurses need doctors like doctors need nurses, whether in the advanced practice role or as a floor nurse. Our education goes way beyond what you falsely describe in your failed attempt to belittle nurse practitioners. There is evidence based studies and journals out there that show positive patient outcomes based on the role of a nurse practitioner and that they can provide just as effective care as a physician.


I would never slander a medical doctor, even if they were horrible and made the profession look bad. You shouldn’t let your opinions of the select few incidences you've "heard of" or encountered define the profession as a whole. If nurse practitioner's weren't doing so well then I'm sure our malpractice insurance would be higher than $1500-$1700/year and the IOM would have nurse practitioners discontinued and relieved of their duties to practice medicine. After all it was MD's who initiated the start of the NP program in the 1960’s due to the great health care disparities among our nation that we’re seeing again now.


All in all I do agree that NP programs should require more clinical hours and most definitely a residency type program, but NP's, well most of them, are not idiots. I know many NP's who are well respected by physicians and other medical professions.


I've personally worked with some of the most fragile and sickest patients in New York. My five years of experience in ER/Trauma, ICU/CCU/PICU, Cardiac/Stroke and Hospice specialties have really prepared me to move up in the nursing profession. I also think the education that is afforded to us is what we make of it. I plan on reading vast amounts of medical journals and studying along side other NP’s, PA’s, medical students, and physicians who I call my friends and colleagues.
 
@Instatewaiter

Thank you for your personal "opinions"! But research says different! NP's can be just as good as doctors in certain respects. Please see the article below.


http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2015/07/when-a-nurse-is-as-good-as-a-doctor/index.htm


Moving on... I am DUAL BOARD CERTIFIED by nationally accredited agencies, once by the NCLEX and the other by the ANCC and I'm only a baccalaureate prepared registered nurse! Who would have thought?! I'm currently working on two more board certifications in Emergency Medicine Nursing and Hospice/Palliative Nursing as we speak while in grad school! You do not need to be a physician to be board certified...

Secondly I'll be taking another board certification by the ANCC or AANP as an advanced practice nurse in family practice, then getting a DEA#, prescription privileges, and a second license to practice medicine as an APRN. Whoa!!

Then onto another Post Masters Certificate in Adult/Gerontology Acute Care Nurse Practitioner (AGACNP-BC) to Doctorate in Nursing Practice (DNP) where I will take my 6th and 7th board certifications through the ANCC/AANP.

Isn't that just amazing?! The amount of learning and knowledge we gain through education is just mind blowing! That's why I love the medical field! All of those degrees, board certifications, and with barely any school loans to pay off at the end because our hospitals pay for us to go back to school! Not trying to brag or but I'm already making 6 figures as an RN and live very comfortably on my own as a young guy in my late 20's. I love that I chose the nursing profession and with nursing the job possibilities are endless!

I don't mind working alongside or below a physician. I absolutely love and respect them, as they've taught me soooooo much throughout my nursing career. I'm lucky enough to call these amazing physicians, NP's, and PA's my colleagues. I wouldn't be the nurse I am today without them, that's for sure!

Have a great day!
 
@Walter Lance

I'm sure that when you add up all the degrees, a 4 year undergrad, plus 2-3 years masters, then 2-3 years doctoral program you get more than that. I'm sorry you needed to take calculus in order to get simple elementary math.

As far as a DNP not having any pre-requisite you're absolutely wrong... so please educate yourself on the topic. You must be an Advanced Practice Nurse or enroll in a BS-DNP (meaning they acquire an MS in an advanced practice role while in the program and graduate with two degrees) or MS -DNP. Don't tell me I don't know my own profession. You don't see me rambling off about what physicians can and cannot do.

Oh, and good for your wife! That's a great way to advance the professionalization of nursing, not! Go become a PA, it'll be like a slap in the face to the nursing profession. Although she'd actually be a great PA with her undergrad in nursing. 🙂

Although our profession has it's issues so do the medical doctors and many others. For example, we must do "Time Out's" and fill out a checklist before we let a physician do any type of procedure or surgery on a patient because they make/made mistakes, like so many humans do, and remove the wrong body part or organ, and perform surgeries/procedures on the wrong patient. Nurses make mistakes too, they might give the wrong medication whether it be the wrong dose, med, time, route, or patient.

Thanks for your response.
 
Last edited:
@Mansamusa

I agree with you wholeheartedly. I would never walk out on a patient coding and leave anyone to run a code on their own. That's just down right deplorable. I meant more of a what-if scenario. I've heard it happening, I kid you not.

I never said I find it funny that MD/DO's collaborate with NP's I actually said I love it. I did say and I quote "I find it quite funny seeing a lot of "medical students" comment with such negativity for nurses on here." Hope that clarifies that for you. 🙂

I am all for effective communication between nurse and physician. I would never jeopardize the safety and well-being of my patient because of petty or unprofessional misconduct by any profession. Above all my patient comes first and nothing gets in between my practice and the care I give my patients.
 
@Instatewaiter

Thank you for your personal "opinions"! But research says different! NP's can be just as good as doctors in certain respects. Please see the article below.


http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2015/07/when-a-nurse-is-as-good-as-a-doctor/index.htm


Moving on... I am DUAL BOARD CERTIFIED by nationally accredited agencies, once by the NCLEX and the other by the ANCC and I'm only a baccalaureate prepared registered nurse! Who would have thought?! I'm currently working on two more board certifications in Emergency Medicine Nursing and Hospice/Palliative Nursing as we speak while in grad school! You do not need to be a physician to be board certified...

Secondly I'll be taking another board certification by the ANCC or AANP as an advanced practice nurse in family practice, then getting a DEA#, prescription privileges, and a second license to practice medicine as an APRN. Whoa!!

Then onto another Post Masters Certificate in Adult/Gerontology Acute Care Nurse Practitioner (AGACNP-BC) to Doctorate in Nursing Practice (DNP) where I will take my 6th and 7th board certifications through the ANCC/AANP.

Isn't that just amazing?! The amount of learning and knowledge we gain through education is just mind blowing! That's why I love the medical field! All of those degrees, board certifications, and with barely any school loans to pay off at the end because our hospitals pay for us to go back to school! Not trying to brag or but I'm already making 6 figures as an RN and live very comfortably on my own as a young guy in my late 20's. I love that I chose the nursing profession and with nursing the job possibilities are endless!

I don't mind working alongside or below a physician. I absolutely love and respect them, as they've taught me soooooo much throughout my nursing career. I'm lucky enough to call these amazing physicians, NP's, and PA's my colleagues. I wouldn't be the nurse I am today without them, that's for sure!

Have a great day!

Nclex as board certification hahaha
The fact that you can have all these degrees and "board certifications" with minimal time and effort shows how worthless they are. Board certification for a physician actually means something. For a nurse, it's just a few more letters for that alphabet soup behind their name

The reason that a nursing program would kick you out for a b+ is because you have to be impressively bad to get anything less than an a
 
Last edited:
@Instatewaiter

Thank you for your personal "opinions"! But research says different! NP's can be just as good as doctors in certain respects. Please see the article below. http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2015/07/when-a-nurse-is-as-good-as-a-doctor/index.htm

Moving on... I am DUAL BOARD CERTIFIED by nationally accredited agencies, once by the NCLEX and the other by the ANCC and I'm only a baccalaureate prepared registered nurse! Who would have thought?! I'm currently working on two more board certifications in Emergency Medicine Nursing and Hospice/Palliative Nursing as we speak while in grad school! You do not need to be a physician to be board certified...

Secondly I'll be taking another board certification by the ANCC or AANP as an advanced practice nurse in family practice, then getting a DEA#, prescription privileges, and a second license to practice medicine as an APRN. Whoa!!

Then onto another Post Masters Certificate in Adult/Gerontology Acute Care Nurse Practitioner (AGACNP-BC) to Doctorate in Nursing Practice (DNP) where I will take my 6th and 7th board certifications through the ANCC/AANP.

Research says different you say... so you post a consumer reports article. That in no way makes me doubt your credibility. What, was there nothing on the Huffington Post? Was the National Enquirer out of NP articles? Perhaps next time you post a real, peer reviewed journal article from a reputable journal to support a claim. This isn't allnurses.

Next, passing the NCLEX does not mean you are board certified. It means you have passed a basic level to call yourself an RN and can be licensed as such. Similarly, an intern who has finished medical school and passed Step 1, 2CK, 2CS and 3 is not QUADRUPLE board certified. They're not even board eligible because board certified actually means something more than passing a single exam.

Next let's compare what board certiication entails from ABEM vs ANCC:
Real EM board certification- 3-4 FULL years of a dedicated residency in emergency medication through the ABEM. This isn't part time schooling where you work and take some classes. It is beyond what most would consider full time work (60 hours/week). In the end they rack up an EXTRA 9,000-12,000 dedicated EM hours which is on TOP of the 5,000 or so in just medical school alone. In addition, they spend hours every week in dedicated didactics which are required by the ABEM. Finally, once this is completed, they are allowed to sit for the ABEM board certification exam and if they pass, can call themselves board certified.

EM by the ANCC- This entails sending in a CV and some clinical vignettes and getting 1 evaluation by a supervisor. Not kidding, that's it. No exam, no didactic requirement, no hour requirment, no residency. Just a portfolio. And then boom, you're certified. That is downright scary and probably explains my experience with NPs in the ED.

Next look at the rest of the "board certifications" by the ANCC. They entail proving you've taken coursework which would be part of any masters prepared NP and passing an exam. No extra training, just passing an exam. That is scary! I can't just sit for the cardiac surgery boards and boom be a cardiac surgeon- I need the appropriate 5-7 years of clinical training to be a cardiac surgeon and THEN pass the exam.

Again, this isn't directed at nurses in general nor at good NPs. It is directed at the people who want to act like they have the skills and knowledge without actually getting the training and putting in the work.
 
It won't be that long before NP start demanding 'equal pay for equal work' because they are board certified just like physicians. The CRNA militants are already demanding that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top